Statistical Paradoxes with MinutePhysics - SciShow Talk Show

Share
Embed
  • Published on May 24, 2017
  • Henry Reich of MinutePhysics and MinuteEarth talks about statistical paradoxes and quantum entanglement. Afterwards, Jessi from Animal Wonders joins the show with two Red-Footed Tortoises!
    Henry Reich's Channels:
    MinutePhysics: www.TVclip.com/MinutePhysics
    MinuteEarth: www.TVclip.com/MinuteEarth
    Animal Wonders: www.TVclip.com/AnimalWondersMontana
    ----------
    Support SciShow by becoming a patron on Patreon: www.patreon.com/scishow
    ----------
    Dooblydoo thanks go to the following Patreon supporters-we couldn't make SciShow without them! Shout out to Kevin, Bealer, Mark Terrio-Cameron, KatieMarie Magnone, Patrick Merrithew, Charles Southerland, Fatima Iqbal, Sultan Alkhulaifi, Tim Curwick, Scott Satovsky Jr, Philippe von Bergen, Bella Nash, Bryce Daifuku, Chris Peters, Patrick D. Ashmore, Piya Shedden, Charles George
    ----------
    Looking for SciShow elsewhere on the internet?
    Facebook: facebook.com/scishow
    Twitter: twitter.com/scishow
    Tumblr: scishow.tumblr.com
    Instagram: instagram.com/thescishow

Comments • 895

  • Evie Elliot Gerzio
    Evie Elliot Gerzio 9 days ago

    Beautiful creatures 😍❤❤❤

  • Gianna Hayes
    Gianna Hayes 28 days ago

    Imagine if a drunk person tried to say statistics

  • Jim Shoe
    Jim Shoe Month ago

    This hurts my brain

  • Tyrannasaur Russ
    Tyrannasaur Russ Month ago

    I got the bird treatment once, I wouldn't recommend it....

  • LA Turley
    LA Turley Month ago

    I had a really good opinion about the host until this episode. I can't put my finger on it, but there is something not quite right about the guests (really off putting). Other than this, he's very informative and a great teacher.

  • Robin Chesterfield
    Robin Chesterfield Month ago

    Why are the EPIC TORTOISE FIGHTS over random fruit pieces so adorable? XD

  • ok
    ok Month ago

    35 min video about statistical paradoxes and 25 mins of it is watching tortoises eat grapes. Great use of my time!

  • Rhonda Lathbury
    Rhonda Lathbury Month ago

    How does she lay eggs there tough. I know that they are wet and soft then get a little harder as the eggs dry but her poor tail. Awwww

  • Michael Skinner
    Michael Skinner 2 months ago

    🤔

  • archmad
    archmad 2 months ago

    Remember how this guy remove comments section on "Are University Admissions Biased?" video?

  • Nerdee79
    Nerdee79 2 months ago

    I couldn't follow that "treatment" metaphor at all.

  • Fabien Niñoles
    Fabien Niñoles 2 months ago

    Simpson's paradox isn't the statistical equivalent of the generality fallacy? The part can be different than the whole if carefully chosen.

  • Zom Bee Nature
    Zom Bee Nature 2 months ago +2

    I have two versions of a video on my channel of two water turtles mating in an aquarium and I didn't realize that turtles have their cloaca at the top of their tails! I knew it looked that way but thought the actual tip was hidden.
    It's interesting to find out it's much different.

    • Zom Bee Nature
      Zom Bee Nature 2 months ago

      THIS episode showed me why I should _NOT_ get a tortoise: I don't want to be constantly cleaning up tortoise poop.

  • shadowpod13
    shadowpod13 3 months ago

    17:00 "This is Yuka, and this is Tidus."
    Uh... Is someone who names your tortoises a Final Fantasy X fan? Because other than Yuna being spelled with a "K" instead of a "N" your tortises are the main couple of FF X.
    ... Or it could be that I've got FF X on the brain since I just started playing FF X Remastered and I love FF X.

  • Marshall Styczinski
    Marshall Styczinski 3 months ago

    Nice LEGO JWST on the shelf!

