Mufasa And Scar Aren't Brothers?!

Share
Embed
  • Published on Aug 24, 2017
  • Last week Rob Minkoff and Don Hahn, Director and Producer of Disney’s The Lion King respectively, revealed that Scar and Mufasa were not brothers?! Today Ben examines if this could possibly be true.
    Hey Super Carlin Friends! ►► bit.ly/196DDlu
    Google Autofill Playlist ►► bit.ly/1DCdQNm
    Theories ►► bit.ly/1z5uZcS
    Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ tvclip.biz/user/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    FOLLOW US:
    T W I T T E R➜ twitter.com/jonkerlin & twitter.com/SCB_Ben
    I N S T A G R A M➜ instagram.com/jonkerlin & instagram.com/scb_ben
    F A C E B O O K➜ facebook.com/supercarlinbrothers
    G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    P A T R E O N ➜ www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Want to send us something?
    Super Carlin Brothers
    PO Box 4339
    Roanoke, Virginia 24015
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Comments • 4 299

  • chanson brummet
    chanson brummet Day ago

    Yeah ffggbjjgfugfdzHNKJGCTT HAHA WAS A GREAT TFCHJGYIH

  • Anissa Zichella
    Anissa Zichella 7 days ago

    I may not be biological Brothers but they could still be brothers

  • Kaylin Schei
    Kaylin Schei 8 days ago

    #HeadCannon

  • Kanyanta Mwansa
    Kanyanta Mwansa 13 days ago

    Actually that was false. A week later, Roger Allens confirmed that Mufasa and Scar are brothers. But there is actually an origin behind Rob Minkoff's claim of them not being brothers.

    In the first draft of The Lion King when it was called "King of the Kalahari," the film was intended to focus around a war between lions and baboons with Scar being the leader, whilst Rafiki was a cheetah. This plot was abandoned and Scar was rewritten into a rouge lion, unrelated to Mufasa and Simba. In "King of the Jungle" as well as "King of the Beasts" Mufasa and Scar were originally not supposed to be related, but instead, Scar was a rouge lion, who was jealous of Mufasa's position as King. He would've trespassed into the Pride Lands before being kicked out by Mufasa, when he meets the hyenas (originally lead by Banagai and Baasho) and plots with them to take down Mufasa.
    There are two versions of how he overthrows Mufasa. In "King of the Jungle" Scar challenges Mufasa in a fight, but the fight takes place on Pride Rock. Scar and the hyenas throw Mufasa off to his death where he is mauled alive by the hyenas. Scar would later exile Simba from Pride Rock, before being defeated and killed in a bloody fight, in which Simba takes the throne and exiles his followers.
    In "King of the Beasts" Mufasa and Scar challenge near a fire tree bridge, and manages to snap his neck in half. Simba, who would be a teenager in this scene would've rebelled against Scar, only to be banished and lose his tail, before later returning and killing Scar, throwing him off the edge of Pride Rock, before killing Banagi the same way.
    However, this plot was scrapped, and thus Scar was rewritten Mufasa's younger brother as the directors felt that a threat within the royal family would be a better plotline.

  • Flux Burger
    Flux Burger 19 days ago

    #HEADCANON

  • Jimmyn19
    Jimmyn19 25 days ago +1

    #Headcannon

  • JaLiyah Edwards
    JaLiyah Edwards Month ago

    They are

  • blackrainy cat
    blackrainy cat Month ago +1

    I saw another video on who nalas father was, and in the video the guy was talking about a book that is not head cannon and I’m pretty sure those where the same books
    The guy who made the books just used the Disney thing to make his books, Not entirely sure if that’s the case but I would look it up

  • Felicia louisiana girl

    I thought that they were half brothers just like simba and nala I believe that nala has different mom that we see in the movie but since I've heard before only a leader male mates with the females mufasa would be her father making this whole story like a hiarchy were the men get with the closest relitive as possible to keep the blood line strong

  • Buckley Harty
    Buckley Harty Month ago +1

    Bees and ants .

