India's Geography Problem

  • Published on Dec 5, 2017
  • Build your website for 10% off by going to squarespace.com/wendover
    Subscribe to Half as Interesting (The other channel from Wendover Productions): www.youtube.com/halfasinteresting
    Check out my podcast with Brian from Real Engineering:
    itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/showmakers/id1224583218?mt=2 (iTunes link)
    tvclip.biz/channel/UC_10vJJqf2ZK0lWrb5BXAPg (YouTube link)
    Support Wendover Productions on Patreon: www.patreon.com/wendoverproductions
    Get a Wendover Productions t-shirt for $20:
    store.dftba.com/products/wendover-productions-shirt
    Youtube: www.YouTube.com/WendoverProductions
    Twitter: www.Twitter.com/WendoverPro
    Email: WendoverProductions@gmail.com
    Reddit: Reddit.com/r/WendoverProductions
    Animation by Josh Sherrington (www.youtube.com/heliosphere)
    Sound by Graham Haerther (www.Haerther.net)
    Thumbnail by Joe Cieplinski (joecieplinski.com/)
    Music: "So Far Away" by Riot, "Lithium" By Kevin MacLeod, "Hydra" by Huma Huma, "Namaste" by Audionautix, and "Raw Deal" by Gunnar Olsen
    Big thanks to Patreon supporters: M, Pete, Ken Lee, Victor Zimmer, Paul Jihoon Choi, Dylan Benson, Etienne Dechamps, Donald, Chris Allen, Abil Abdulla, Anson Leng, Johnn & Becki Johnston, Connor J Smith, Arkadiy Kulev, Hagai Bloch Gabot, William Chappell, Eyal Matsliah, Joseph Bull, Marcelo Alves Vieira, Hank Green, Plinio Correa, Brady Bellini
  • Runtime: 12:43
  • india  geography  problem  geopolitics  politics  issue  power  geo  water  borders  china  tibet  nepal  bhutan  bangladesh  indian  pakistan  east pakistan  british empire  britain  british  partition  international relations  wendover productions  wendover  half as interesting  hai  explained  interesting  animated  international  defense  human  people  countries  

Comments: 6 083

  • Vikram bhat
    Vikram bhat 18 minutes ago

    wit 966k subscribers how cud u lick chinese ass....? @0:30 get our map right or stop doing video on india........

  • Bharadwaja Kambhammettu

    "British created India and India did not exist as a country before the British"? what nonsense!! The author does not know Indian history at all and views India from the eyes of the British. Who says that India is not a country before the British came to loot it? The idea of a nation state and that to be called a country, it should have a singular & coherent culture, language, ethnicity & religion etc is a very new European idea. That yardstick can not be used to measure India. India is a civilisational state inhabited continuously for thousands of years and the description of India in each of its many languages is the same. British only looted & destroyed India and when leaving broke it into two. If the British had created any thing, they created Pakistan.

  • Sanjeet K
    Sanjeet K Hour ago

    9:23

  • Sanjeet K
    Sanjeet K Hour ago

    7:10

  • Nishan Shetty
    Nishan Shetty Hour ago

    uhhhh....no idea about wht he evn talking....uff...INTERNET...

  • Wicked_man Gamer
    Wicked_man Gamer Hour ago

    This video is a bunch of misconceptions and stereotype.
    Though I appreciate the time you would have put into the research but most of it is flawed.

  • John von Shepard
    John von Shepard 2 hours ago

    But is there enough toilet for indian in india?

  • John von Shepard
    John von Shepard 2 hours ago

    Kung fu come from India.

  • Rob Watson
    Rob Watson 4 hours ago

    That's some shocking HTML at 8:31 :O

  • Tejaswi Gururaj
    Tejaswi Gururaj 4 hours ago

    India had worlds largest ship building industry before it was deceivingly colonized

  • treeberry4
    treeberry4 4 hours ago

    And yes, stop showing British as God of modern India!! India would have still developed nonetheless British or no British. Nothing British did was for Indians. It was all to serve their own interests, transport their own goods and themselves, to colonise more. Thus the railway system. Did British tell you, they used new railway tracks in some hilly areas to establish their cities and did not allow Indians in the prime centers of city. Did British tell you, how they refused medicines in famines to Indians? Did British tell you how they kept dividing India geographically right from beginning of 20th century? How they played politics of Divide & Rule, deliberately?Did they tell you tortures inflicted on Indian freedom fighters & prisoners in Kala Pani jail- Andaman & Nicobar Islands? No you don't know nor will you let others know. British were as bad as Hitler. So stop projecting them as best thing which happened to India. British were a curse then. Integrate India my foot!! Its only because of British that India was divided. I pray to God one day Britain gets back what it did to India and gets divided further & further. FYI India was already called as country Bharat/India. Many rulers have ruled over India as one country in history despite some disintegration in between.

