The Greater Good - Mind Field S2 (Ep 1)

Share
Embed

Comments • 28 662

  • Wemaw 2
    Wemaw 2 Hour ago

    This remembered me about the story of a railroad-worker/controller, sacrificing his son to save more lives like god sacrificing his only son jesus christ to save more lives.

    Link for the story that relates this experiment....m.tvclip.biz/video/fs3rRDWQw5w/video.html
    FYI. I just share this cause this is the 1st thing that comes on my mind.......

  • Constantin Gatej
    Constantin Gatej 3 hours ago

    Michael... you are a total hero. Congratulations for the initiative and for all the work u have done.. This was absolutley amazing.
    What amazes me is the fact that many people thought about this .. but just a you actually materialized the ideea... so.. this was also motivating. Thank you!

  • Carlos Mendoza
    Carlos Mendoza 7 hours ago

    Yo this was so intense!!! So grateful for your work though!

  • Brian Griffin
    Brian Griffin 8 hours ago

    Look on YT for derren brown's PUSHED no ethics board he convinces people to kill

  • David Kang
    David Kang 8 hours ago

    21:28 "No one was in any danger" *yanks door shut*

  • Banzai Banana
    Banzai Banana 11 hours ago

    heres my view: if both groups both know they shouldnt be on the track, then pull. If only the group of 5 knows they shouldnt be on track, dont pull. If only the one person knows, pull. If niether know, pull.

  • thelegend killer74
    thelegend killer74 14 hours ago

    It was hard to watch people go through this this is terrible but still love it

  • Max Anderson
    Max Anderson 15 hours ago

    It's just a social experiment bro, calm down man!

  • Jonas Pönwalter
    Jonas Pönwalter 16 hours ago

    I gotta say those attention warnings would seem very fishy to me, as well as the workers, who shouldn't be on track when a trains coming and seem to be blind, as well as deaf.

  • Tyler Kimberling
    Tyler Kimberling 16 hours ago

    I really don't wanna be rude but, cory does have some sort of mental disability right. It was just subtle enough to not be sure.

  • Lava master
    Lava master 16 hours ago

    I already doubted it because these reactions from the subjects seemed faked AF, but this proves it
    the lever is already down at track 2 before he pulls it in this shot 27:23
    Really disappointed in Vsauce, I thought your intention was to educate people not deceive them

  • Conor D
    Conor D 19 hours ago

    I'd let it kill the 5 because the dude on the other track knows the train isn't coming his way while the other 5 do. Let natural selection do its work. Also, as soon as you pull that lever..that one guys death is your fault.

  • Olivia Kiggins
    Olivia Kiggins 19 hours ago

    Jeremy bentham said "the greatest good for the greatest number" There ya go
    And befor you reply to this calling me a smart Alec... I learnt that and other trollie problems in RP/RME

  • Karate Karat
    Karate Karat 20 hours ago

    Kill anyone on tracks lol, shouldn’t be there

  • Anonymous Entity
    Anonymous Entity 21 hour ago

    Micheal: Hey! J.R, my name is Michael
    J.R: Hey! Im J.R
    *Michael: Yes i know u dum fuk*

  • Anonymous Entity
    Anonymous Entity 21 hour ago

    I was wondering if changing the track while the train was right over the joint it would run into the wheels and jam the train to an immediate stop

  • Rawbeard
    Rawbeard 21 hour ago

    huh, so this is this YT Red? it seems to be finally available over here. man, this is not late at all.

  • michael cruz
    michael cruz 23 hours ago

    1:23 Stranger things?

  • Sujeidy V
    Sujeidy V Day ago

    H.,,kKix,zozkixoxkicxzozixoix

  • Israel
    Israel Day ago

    One of the takers didn’t show any emotions, didn’t freeze, he just laid down, did nothing and blamed others....a potential psychopath?

  • Israel
    Israel Day ago

    I bet the last guy will nightmare it for while even thou he knows it was a test

  • João Rodrigo
    João Rodrigo Day ago

    Just flip it back and forth, rail noises or train derailing would warn everyone there

  • devyn coleman
    devyn coleman Day ago

    I cried on the intro

  • project zorgo fan

    hello

  • William Zhao
    William Zhao Day ago

    I would pull the lever in the middle so the 6 people can share the hurtling train.