  • Ash
    Ash Month ago

    New theory - J and Ben aren’t brothers

  • Amberlynn Hill
    Amberlynn Hill Month ago

    It is not uncommon for lion brothers to take over a pride together when they are young but mufasa also has more parasites then scar because red manes means unhealthy lions black manes are healthy plus male lions in real life kinda mount with each other to keep bounds together so good luck with getting past that you now know more of lion that you probably didn’t want to know

  • Elijah Ruddy
    Elijah Ruddy Month ago

    Where is that blue /red sign from I’ve seen it before can’t remember

  • Padpaw22
    Padpaw22 Month ago +2

    That whole bloody lion tribe is 1 big incestuous family.

  • Nathaniel Reynolds
    Nathaniel Reynolds Month ago

    Funny as you say that because i am actually eating tacos at this very moment

  • Toads load 100
    Toads load 100 Month ago

    Did you know that scar used to be in the lion guard

  • Matthew Daltrey
    Matthew Daltrey Month ago +2

    No, Scar and Mufasa are canonically brothers. I'm pretty certain. They look different because, looking at the parents, they inherited the different colourations.

    • KANYANTA MWANSA
      KANYANTA MWANSA Month ago +1

      You are correct sir! In fact, Mufasa and Scar were originally not supposed to be brothers. Scar was going to be a rouge lion who was jealous of Mufasa's position as King and would've allied with the hyenas(lead by Banagai) to take him and Simba down and rule Pride Rock. He would've defeated Mufasa in a fight before banishing an adolescent Simba to the desert, only to later be killed by Simba himself. This plotline was too dark and as well as that, a threat within the royal family would be more interesting, so they changed the storyline to make him Mufasa's younger brother who seizes the throne by killing his brother, and exiling his nephew.

  • American Dude
    American Dude Month ago +1

    Ummm he says Scar Brother help me so umm also he’s Simba uncle so yes there Brothers

  • Heaven Williams
    Heaven Williams Month ago

    I always thought they were half siblings.

  • YoloMaster Sherr
    YoloMaster Sherr Month ago

    Ive been watching so long

  • YoloMaster Sherr
    YoloMaster Sherr Month ago

    I thought that whenever they moved the chair, that was the same guy being his brother

  • YoloMaster Sherr
    YoloMaster Sherr Month ago +1

    Who literally jusy realized that the supercarlin brothers werent just the same person

  • broken_ by_death
    broken_ by_death Month ago

    Looks up on google* ...
    My life was a lie

  • Sans Gaster
    Sans Gaster Month ago

    I thought you said "A Hottie" 😂😂😂

  • Bush Law Offices
    Bush Law Offices Month ago

    Oops I was wrong sorry

  • Bush Law Offices
    Bush Law Offices Month ago

    Scar got his scar because when he was out hunting with his mom she died from a buffalo stamped just like mufasa. And his dad got mad and clawed scratched him in the eye he ran away and zira started calling him scar and I guess it just stuck with him.

  • Bush Law Offices
    Bush Law Offices Month ago

    Where did you get your shirt!

  • Christie Marie
    Christie Marie Month ago

    I d

  • Layth Adrian
    Layth Adrian Month ago

    Maybe he thought Scar was a better name than Trash

  • goji 63
    goji 63 Month ago

    I think they made a good decision making Mufasa and Scar not brothers, they don't even look alike, one looks buff and healthy with a red mane and yellow fur and red eyes, the other one is skinny and cranky and looks like a different genetic species with a black mane and dark brown fur with green eyes, maby they have different fathers, Mufasas is obviously Ahati, and Scars might be an rouge outlander, this is my opinion.