  • KelsaRavenlock
    KelsaRavenlock 3 months ago

    you should have had somebody from HuffPost or Breitbart come on to talk about statistics they both seem to have many experts at manipulating them.

  • fyukfy
    fyukfy 3 months ago

    Isn't Simpson's paradox the basis for gerrymandering?

  • brian554xx
    brian554xx 3 months ago

    Do tortoises not travel really far, or have we not watched them long enough?
    🤔

  • Nic
    Nic 4 months ago

    Statistics tell us that one in five are in the bottom 20 percent of their class.

  • Oskar Ström
    Oskar Ström 4 months ago

    Why would it be fair for universities to consider gender when reviewing applicants? Shouldn't it be purely merit based?

  • c s
    c s 4 months ago

    what about the variants or standard deviations?

  • Simon
    Simon 4 months ago

    I always have good humidity

  • ZergrushEddie
    ZergrushEddie 4 months ago

    This is why we have the term "lies, damn lies, and statistics." You can either infer too much or too little and get wildly different results. The "ornithology vs film school" is a great example of that. Pretty interesting to see the potholes of the field and how to successfully avoid them.

  • Ashmeed Mohammed
    Ashmeed Mohammed 4 months ago

    blown away by them eating lizards...

  • Ashmeed Mohammed
    Ashmeed Mohammed 4 months ago

    the statistical guy seems bored by the wildlife

  • Ashmeed Mohammed
    Ashmeed Mohammed 4 months ago

    legitimately blown away by the cloaca story...

  • king james488
    king james488 4 months ago

    lol... reish...
    and why is she petting a turtles shell? it's a shell!

  • blackkittyfreak
    blackkittyfreak 4 months ago +1

    Wow, I have never seen so much sexual tension between two straight males. Maybe they were both internally fangirling or something.

  • Stubby Legg
    Stubby Legg 4 months ago +2

    i love watching hanks mind get blown lol its adorable.... it poops out its tail?!!!!!! hahahahahaha

  • Tidus
    Tidus 4 months ago +1

    Bruh I’m a turtle

  • Holly Clark
    Holly Clark 4 months ago

    I love how excited he gets about Entanglement, I just wanna squeeze him 😂😊

  • TheCrakp0t
    TheCrakp0t 5 months ago +1

    This is particularly why gerrymandering is so insidious.

  • Phinehas Priest
    Phinehas Priest 5 months ago

    WHERE'S THE PARADOX?
    Too many TVclip video makers think "paradox" means confusing to simpletons.
    Simple way to show this card thing is not counter intuitive even:
    There are 2 colleges:
    A: Gets 99% of its students from a Scandinavian country and 1% from a central African country.
    B: Gets 1% of its students from a Scandinavian country and 99% from a central African country.
    Which colleges likely has more whites?
    Well, duh, A of course.
    What if I add information:
    A: Gets 99% of its students from a *97% white* Scandinavian country and 1% from a *2% white* central African country.
    B: Gets 1% of its students from a *98% white* Scandinavian country and 99% from a *3% white* central African country.
    Oh no, now that we mentioned the percentages of whites in the countries it is a PARADOX!!!
    No, only an idiot would get confused by somebody pointing out that B's Scandinavian country has a higher percentage of whites and B's African country has a higher percentage of whites, so, uhh does this mean B should have more whites attending?
    This is a simple example of weighted statistics:
    A: 99% x 97% + 1% x 2% ≈ 96% whites
    B: 1% x 98% + 99% x 3% ≈ 4% whites
    Most people naturally get weighted statistics. This video did NOT present a paradox, it sadly did not even present something that is counter-intuitive.

  • Falney
    Falney 5 months ago +3

    I was so disappointed when the camera focused on Henry and there wasn't a picture of a stick man on his chair.

  • base vegeta
    base vegeta 5 months ago +2

    Your a beast hank!!

  • Alexander Alexandrov
    Alexander Alexandrov 5 months ago

    Taken to an abstract level, there is no paradox here.
    There is no paradox here, despite the data being from the same source - changing the numbers and values of variables, changes the problem, which changes the result.