  • Руслан Мамедов

    Идиотизм.

  • Igor Ilic
    Igor Ilic Day ago

    Has enyone noticed a psychopatic behaviour in one of the participantes?

  • Cheewi From The Void

    Can you make a tik tok account?

  • Sara Saric
    Sara Saric Day ago

    pff I'd look for the brake

  • Sky Lord
    Sky Lord Day ago

    The womans face made me cry

  • cruelboii69
    cruelboii69 Day ago

    Drogadicto

  • Alvari Isbani
    Alvari Isbani Day ago

    Poor cory ;(

  • Vinicius Grossmann

    Holy ****, this has been the most interesting video I've seen on TVclip

  • Klugger
    Klugger Day ago

    Idk this guy. But is There people that actually pays to watch his vidéos? Why

  • Bek Slater
    Bek Slater 2 days ago

    Swap the one person for a dog and I’d choose to hit the 5 people any day, without doubt

  • Yasin Çeşmeci
    Yasin Çeşmeci 2 days ago

    Is Micheal dead?

  • please stop the obsession about bts thx

    i would stop the car?

  • firstnsme Lastname
    firstnsme Lastname 2 days ago

    I'm disappointed micheal doesn't walk in to the building and say "Hey Vsauce, micheal here."

  • jatinder saini
    jatinder saini 2 days ago

    Kim jong un will do that trolley experiment for you in real

  • Th3 B4nker
    Th3 B4nker 2 days ago

    This is a terrible experiment. So you put someone that isn't trained that has no affiliation with the company and puts them in a Room because it's hot outside with someone who's working that supposed to be there but he leaves. You have no responsibility and no liability in that Room but as soon as he leaves and you touch something then you assume all responsibility and liability. As soon as you switch it to kill the single person you will liable for that person's death but if you leave it to kill the 5 people and not touch anything it would be on the company.

  • King Slayer
    King Slayer 2 days ago

    The only free episode

  • JaimeG88
    JaimeG88 2 days ago

    Plot twist: they didn't conduct the experiment for the greater good of mankind; they did it for the youtube clicks.

  • Gage Andersen
    Gage Andersen 2 days ago

    The train should just steering around them.

  • Mo'men Osama
    Mo'men Osama 2 days ago

    is it real though?
    www.imdb.com/name/nm5677622/

  • TheUnicornBae
    TheUnicornBae 2 days ago

    I’m sooooooo glad you had the «This is just a test. Everyone is safe» note right before!!!

  • Manuel Gronewold
    Manuel Gronewold 2 days ago

    the 2 who saved lives where crying and in shock which showed alot of Empathy for Strangers and even their Familys . The People who did nothing where laughing in the Interwievs, and did not care for the people. All they wanted was to be out of the Situation.

  • qwerp poiuytre
    qwerp poiuytre 2 days ago

    i love this but I'm concerned about the validity of the female voice and the "object on track" line I would fear it could cause too much change the participants behavior even in that situation.

  • nicholas nicholas paes da silva

    Yea i would let the train go track 1, crossed arms with a smile on my face

  • nicholas nicholas paes da silva

    ALL in the name.... Of science

  • JabbaTheBops
    JabbaTheBops 2 days ago

    I'm more of a Thanos guy so..

  • Joe Bearman
    Joe Bearman 2 days ago

    I prolly would hit every button lol

  • Blue Newt
    Blue Newt 2 days ago

    Am I the only one who sees the terrible visual effects in the rail road videos

  • Timo Hoogendoorn
    Timo Hoogendoorn 2 days ago

    My solution to the trolly problem:
    Keep switching as fast as possible and hope the train goes of the track.

  • Snan
    Snan 2 days ago

    this feels painfully staged...

  • Roy Rosales
    Roy Rosales 2 days ago

    I remember reading about this kind of thought experiment in psychology class, and it was neat to see it actually done. I would be curious to see it performed again, but next time have the one individual on the track be a very close loved one.

  • David French
    David French 2 days ago

    15 minutes of my life has been stolen from me.