  • treeberry4
    treeberry4 5 hours ago

    Typical of Westerners to choose worst visuals. Despite the fact India has super developed cities too. And transportation problem? Which world u r living in? We are in 21st Century and Indian Railways, Road transport is very much equipped and deals well with transporting goods. Stop this partiality.

  • SilverWind MC
    SilverWind MC 5 hours ago

    lel

  • Nikhilesh Surve
    Nikhilesh Surve 5 hours ago

    One of the biggest problem for Indian in developing is the centralisation of power which is why the last part of federal India was not accurate & comparison with US (which is a constitutionally federal state with all it's states independent to govern themselves within their borders) is absurd. Indian model is much close to unitary but the existence of state govts make it look federal just as existence of home nations (who enjoy much greater autonomy than Indian states) make UK look federal. If India were to become federal accepting one size doesn't fits all many (not all) of it's problems could be solved (like some states demands for either autonomy or special status, language inequality by national government, etc.) & development could be brought relatively much quicker (since states as well as cities will be forced to take greater responsibility due to acquiring greater administrative powers within their borders without being allowed to rely upon the national government).

  • Javed Rachman
    Javed Rachman 6 hours ago

    'English literacy got good'

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    100000000%true

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    100000000000%true

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Prati second ide gurtuku raavali meeku...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Meeru rajakeeyam chestene nenu gelukkunnanu...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Nenu eppudo cheppanu...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Asale adugupettanu...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Nenu vere caste lo asale adugupettanu...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Anavasranga hopes pettukoni suicide cheskokandi...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Same caste well settled..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 6 hours ago +1

    Malli malli cheptunna vinandi..

  • Lingaraj Ramanjaneyalu

    Your knowledge is not adequate. Please read more. Understand Indian culture trough India lense. A lot of misinterpretation.

  • Pradeep Choudhary
    Pradeep Choudhary 8 hours ago

    Doesn't India have a fence on the border with Pakistan? Last time I checked it was the longest and most patrolled border fence.

  • Adnaan Khan
    Adnaan Khan 9 hours ago

    India was never a country it was a group and it is a group of different cultures princely states and union territories but we were brought together to form one India by British who looted all of us and now we fight amongst ourselves 😎😂✌️ just the state of Maharashtra has so many versions of marathi language the north is muslims the north east is Buddhist and Christians the south is Hindu not the UTTAR PRADESH Hindu they are the true indians the north are people who came from outside india the punjabis the Bengalis so many people but now the communist government says its Hindu nation😂😂✌️

  • triplenz
    triplenz 9 hours ago

  • Salman Chowdhury
    Salman Chowdhury 10 hours ago

    What no mention of the Siliguri Corridor?

  • Rohit Sardessai
    Rohit Sardessai 13 hours ago

    This video is made with shallow insight and poor knowledge of India's history and problems.

  • Guinness
    Guinness 20 hours ago

    Not sure I agree with you about excelling at English. The English spoken in India is very different from that spoken elsewhere. It is used as the common language for India, and it's syntax and meanings often don't correspond to those naturally inferred in the west. This can cause huge problems in communication

  • Lizardtube!
    Lizardtube! 21 hour ago

    My teacher just showed this video and your China video and it was awesome 😏😏

  • Walter Stoermer
    Walter Stoermer 21 hour ago

    Education systems, not educational system

  • Yushan Yasindu
    Yushan Yasindu Day ago

    You forgot to separate Sri Lanka from India. That country looks like part of it but no that completely separate island with completely different culture . you might wanna study history before doing things like this.