  • Nahla Oruc
    Nahla Oruc Month ago

    umm... Sorry, I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW DO SCAR(TAKA) AREN'T BROTHER'S BEACUSE THEY WE'RE BORN TOGETHER /:

  • Simbas Edits
    Simbas Edits Month ago +1

    Well in my opinion this is isn’t the directors choice to say their not brothers because the movie did not come first it was the books and have u seen the mum and fad they both have similarities I’m sorry but I think u need to look into the books for information on this movie also the directors don’t know a lot like the fact in the comics Simba had a son named Kopa nobody told the directors abot this and made up Kiara

  • Omar Reyes
    Omar Reyes Month ago

    1:57 that's not exactly how it works, 1st the male of the pride doesn't necessarly needs to be old to be "dethroned" in fact an old lion can take a younger lion's pride, second, they don't need to die, true the duel for the pride can have a fatal outcome but it's not always the case, it's hardly the case even, lastly killing/defeating the previous leader of the pride does not make the females go into heat, killing their offspring is what makes them go into heat.
    P.S. younger males usually leave their own pride when they are adolecent or young adults in search of their own, they rarely try to take over the pride were they were born.

  • Son of the Sea
    Son of the Sea Month ago

    Soooooo... WHAT WAS THE POINT OF THE WHOLE VID??? HAHAHAHA

  • Grumpy Jedi
    Grumpy Jedi Month ago

    Tacoooooos !!!!!!!!!

  • Ravenclaw for life
    Ravenclaw for life Month ago

    "After saying takka too many times is anyone else hungry for tacos"
    For dinner tonight im actually having tacos

  • its ok, im white
    its ok, im white 2 months ago

    Doesn't scars kid hook up with Simba's kid?

  • calvin .
    calvin . 2 months ago

    If mufasa called him brother he's his brother

  • CaptainCoCoaPuffs
    CaptainCoCoaPuffs 2 months ago +1

    Speaking about brothers are you related to jacksepticeye

  • ReaganPlayz
    ReaganPlayz 2 months ago +2

    Scar is a try-hard!

  • Lord Frost N' Chilled
    Lord Frost N' Chilled 2 months ago

    #TACOSTACOSTACOS!

  • Fan 111
    Fan 111 2 months ago +1

    5:56 "when a hottie himself shows up"

  • william amely
    william amely 2 months ago

    It's very likely that they're half brothers (having the same Lion as their Father, but NOT the same Lioness as their Mother. Another possibility is that their pride was sired by Two different male Lions, but who were brothers to each other. Thus Mufasa and Scar may be closer to Cousins, then Brothers. But in the absence of their original lineage, we must accept their being Brothers.

  • Ashley Draper
    Ashley Draper 2 months ago

    Doesn’t scar refer to Mufasa as his big brother in the movie though?

  • Archie Bain
    Archie Bain 2 months ago

    Who else’s favourite character is Mufasa

  • The Irish Man
    The Irish Man 2 months ago

    Where can I get that shirt? Please let me know I need that in my life!

  • M C
    M C 2 months ago

    Just stop

  • Chris Zablocki
    Chris Zablocki 2 months ago

    Support WWE. The retards need entertainment. And the coliseum was ruined to the ground by barbarians more than 1000 years ago. This Disney rivalry isn't going to end well.

  • Zarek Downes
    Zarek Downes 2 months ago

    Where da socks

  • Adrian King
    Adrian King 2 months ago

    WHAT!!!! Scar and Mufasa are not Brothers!!!! 🤯🤯🤯🤯

  • hamza hussein
    hamza hussein 2 months ago

    Wix

  • Lynn Robinson
    Lynn Robinson 2 months ago

    Ants have a queen

  • Menthe
    Menthe 2 months ago

    Hey means spider o.o

  • Ruth Rodriguez
    Ruth Rodriguez 2 months ago

    I don't believe you scar and mufasa are brothers I kind of don't believe you

  • KVILL VILLIN
    KVILL VILLIN 2 months ago

    Disney is the face company for the illuminati. They controll the world

  • danielberryjr007
    danielberryjr007 2 months ago

    So Mufasa is the son of Uru and A Hottie?