  • can i get 5000 subs without any vid

    LMAO the meme

  • 건김
    건김 3 days ago

    If i have to save six people, i would put the lever on the middle.

  • Die Zauberbox
    Die Zauberbox 3 days ago

    End of test.
    Everyone is safe.

  • Rollo Fenrir
    Rollo Fenrir 3 days ago

    These are not enough subjects and you should take them from different backgrounds not all Americans,
    I would have chose the track to stay on 1 because of multiple reasons. One being families are easier to morn when there are others with the same loss.
    2 this could be an incident that shows the lone person that he’s meant to exist, as there was an equal chance of both sides dying. Changing anything is basically changing fate which is wrong.

  • Apricots
    Apricots 3 days ago

    I wanna smash Dr. Judy Ho in 7:23. God she is so hot ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh she's so hot ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh I wanna smash her soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • MNM -
    MNM - 3 days ago

    My first thought was to change positions rapidly to try and derail the train. Quite surprised nobody attempted it.

  • Kyano Vp
    Kyano Vp 3 days ago

    A lost respect for Michael
    And i really don’t want to....
    He’s a good, smart person who did an experiment which is fake
    Because the test subject are actors too!
    It’s very sad to do that just for views Michael😭

  • Mark BERGY Baxter
    Mark BERGY Baxter 3 days ago

    * liberal jewtubes censorship needs to stop*

  • Andy Tang
    Andy Tang 3 days ago

    The subjects were not given any true information to make a valid approval for participating the "real" experiment. How could you experiment on any human subjects without having the subjects' consent to do the "real" experiment on them??? Is it even legal to do human experiment without their consent???

  • Andy Tang
    Andy Tang 3 days ago

    I have been subscribing Vsauce for 8 years, so I am a huge fan for Vsauce! But I got to say that I am still terrified at the post-experimental behaviour of the subjects. They seemed to be way calmer than I had expected. If the experiment was so real that the subjects truly believed that they just "killed" someone regardless of the situation, I think the amount of guilt could be so overwhelming that their reaction, when they realized that it was just a test, would be far more violent.

  • Gamby Hamby
    Gamby Hamby 3 days ago

    Even I was scared out of my mind and I wasn't even there

  • Pretzel Boy
    Pretzel Boy 3 days ago +1

    My BPM were going 120 the whole video. My normal is 63....

  • Insensitive Sensitivity

    Hey V sauce, you just killed someone

  • Scias
    Scias 3 days ago

    4:00 so meta, facing the trolley problem in a sense by trying to set up the trolley problem experiment

  • Doodad
    Doodad 3 days ago

    This is literally the only good TVclip premium show

  • Karin Gutenbrunner Byom

    I would immediately hire this first woman. That's having guts!

  • Filip
    Filip 3 days ago

    My solution: Push the people off the tracks. WTF are they there!?

  • Alex Micu
    Alex Micu 4 days ago

    A psychopath would not touch anything and laugh. Just like me xD

    • Alex Micu
      Alex Micu 3 days ago

      Ye but we don't know if he is a psychopath cause he hid that good. Maybe he isn't

    • jan mam
      jan mam 3 days ago

      in the experiment there was one who showed no signs of worry at all

  • Shad GotEm
    Shad GotEm 4 days ago

    This many people have premium lol.

  • Martin
    Martin 4 days ago +6

    Technically the probability of that one of the group workers noticing the vibrations of the ground and warn others is far more likely than the single worker which's outside of range of the group for direct physical contact to warn him.

    • Martin
      Martin Day ago

      That too would be an interesting hypothetical question but probably requires too much preparation because then the participant also has to experience the trembling of the train before doing the test to make it as likely as possible that someone flips it.
      If it's unknown how noticable the trembling is, nobody would switch it.

    • Mike Shmidt
      Mike Shmidt Day ago

      That's what I was thinking this whole time man. I think it'd be interesting if the lever was on the setting to kill 1 person, to see if anyone wourd flip it then.

  • Jeff Burkett
    Jeff Burkett 4 days ago

    This guy needs some pussy.