  • Neillotpal Chakraborty

    India was never formed on the basis of being a homeland for Hindus
    our leaders wanted a land for Indians and didnt base it off of one particular religion
    thats why India always has had diverse religious groups with significant populations which simply cannot be claimed by any other country perios
    also the argument completley falls apart when an Indian who happens to be a muslim can call India home and has the same love for the country as his compatriot who happens to have a different religion
    India is for Indians
    has been is and forever will be

  • वि श
    वि श Day ago

    Never seen a video with so many misguided facts.
    Unsubscribed.

  • ken ezzell
    ken ezzell Day ago

    The three things holding India back are..... sanitation....lack of shoes...and no traffic laws.

  • AJAY MISHRA
    AJAY MISHRA Day ago

    India beat pakistan every(4) times in a war and india is also the country with highest english speaker.

  • george prince
    george prince Day ago

    Sorry India no more in close relation with Nepal

  • Sciencelover
    Sciencelover Day ago

    Looks like a propaganda spreading video against India.

  • Anand Shridhar
    Anand Shridhar Day ago

    Good on you for trying but a lot of your video is based on very poor research and wildly incorrect assumptions sadly....

  • Mayank Singh
    Mayank Singh Day ago

    India is still a bad place for business and then there is corruption and our education system kills innovations

  • Ashwin Narayanan

    Another stupid thing is most of the rural population doesn't speak English. Outsourcing is hardly a contributing factor in to our economy.

    • Ashwin Narayanan
      Ashwin Narayanan Day ago

      I am unsubscribing this channel after watching this video as you proved you are plain stupid and unreliable source of information.

  • Ashwin Narayanan

    Who ever made this video is an illiterate idiot who knows nothing about India and China and the cultural relations between them since centuries. It was under the influence of India that Buddhism spread to Tibet China and Japan. India was a country even before British colonised it. This moron doesn't even know that the trading company of the British was called "East 'India' company". Just go through the history books again to learn the cultural ties between India and China. How many of the Chinese came to Indian universities to study our culture. Also go to Indonesia Malaysia or Cambodia and find out why they have Hindu temples and who built them you will know what world class Navy we had. Do some research before making a video don't be so stupid.

  • Arun Kumar M S
    Arun Kumar M S Day ago

    Totally reinforces all the colonial historical lens. Definitely great "research". "Indian navy was never world class and Indian kingdoms didn't have colonies". Downright lie. A Kerala king defeated the Dutch East India Company in a war. The Tamil kings conquered and ruled over much of southeast asia in 1500s

  • Aseem Sidhu
    Aseem Sidhu Day ago

    Incorrect there are many drivable bordercrossings between the two countires. I would suggest you do better research next time . FYI try googling Nathula Pass a lot of trade happens through that border crossing.

  • Hello Boy
    Hello Boy Day ago

    India is not so poor as you think..
    India is not so rich as think..
    India is diverse..
    You can find happy and healty poor people..
    Opposite rich people

  • Hello Boy
    Hello Boy Day ago

    British took everything from india.. but they forgot to take english back

    AND THATS A BIG MISTAKE

  • raghu karthik
    raghu karthik Day ago

    many mistakes

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    100000000000%true

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    100000000000%true

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    100000000000%true

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Chuddam valla doubts lo enta nijam undo...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Prajalara mee mundu open challenge...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Kaneesam manushullagaina pudatharu..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Tarvata putte pillalina gorrella kaakunda..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Rating ichukomani ch*eppu...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Edina practicalee kada..

    • birkuri sharath
      birkuri sharath Day ago +1

      What happend..?i willl tell any thing practically..evari culture vaaridi..musli*m culture musli*ms de..s*t culture s*t de...hindu culture hindus de..evari culture evariki set kaadu..

    • Avidi Arshid
      Avidi Arshid Day ago

      birkuri sharath u r embarrassing indians, guddhu na kodaka

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Valla baryalan*u pampinchamani cheptunna...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath Day ago +1

    Vellaku na mog*atanam chutney meeda doubt undanta..

  • dhaval dalasaniya

    This is not India what you explained ... totally wrong sorry

  • TJ TeagueTaco
    TJ TeagueTaco Day ago

    Indians get so triggered lmao. I've just been laughing and reading their comments for ages. How interesting...

