• Published on Jul 3, 2018
  • After months of deliberation J and Ben think they have finally gotten to the bottom of one of Disney Pixar's biggest mysteries: the infamous Mr. Gibbs theory and the identity of Boo's parents!
    Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► bit.ly/2oDIxOL
    J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
    Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
    Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ tvclip.biz/user/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    V L O G➜ tvclip.biz/user/jonathancarlin
    T W I T T E R➜ twitter.com/jonkerlin & twitter.com/SCB_Ben
    I N S T A G R A M➜ instagram.com/jonkerlin & instagram.com/scb_ben
    F A C E B O O K➜ facebook.com/supercarlinbrothers
    G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    P A T R E O N ➜ www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Want to send us something?
    Super Carlin Brothers
    PO Box 4339
    Roanoke, Virginia 24015
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Comments • 5 733

  • Jonathan Carlin
    Jonathan Carlin 11 months ago +1128

    Watch J struggle to raise the cutest child on earth!

    • Boba Fett
      Boba Fett Hour ago

      Carter Day one year ago on the Jonathan Carlin channel and 7 years ago on the super Carlin brother channel

    • wooden potatoes
      wooden potatoes 17 days ago

      @ItsAMeAMario or boo and jack jack are siblings

    • wooden potatoes
      wooden potatoes 17 days ago

      Not true too far fetched

    • Elijah Hill
      Elijah Hill 3 months ago

      scott is clearly his alias guys cmon

  • Simone Brown
    Simone Brown 58 minutes ago

    Edna is definitely boo’s mother!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Simone Brown
    Simone Brown Hour ago


  • Emma Taylor
    Emma Taylor 8 hours ago

    "And we can go ahead and strike Stratagal off of it because fidoafdioh biology..."
    Favorite line. I'm literally going to use fdhksafj biology from now on.

  • Teigen Hackett
    Teigen Hackett 10 hours ago

    Me You mean Thomas riddle foolery

  • Aidan Ha
    Aidan Ha 12 hours ago


  • OneIsTwo ThreeIsFour
    OneIsTwo ThreeIsFour 13 hours ago

    Dont worry I just had to wait for toy story 4

  • Catherine Lozano
    Catherine Lozano 15 hours ago


  • MasterKnight 3000

    I’m speechless because it fits SO well!

  • MAVIS Dreyer
    MAVIS Dreyer Day ago

    Who are the 4 other kids thunder head adopted

  • AX1D3NTPR0N3
    AX1D3NTPR0N3 Day ago


  • Someguy
    Someguy Day ago +1

    Spoilers of Toy Story 4

    In the Kindergarden scene were Bonnie goes to the orientation, there’s a girl very similar to Boo, the girl has the shirt and hairstyle that Boo had in Monsters inc.
    In a Toy Story short, Bonnie was playing on the bathtub with toys, and in the bathroom there was Sully’s fur. So maybe it was Boo the girl in the kindergarden scene in Toy Story 4.

  • Lego Man
    Lego Man Day ago


  • Zero Logic
    Zero Logic 2 days ago

    Mary Gibson's timeline is cut off on how she got a hold on time travel, well, she would first have to open acloset door andn of a child while the monster is scaring them, and entering the monster world. And, since she has modeling in her blood, that explains wood crafting AND a door that makes her house a wood crafting house to a witches cottage. While Carlin explained the ANDVANCED technology, it would be pretty easy for her to make that.

  • Emmett_53
    Emmett_53 2 days ago

    Just so u know boo does not age at all in toy story 4 she is seen playing a carnival game

  • Ravenofthedog
    Ravenofthedog 2 days ago

    To be honest, Boo having gay adoptive parents (“roommate Scott”) makes so much sense. She doesn’t seem to be surprised by much ,which is a surprising trait for a two year old, which could come from being raised by two men and being a part of the underground gay community in the American 50’s. She doesn’t have the largest room in the universe which could be because they have to live frugally to avoid detection. Finally, it could have been a unofficial adoption where Edna basically threw Boo at Thunderhead, not only because he was good with kids but also because he was already reasonably within hiding so was less likely to blab to the press (who would have had a field day,especially in the 50’s and 60’s)about her secret baby.
    Bonus; her timeline is in the 50’s but she isn’t exactly drowning in baby dolls and domestic training toys and to be gender equal in how they raise Boo seems like a thing a gay couple would be more likely to do.

  • Fredrick the Catfish

    Thunderhead and Scott were defo gay but it was the 1950's so they had to keep their relationship as 'roomates'

  • Tony Engardio
    Tony Engardio 3 days ago

    Doubt a gay couple could have even raise kids back in the 50’s

  • taxi cab
    taxi cab 3 days ago

    Is Scott Mr. Gibbs?