  • Cats are Adorable
    Cats are Adorable 2 months ago

    No they are beacuse there dad had a black mane and green eyes and had scars face and mufasa body colour and their mother had scars body colour and their mum had mufasa eyes colour and face shape

  • moon_sky.21
    moon_sky.21 2 months ago

    Taka literally means waste in Swahili, the language used in the lionverse.😖😖😖

  • chicken_nugget moomoo_meow484

    2019?

  • William Nett
    William Nett 2 months ago

    Wouldn't they be brothers from same father not same mother. The females go into heat and are brothers that way. So they are brothers but not brothers. Kind of a step bro in a way.

  • Jhaime Charles
    Jhaime Charles 2 months ago

    But rafiki had told the pride too call taka scar as a reminder of his actions

  • Giraffe Girl
    Giraffe Girl 2 months ago

    I have like all of the Disney movies,

  • Ferocious Fox
    Ferocious Fox 2 months ago

    A-hottie 😂😂😂

  • lion girl 43
    lion girl 43 2 months ago

    I kind of agree with you they don't look alike and if they were brothers I highly doubt that his brother wanted to be king

  • Beowulf Macbethson
    Beowulf Macbethson 2 months ago

    What's next? A purple lion arrives and tries to collect all of the Jalali stones so he can snap his fingers and turn the Circle of Life into a Semi-Circle?

  • John O'Brien
    John O'Brien 2 months ago

    So is simba's grandfather leo or ahadi?

  • Taija Bartrop
    Taija Bartrop 2 months ago

    If my name was meant garbage I WOULD GLADLY GIVE MY SELF A SCAR TO BE RENEMAED😂

  • ApolloSniperman
    ApolloSniperman 2 months ago

    Just saw the Toy Story balls in the background

  • kamo killer
    kamo killer 3 months ago

    He said Simba needs to look out for his son this video came out 2017 and u tellin me u still haven't seen the Lion King 2 u know where Simba has daughter come on now sir u can do better

  • Banished Air
    Banished Air 3 months ago

    Also, Mufasa is an African lion and Scar is an Asian lion, so they can't possibly be actual brothers

  • Madeline Carragher
    Madeline Carragher 3 months ago

    Wait but “A Tale of Two Brothers” is not canon I thought? Regardless, this was an awesome video!

  • Lillypetal of ThunderClan

    i was eating tacos during the video!

  • Big Boss
    Big Boss 3 months ago

    Really wanted them to cut in Liquid Snake shouting brother.

  • Amy Brodsky
    Amy Brodsky 3 months ago

    am i the only 1 who has never seen the lion king?!?!?!?!

  • Bectek props
    Bectek props 3 months ago

    my mum is making tacos right now

  • Troy Staunton
    Troy Staunton 3 months ago

    Scar shouldn’t even be in the pride. 1 alpha male, many lionesses host Cubs. No alternative males.

  • Poppy Schmee
    Poppy Schmee 3 months ago

    And wolfs have hierarchies

  • Grace
    Grace 3 months ago

    2019 anyone?

  • David Cardona
    David Cardona 3 months ago

    Can't you say the same thing without being so goofy....?

  • Arielle Davis
    Arielle Davis 3 months ago

    Mufasa = Dark Vader = Genie?
    Aladdin, Simba, and Luke I am your fathers.

    • Wess Wise
      Wess Wise Month ago

      Genie was Robin Williams. R.i.p.

  • angelio 101
    angelio 101 3 months ago

    I just ate tacos before this

  • Nancy Applesmith
    Nancy Applesmith 3 months ago

    The father comes to save the day. Why dose that sound familler?

  • Sean Williamson
    Sean Williamson 3 months ago

    Pretty sure Simba refers to Scar as his uncle.