    • TJ TeagueTaco
      TJ TeagueTaco 16 hours ago

      Avidi Arshid I work for myself. I won't work for an Indian

    • Avidi Arshid
      Avidi Arshid Day ago

      TJ TeagueTaco I want u to laugh when u work for an Indian in future

  • Gaurishankar Bodra

    Another propaganda, the speaker is an asshole, they know about shit about India.

  • Legendary Rebel
    Legendary Rebel Day ago +1

    Dear India! Sorry our stupid, oppressive, shameful, occupying, unelected, unequal, queen/king system land grabbed and tried to rule (while not giving a true shit about domestic issues back home)  your 3rd world lands! The British Empire was always an unnecessary burden (occupation) on the normal people, while the select few royals gain from it!

    • Legendary Rebel
      Legendary Rebel 23 hours ago

      Your crappy country is really divided between rich and poor, even where I live in the four countries (UK) we have rich/poor but not to the slums extent that you have there. Teresa May doesn't always know what she's doing, and her initiating small contracts (what ever level) is NOT a huge priority for England. I understand the annoyance about the occupation/rule by the British Empire (believe me I hate it,  just like many other English, Welsh, Scottish and Irish) it was unnecessary, wasteful and oppressive. The Queen's a cunt, along with her Monarch, many people here think it. You should be worried about the Pakis raping your land and nuking you!

    • Avidi Arshid
      Avidi Arshid Day ago

      your sh1t aid never reached indian government and it only went to your british NGOs only god know what they have done with it. Thaz why ouu former finance minister told it to ban it, and yet your government keep feeding those british NGOs for some reason. U need to ask your sh1tty government.
      sh1tty india? thatz why your PM teresa may came here to beg for more trade deals? glad we told her to fck off back to her small island. LArge majority of indians hate and despise britian for keep stereotyping india as a land of poverty even after reducing poverty from 98 percent to 22 percent.
      india cant be poor, indai has poor people of around 447 million, and the rest are living in middle class life of about 862 million. Your government with your media has only keep focusing on 447 million poor people while totally ignoring the other 862 million people and have destroyed india's image all over the world .
      *WE WILL MAKE UK PAY FOR THIS. THATZ WHY OUR LEADERS HAVE PUT HIGH TARIFFS ON EACH AND EVERY COMMODITY OF UK, MAKING IT IMPOSSIBLE TO COMPETE IN INDIAN MARKET. TRADE BAN IS ONLY THE BEGINNING. WE WILL MAKE SURE U WILL THOROUGHLY ENJOY BREXIT*

    • Legendary Rebel
      Legendary Rebel Day ago

      Fuck you paki cunt! I don't care about what the occupation did/resources wasted on the British Empire, while people here in the four countries suffer and are live with a reputation that we like land grabbing and being part of some Queens dog empire! Your home land (India or the newer Paki.) has always been shitty, poor and divided, regardless of who wastes money or English, Welsh, Scottish or Irish troops are stationed there!

    • Avidi Arshid
      Avidi Arshid Day ago

      Legendary Rebel fcking scum, when British occupied india, it was 2nd richest country in the world, when they left, they made india poorest in the World. Go read some history.
      Your industrial revolution was all possible because of Indian looted money

  • Saki Mcbill
    Saki Mcbill Day ago

    The biggest foreign influence China had was Buddhism and this came from India!

  • Avirup Nandi
    Avirup Nandi Day ago

    Seems like some baldheaded Britisher have cooked up a spicy Biriyani here.. ;)

  • Julia Clark
    Julia Clark Day ago

    Wow. So much BS about urban and rural.

  • Denis Heraud
    Denis Heraud Day ago

    ....... LOL!

  • bhakta peter
    bhakta peter 2 days ago

    vedic and buddhist deities can be found in many parts of china. Bharata varsha included china the vedic kings ruled this area too long ago

  • gottmovie
    gottmovie 2 days ago +2

    FACT: All Indians stink.

  • Yo-sup Stahlin
    Yo-sup Stahlin 2 days ago +1

    you are an idiot. India had contacts with China for a very long time. with both included in silk trade to the rise of Buddhism and flow of teachings of saint confuscius to India. there are many people in India who still follow the path of saint confuscius

  • Aniket Sangwan
    Aniket Sangwan 2 days ago

    I've honestly never seen a dumber video. Almost makes me ashamed to call myself a geography major. Idk what the dude is trying to get across. The Thar desert is the same across both the borders and to suggest that this geography is leading to conflict between India and Pakistan is disgrace to politicial science. India's geography is a lot more varied than what the video tells and is agreeably, both an asset and a a challenge.