  • chris don
    chris don 4 days ago

    I would not pull the lever.
    The train is on the track for a reason.
    And there are to many unknowns if you switch.
    Imagine you did it and then you realise that you instead frontal crashes two trains.

  • Joy and Jane
    Joy and Jane 4 days ago

    best youtube red show ever made your awesome

  • Bogdan Voicu
    Bogdan Voicu 4 days ago

    :-)

  • Federico Jacobitti
    Federico Jacobitti 4 days ago

    This is madness, this is surreal.
    Micheal, since you clearly lack any sort of conclusive results to your emotionally compromising experiment, let me be of help: this was one of the most cheap, gratuitous, inconclusive, and totally arbitrary emotional burdens I've seen delivered to "test" patients.
    This might just be the last time I've given full attention to your work, sorry
    PS: in case this video made you gain subs I'd like to add that, in my opinion, the quality of your subscribers partially defines your work, which I won't be part of anymore

  • Dante Sarotti
    Dante Sarotti 4 days ago

    so this video was your choice, making a few people suffer anxiety for the sake of humanity or just letting it be...

  • Natas Memo
    Natas Memo 5 days ago

    Seeing Elsa have to make that decision made me cry. This is intense!

  • Johnnybomb1
    Johnnybomb1 5 days ago

    @1:23 Far Cry blood dragon ?

  • Narendar Sriram
    Narendar Sriram 5 days ago

    The subjects seem like actors too. At least Elsa (the first one) for sure.

  • Brian Stoyanov
    Brian Stoyanov 5 days ago

    I live in Bulgaria and even if I want to watch it I can't because "This option is disabled in your region"

  • Wessel Driessen
    Wessel Driessen 5 days ago

    With Corey it really showed how important it was that there was a psychologist present, he immediately saw that the guy needed a bit of a slow down and held back Michael a bit when he asked the question in too much of a quick succession

  • XeEnjoi
    XeEnjoi 5 days ago

    She’s an actor. At 19:39 she looks at the camera

  • Shams The Whisteller

    That was an incredibly interesting experiment. The amount of moral dilemma is huge. I don't even know if it should have be done. Maybe, maybe not. Anyway, thank you for the video.

  • edgar deluis
    edgar deluis 5 days ago

    Maybe all of us are been using for an experiment and sudenly michael could appear saying "its an experiment yuo parents aren't and we make you feel you were human"

  • Brian V
    Brian V 5 days ago

    I would make that shit drift lol

  • RoHit Swaro
    RoHit Swaro 5 days ago

    Chidi is that you??

  • Polly Huang
    Polly Huang 5 days ago

    This is by far the best fake video I ever found in my whole life encountering miscellaneous fake videos. Watch the whole video and try to see back at part 19:19 and 27:24, also 27:33

  • Alexander Davis
    Alexander Davis 5 days ago

    The last guy is the only one that acted the way I feel I would’ve

  • Alexander Davis
    Alexander Davis 5 days ago

    I cried even watching this.

  • Jeremey Bafico
    Jeremey Bafico 5 days ago +2

    Anybody else miss the normal Vsauce before they went to TVclip premium

  • Angry Patriot
    Angry Patriot 5 days ago

    Everyone here needs to watch THE PUSH on netflix. I Highly recomend.

  • m.haythem Rouis
    m.haythem Rouis 5 days ago

    Why do you think that the best outcome is to mimick the human decision. Why we dont ask ourselves if an AI can be more intelligent than human, there is a chance it can learn to be more ethical.

  • William Mac
    William Mac 5 days ago

    Even with the etical posture of the Greater Good, It's not completly a good if it involves son evil on it, analogy of this is that good is only and remains good if it's totally good, if you leave food in a place where is not going to rot it will never rot, but if you leave it exposed it will rot to the bottom. You will say that food always rot but that is not true, that's how you make the most delicious meat in the world, you put it in a cover of butter or something that prevents it from having oxigen and light and voila, you put that meat for a coulple of months and it will be the most delicious and tender meat you have tried. It's an interesting thing to discuss, the ethics.

  • Tapu Vae
    Tapu Vae 5 days ago

    10:00 damn cant wait to see all 3 ep