  • Karla Marez
    Karla Marez 3 days ago

    And they were roomates

    Omg they were roommates

  • Haibbdggfhhfcbjtfgjffy Bhggg


  • Oscar Markowitz
    Oscar Markowitz 4 days ago

    This is all going off of the assumption that boo is a super

  • Pugs Foreva
    Pugs Foreva 4 days ago


  • Görk
    Görk 4 days ago

    But Boo is... hispanic.

  • Steven D Smith
    Steven D Smith 5 days ago

    You guys totally glossed over Scott. And I'm not the only one who noticed.

  • Nichole Wilde
    Nichole Wilde 5 days ago

    "Holy noodles, guys!" Lol. I love it.

  • Hollow Walker
    Hollow Walker 5 days ago


  • Jose Davila
    Jose Davila 5 days ago +1

    When you said mr Gibbs I you meant the one from pirates of the Caribbean

  • Trudy Preston
    Trudy Preston 5 days ago

    What if Boo was an oops baby?

  • Kellee Metz
    Kellee Metz 5 days ago


    Ian SPRANKLING 5 days ago


  • surukomaru
    surukomaru 5 days ago

    Yo, what if her dad was the toy collector from toy story?! They look similar. And if Randal is Andy's monster, it could possibly be around the same time.

  • Charmeleon Hockey Kid

    Who is the father? META MAN, YOU ARE THE FATHER!!!

  • Charmeleon Hockey Kid


  • Lynx Ackerman
    Lynx Ackerman 6 days ago

    Hold on I laughed when he said Boo was the witch like Nani 😆😆

  • lilrichic
    lilrichic 7 days ago

    I fully accept this!! Btw Scott and thunderhead are totally gay lol

  • trashy
    trashy 8 days ago

    and the were roomates
    god they were r o o m a t e s

  • Ultimate Gaming
    Ultimate Gaming 8 days ago


  • greywolf134
    greywolf134 8 days ago


  • Cyndia Leyva
    Cyndia Leyva 8 days ago


  • R1OT Clan Official
    R1OT Clan Official 8 days ago +1

    Well the fathers last name can’t be Gibbs because if Enda gave Boo up for adoption the adopted father would have the last name Gibbs. A.K.A. Scott Gibbs........ maybe

  • NE Person
    NE Person 9 days ago

    You missed some major things, her dad had thunder voice, manipulation of metal objects , love of animals, all of these things are characteristic's of boo!

  • Christopher Estep
    Christopher Estep 10 days ago

    Actually Dash did Take on Mr. Incredibles power but instead his top body it’s his lower body

  • MrGriff1361
    MrGriff1361 10 days ago

    if this is true then the real question is who is scott and why wasn't he enough of a father figure for boo? i mean they were raising her together right?

  • lucifer
    lucifer 10 days ago

    my-my last name is gibbs...

  • Logan Danielson
    Logan Danielson 11 days ago

    I think its true: scott appears to be a swell guy

  • CherryRibble MyButt
    CherryRibble MyButt 11 days ago +1


  • Anthony Aguilar
    Anthony Aguilar 11 days ago

    What if mr incredible wife cheated on him whit meta man and that’s why jack jack had so many powers

  • Aidan H
    Aidan H 12 days ago


  • Matt Epicness 2.0
    Matt Epicness 2.0 12 days ago

    In the stall she went under the stalls

  • Mauro J De Filippo
    Mauro J De Filippo 12 days ago

    Btw it seems to say 1982

  • Eva Olivero
    Eva Olivero 13 days ago


  • Jocelyn Amaya
    Jocelyn Amaya 13 days ago

    Why can’t you just google it

  • Cheetah Speed
    Cheetah Speed 13 days ago


  • MzRocker 10
    MzRocker 10 13 days ago

    She appears in bonnies school in the background of the toy story 4 trailer

  • Dana Chiong
    Dana Chiong 13 days ago

    So smart👍

  • Pasta Movies
    Pasta Movies 14 days ago

    Mr Gibbs is Mr Gibbs from Pirates of the Caribbean.

  • Castro Dessavre Adriana

    Wait! Did you just discovered thunderhead is actually gay?

    HARDCORE GAMER 76 14 days ago


  • Ian Turner
    Ian Turner 14 days ago +3

    in a file for one of the kids says they are traveling to 1999, and boo would be born in 1996 or 1997. The math adds up in that case.

  • Angel or whatever Guzman


  • Kathleen Barney
    Kathleen Barney 14 days ago

    She has sonic screams

  • I r r e l e v a n t
    I r r e l e v a n t 14 days ago +3

    Video: Pixar theory
    Ad: Walt Disney Animation Studios

  • Ace Alvarez
    Ace Alvarez 15 days ago


  • doge
    doge 15 days ago

    So that's why she does not like caps her husband did for wearing one

  • angry cat
    angry cat 15 days ago


  • MisterSamman
    MisterSamman 15 days ago

    I just realized Jack Jack is a “Jack of all trades but a master of none.”