  • Ashutosh Shrivastava

    This is racist imperialist propaganda of divide and rule, native Indians always called themselves Bharatiya, hindu is arabic for Indie and hindi is india,this fascist propogandist needs to read sashi tharoors an era of darkness

  • Sanved pawar
    Sanved pawar 2 days ago

    I'm really tired. When China is shown, you show Shanghai and all the fancy cities and when you show India you show small villages and slums. Whatever happened to Mumbai, Delhi, Chennai, Kolkata, Banglore, Hyderabad, Pune, Nagpur........etc.

  • Shashwat Sharma
    Shashwat Sharma 2 days ago

    "The British Rule didnt last long" bitch pls retard.
    This is such a bull crap video ffs, get yourself educated dummy

    • Shashwat Sharma
      Shashwat Sharma 13 hours ago

      lol STFU
      when tf did I say that I hate brits?

    • TJ TeagueTaco
      TJ TeagueTaco 16 hours ago

      Shashwat Sharma You hate British people change it

    • Shashwat Sharma
      Shashwat Sharma Day ago

      lol what?
      what does me keeping MU pic has to be a problem?

    • TJ TeagueTaco
      TJ TeagueTaco Day ago

      Shashwat Sharma Why do you have a Manchester United picture. It is British, change it!

  • Linda P
    Linda P 2 days ago +4

    India is so filthy, been there once and would never go there again....

    • Avidi Arshid
      Avidi Arshid Day ago +1

      Linda P let me guess, u only went to old Delhi and 9 out of 29 underdeveloped states like up(Varanasi), rajestan etc.
      Oh we won't miss u though

  • King Speedy
    King Speedy 2 days ago

    india is the most ugliest,filthy n populated country on the planet.

  • Indifferentass
    Indifferentass 2 days ago

    Wendover productions you generally research and research in an unbiased way but this unresearched biased piece of work really shows your lack of even basic facts. This is really disappointing I really enjoyed your videos but this video really disappointed me.

  • rakesh mandal
    rakesh mandal 2 days ago

    Every knowledgeable person should dislike the video ..as it full of incorrect information and baised one..

  • VladiSSius
    VladiSSius 2 days ago

    pls make Indonesia's geography problem next one.

  • Sam Grima
    Sam Grima 2 days ago +3

    India is shit hole

    • Avidi Arshid
      Avidi Arshid Day ago

      Sam Grima sh1thole india your country is begging to do trade

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    1000000000000%true

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    10000000000%true

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    1000000000000%trur

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Asale jaathini vadilip*ettanu..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Naato geluk*kunte cinema ilane vuntadi..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Nannu gelukunnaru kada anni jaathul*ni thokkesta....

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Meeru ekkite nenu meeku min*denni...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Mayy*ara naa kodukulu..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Mee jaat*hiki telivi thetalu undavu..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Telan*gana chilla*ra naa kodukulu..

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Situation taggattu ave bayataki vastayi...

  • birkuri sharath
    birkuri sharath 2 days ago +1

    Cheppanu kada anni angles naalone unnayi..

  • Bhrigu Roy
    Bhrigu Roy 2 days ago

    The research that has gone behind this video is half baked. The perspective biased and a tone rather disrespectful. It is quite surprising how easy it is to misinform everyone with biased opinions about things you do not understand. Superficial racist researchers with no knowledge of Indian history were probably given the task of making this video. I bet they have never even come to India.

  • knowledge seeker
    knowledge seeker 2 days ago

    the industrial revolution in the UK is because of Bengal(Bangladesh) wealth

  • sahil singh
    sahil singh 2 days ago

    Chola Navy actually made punitive expedition against various south east Asian states, even transporting troops which fought battles and sacked cities.
    It's just that Indian history is one of the most less known history.

  • Gogeta Gamer
    Gogeta Gamer 2 days ago

    it was supposed to be about geography.. not history

  • XT Wang
    XT Wang 2 days ago

    2:41 That's Montreal!

  • nitz vision
    nitz vision 2 days ago

    I came here for geography class as title suggest end up listening Western ignorant British influenced history 😂