  • Maxine Walters
    Maxine Walters 3 months ago

    Haha what a round about way to reinforce what we already know! As a Zoologist (animal expert) and die hard Lion King lover I was about to jump down into the towel section and mouth off at many moments in this video. Glad I waited until the end! Yes, that is how real lion prides work. Adult male lions (outsiders as male lions are, for the most part, expelled from a pride when they are ready to breed and take over their own prides...therefore becoming outsiders even if they were previously pride members) challenge the king. If they win (usually by killing the king) infanticide (the killing of all the previous king's offspring) will occur. But it is precisely by this reasoning that Scar and Mufasa must be brothers-otherwise the the eldest one (son of the previous king) would have been killed! Speaking of eldest, it was always my understanding that Scar was the eldest, from a previous litter of Ahadi and Uru. The reason why Mufasa got the throne was because he was more powerful and won a fight between himself and Scar when Ahadi died. Not sure where I read this...maybe it isnt canon? I also understood that Mufasa gave Scar that nickname as a taunting display of one-up-man-ship so that Scat (Taka) never forgets that he owes his life to Mufasa.

    • Maxine Walters
      Maxine Walters 3 months ago

      Also...no one said that Scar and Mufasa both had the same mother....male lions breed with all females of the pride. Potentially Scar was born to a lesser lioness (not the top notch Queen Uru)

  • vaughn ferrier
    vaughn ferrier 3 months ago

    Why do they always say click the card if they want you to finish the video I don't know about you guys but I like the video at the end

  • ZerroTheDragon
    ZerroTheDragon 3 months ago

    I really want to read those books but they're so rare omg

  • SS SillyString
    SS SillyString 3 months ago +1

    #HEADCANNON

  • Chyanne Nixon
    Chyanne Nixon 4 months ago

    Totally what's not interesting about lions murdering helpless cubes and week equal lions then making the cubes mother their mate. what's not to love.

  • Juan Padilla
    Juan Padilla 4 months ago +1

    I wonder how James Earle Jones & Jeremy Irons reacts 2 The News about it 2?

  • evanluck
    evanluck 4 months ago

    They just want to get rid of the idea of Simba and Nana being related

  • dangthatsalongusername
    dangthatsalongusername 4 months ago

    Doesn't toca mean trash

  • dangthatsalongusername
    dangthatsalongusername 4 months ago

    I choked on my coke when I saw this video

  • FandomGirl
    FandomGirl 4 months ago

    THEY ARE NOW MAKING A LIVE ACTION LION KING AND IM SO EXCITED

  • Anime&kpop fan Sophia
    Anime&kpop fan Sophia 4 months ago +1

    I just realised that Simba did have 3 children...
    Kion - lion guard
    Kiara - movie 2
    And another one that died.... I forgot his name...
    But I am not very sure if the Lion Guard series would count as canon, but I do like the idea of there being 3 siblings, and not just Kiara

  • Daniel Simkins
    Daniel Simkins 4 months ago

    The Lion King is the Shakespear's Hamlet! They are definitely brothers!! As usual Disney didn't create a story, they stole it and shuffled stuff around. But they're absolutely brothers!!
    Speaking of brothers.....love the info these guys give.....BUT DO YOU HAVE TO SHOUT EVERY WORD?!!! I have to turn my phone volume down so I don't wake up people in the next house!!!!

  • DemonOfShadows66
    DemonOfShadows66 4 months ago

    Oh Scar's real name is Taka, just like the villain from Kimba the white lion, weird coincidence huh

  • Jonte Lindsey
    Jonte Lindsey 4 months ago

    Well in the book they are why did u jus waste my time watching this when ik the answer already

  • Rogue Atlas
    Rogue Atlas 4 months ago

    Scar and mufasa are kid of like the huega clan from Naruto the story we here in season three during tournament

  • Eileen Bill
    Eileen Bill 4 months ago

    ..

  • Fluff Whiskers
    Fluff Whiskers 4 months ago

    All I can hear is ‘a hottie’ and a ‘guru’ xD