  • FaZe Vain 22
    FaZe Vain 22 15 days ago +1

    Meta man more like mega man

  • Tee Charlestache
    Tee Charlestache 15 days ago

    I’m dying. I’m halfway through the video, and I check on my pizza tracker. Apparently June is dairy month, and a Note said ‘Thank you Edna’.

  • CaptainMurica USA
    CaptainMurica USA 15 days ago

    The song boo is singing in the bathroom was actually to the tune of “Beauty and the Beast”.

  • guy4er
    guy4er 15 days ago +1

    I think her powers are time travel this power means she could be in two places in one time and it's explains her place in the pixel theory

  • Rosie
    Rosie 16 days ago

    Half of this video is based of the video you uploaded 2 years ago. And the other half is you referencing other movies. I get it you need to reference other movies think boo might be the suspect but get to the point. Don’t reference 5 different possible suspects then say “no”.

  • Tate Janssen
    Tate Janssen 16 days ago


  • Ali R
    Ali R 16 days ago

    Yeahhh “roommates” purely heterosexual relationship, living together raising 5 kids.

  • Sonic The Hedgehog
    Sonic The Hedgehog 16 days ago +1

    0:00 - 0:01 LOL 😂

  • MisterMels
    MisterMels 16 days ago

    She wouldn’t become the witch if brave would be long before the incredibles and monsters inc on the timeline

  • Shayla Nelson
    Shayla Nelson 16 days ago

    Okay, everything in this theory seems very convincing except for one major detail: how is she the witch from Brave?? As mentioned through the Pixar Theory, Brave is based in the second sequence of the theory, almost to the VERY BEGINNING. So if she was the witch from Brave, why would she use her powers to travel to another dimension way before her time, where she grows old and never finds Sully again? Why wouldn’t she use her powers to see Sully again?

  • Able Kitten
    Able Kitten 16 days ago


  • Rice Man
    Rice Man 16 days ago


  • Dudeguy
    Dudeguy 16 days ago +1

    When I saw the title “ MR GIBBS REVEALED” I thought they were going to talk about Mr Gibbs from pirates of the Caribbean😂😂

  • Carisma Ortiz
    Carisma Ortiz 17 days ago

    Question. In the monsters ink movie when sully almost gets caught in the human world there was a woman. And when they called the police she was obviously worried.

  • Juan Soto
    Juan Soto 17 days ago +1

    Scott is really important to this theory

  • Stray Badger
    Stray Badger 17 days ago

    Scott is a delightful guy

  • oof oof
    oof oof 17 days ago +122

    "Looking for her only other father figure, Sully" rip Scott

    • ii curlyyheadmoni ii
      ii curlyyheadmoni ii 5 days ago +1

      that reminds me of that vine thats like 2 dudes sitting in a hot tub 5 feet apart cause they're not gay

    • djenn
      djenn 10 days ago +4

      I KNOOOOOOW!!!!

  • wooden potatoes
    wooden potatoes 17 days ago

    I just thought of an amazing theory in nightmare before Christmas there are a bunch of doors and boo says boo a lot oogey boogey wants santa bcos he lost contact with the monster world and wants to find his way back cos boo is saying this Cos that is part of the reference to her true scarer oogey boogey which is why Randall was the replacement monster

  • Nothankyou
    Nothankyou 17 days ago

    Okay they are so gay. Two adult males as roommates, raising children, in the 1950's. You're telling me that they weren't gay lovers in secret because being gay wasn't a widely accepted thing?

    Sounds fake but okay.

  • Tayorama YT
    Tayorama YT 17 days ago


  • Cassidy Johnson
    Cassidy Johnson 18 days ago +1

    Mentaman also has sonic scream which is if you remember in monsters inc boo screams and the electricity goes hay wire which could easily because of her sonic scream ability.

  • Cade684
    Cade684 18 days ago

    10:14 Car alarm.

  • Lcst Boy
    Lcst Boy 18 days ago

    Her only father figure was sully? EXCUSE ME DONT IGNORE SCOTT #appreciatescott

  • Carina Trevino
    Carina Trevino 18 days ago +1


  • •Adeen•
    •Adeen• 19 days ago

    S C O T T

  • Daemonium_Lupus
    Daemonium_Lupus 19 days ago

    What if Edna gave Boo to Thunderhead and Scott because she knew they wanted more children. Hear me out, Thunderhead and Scott are lovers and parents under the guise of roommates. Like, she was about to give her up to an adoption shelter or orphanage but Thunderhead said something about either him or Scott wanting more children. So she asked if he would take her and he and Scott agreed. So when Boo showed her powers at a young age they knew how to handle her. But then Thunderhead died and Scott had to raise all five children alone. In grief Boo tries to find Sully, a friend she made and took care of her. So though out her life she continues to try find Sully and still believing she could find him because of how she was raised.

  • Grapes Chickens
    Grapes Chickens 20 days ago

    I have a theory now here me out maybe her parents aren’t introduced

  • Owen Sings
    Owen Sings 20 days ago +1


  • Jakob Goodwin
    Jakob Goodwin 20 days ago


  • Chester Holland
    Chester Holland 21 day ago

    There needs to be horror movie that will show who boos parents is, whats they're name and feature boo herself also her boyfriend if she is in relationship. In beginning of movie were boo goes to high school, her parents has nice house and when boo gets home in days later they knowdace things starting to change in they're house start experiencing activities include shadows moving in house, objects move it self, cold spots, male screaming out side but nobody is out there they never thought nothing about ghosts nothing except the screams got they're attention but still not thought nothing about it nor Randall was not mention from her parents nor boo at the time. then at night boo goes to sleep and start experiencing dreams about nice male person, he wanted to see her again, he miss her and he wants her after she wakes up she don't say nothing about her dream to her parents nor her friends in school nor her boyfriend if she is in relationship. Then week later boo start experience dreams again of nice male then she gets strong sensation that something not right then in her dream a nice male turns evil, mean, and angry the smile turns into evil grant with jagged teeth start look like Randall then immediately she wakes up paralyzed can't move nor talk and her mom came to wake her up for school and knowdace her eyes open but can't move nor talk and looked at her mom like help me mommy and her mom becomes scared and holler boo are you okay? She cant speak back for minutes then minutes later boo can finally move, finally speak and came out of evil sensation and then her mom ask her what wrong and then she start discussing her about dreams and nightmare that's when she mention Randall. Her mom didn't believe her and made her skip day of school and took her to doctor and there was nothing wrong with her. she starts crying and wanted to stay up all night does not want go to sleep. then because lack of sleep she becomes short tempered, angry and want skip days her mom then takes her back to doctor see if there anything wrong with her and there was still nothing wrong with her health. then her dad knows some one that investigate ghosts and activity then he got he's friend to come over so he can borrow he's camera so he can put it in boos house and her mom said you think there ghosts and he says i don't know it worth to check find out. Then nights later in boos room while boo is sleep she start experiencing attack and camera picked it up then her closet doors slams open its self. Then when boo went to high school her parents watched it and her mom start thinking there is something in they're house. Then when boo got home from school there was a paster from the church with investigators at her parents house and start investigate it and know the energy in boos room felt negative and demonic, the cold spots temperature show 66.6F and less when they saw that indicates demonic or negative, objects fly it self and shadows. then investigator pull out of emp recorder and ask what is your name are you male? Why are you here and how did you come? answer in truth and then it responds back Randall then boo was unnerve when she heard that. Also it said I'm here to get the kid and you all can't do nothing about it and it said I came from monster world. the investigators ask him why you want the kid? Then demonic Randall responds back you see. then her parents said next day boo can go to school and she needs get her boyfriend up here right away and the pastor told her that this is incubus what happen is that this demon became attractive to you and Randall was not fully defeated at the time since you was little and that thing followed you here. the night boo sleeps in living room and there was no attacks but noises in house. Then next day her and her boyfriend came to her house from school and then contact the pastor of the church and investigator to come up and talk with us and her boyfriend asked boo why Randall wants boo why her why you all's house? her parents said let's see what we can do when pastor shows up. Then pastor shows up and told boos boyfriend that she is attracted by demon that name Randall and he told him about her past what happen then her boyfriend ask him what should we do? Then he said let's first bless the house. Then they start blessing the house for demons to be removed and not never return. Then they go in boos bed room then they start blessing then boo starting get scared, getting sick and trying to black out and getting attacked them pastor blesses over her and then when the demon activity stopped then pastor told her boyfriend to claim her said you gotta claim her now and you gotta tell this demon that he can't have her. Then her boyfriend she is mine you can't have her and you ain't gonna get her you need to leave and not come back. Then her boyfriend hugs her and then pastor said boo tell Randall to leave you alone then she said Randall leave me alone 3 times then demon defeated and every thing in house became bright and cold spots left. then in end with beautifull scene with her, her boyfriend and her family also her boyfriend m moves in with her then the movie is over. The movie like that needs to be made we're we know who is her parents, and were monster and Randall is mention. A horror movie were Randall returns in demon form and the movie needs label return of Randall

  • Kelly Schmicking
    Kelly Schmicking 21 day ago

    those amazing socks have been knocked off.

    SUPREMA 21 day ago

    as if they care. Maybe Pixar didn't think it through

  • Nicki Rippa
    Nicki Rippa 21 day ago

    My brain hurts