  • andrewxc1335
    andrewxc1335 5 months ago +2

    It was funny to watch Hank's head explode as he was trying to figure out the evolutionary gymnastics that tortoises had to endure to make the cloaca work.

  • Meme lord
    Meme lord 5 months ago +1

    The interactions between them feels tense

  • Simon Moore
    Simon Moore 5 months ago +1

    Oooo I sensed some odd tension from 0:35 - 0:49 😯🙊

  • Jake Parker
    Jake Parker 5 months ago

    Absolutely blew my mind!!!!

  • Jeff Taylor
    Jeff Taylor 5 months ago

    Such a great show, love how ya'll make science right in front of us!

  • TheNicholasWayne
    TheNicholasWayne 6 months ago

    I wonder what this guys diet/exercise is like hes got some serious veins coming through those arms.

  • Speed Demo
    Speed Demo 6 months ago +1

    Two intellectual beings discussing about statistical paradoxes in wage gaps and gender deviation in universities.
    Feminists: Women still get paid $0.69 for $1.00

  • Raul Reza
    Raul Reza 6 months ago +2

    I came here for math and I stayed for the tortoise

  • Haakon Dahl
    Haakon Dahl 6 months ago

    11:05 Various phalluses? Oh, sorry.

  • Haakon Dahl
    Haakon Dahl 6 months ago +2

    The black cards don't get admitted to college. Figures. Racists.

  • Kindlesmith80
    Kindlesmith80 7 months ago

    Not much of a paradox; you are looking for different things statistically using different variables.

  • iamsam 1
    iamsam 1 7 months ago

    It's to early for all this. My brain checked out.

  • Youse Jose
    Youse Jose 7 months ago

    Why does onion make you cry?

  • Apiwat Chantawibul
    Apiwat Chantawibul 8 months ago

    30:14 loop = rave party

  • Evi1M4chine
    Evi1M4chine 8 months ago +1

    *Uum, Mr Reich, shouldn’t people get into university based on how GOOD they are?* Not based on their unrelated sexual organs? … Because what you describe as “fair”, aka quotas, is actually *textbook sexism.* No matter which bits of organs got an unfair advantage out of it.

  • Ross Betts
    Ross Betts 8 months ago

    Swiss army tail

  • Nmethyltransferase
    Nmethyltransferase 8 months ago

    Why does ketamine work (whereas memantine fails) for depression?

  • E Kramer2
    E Kramer2 8 months ago

    They are adorable!

  • Andrew Church
    Andrew Church 8 months ago

    Sci Show guy didn’t get the point, kept injecting his own thoughts on stat fallacies, all good BUT Simpson’s paradox is WORTH getting right in a simple succinct short episode, you and NAIL IT! (do they still say that?)

  • Andrew Church
    Andrew Church 8 months ago

    this makes a total mess explaining Simpson’s Paradox. Sic Show, you SHOULD red do it. Easiest was it to compare the success rate of two doctors, based on two procedures, heart surgery and bandaid removal, thanks to MIT probability Lecture mooc. Here it becomes obvious how the best doctor has worst stats when you give just the total percentage success rate, while performing better in both categories.

  • skylar ainsworth
    skylar ainsworth 8 months ago

    am i the only one who noticed him flicking his tounge the whole video?

  • HeatherCatherine
    HeatherCatherine 8 months ago

    I like the statistics (especially the banter about trying to explain reasoning for quantum entanglement) and the Tortoises. I used to watch mine try to eat for hours it really is entertaining.

  • Scruffy Mopplidge
    Scruffy Mopplidge 8 months ago +1

    A physicist and a statistician sit down in a room. They have great chemistry.
    Thank you.

  • rosenracht
    rosenracht 8 months ago

    This is that Mentat thinking.

  • ASTMA193
    ASTMA193 9 months ago

    Very interesting.

  • Dogesky
    Dogesky 9 months ago

    Our entire existence can be visualized using a deck of cards.

  • Matthew Nighbert
    Matthew Nighbert 9 months ago

    "That is bizarre."

  • Matthew Nighbert
    Matthew Nighbert 9 months ago

    "... like, "WAAAAAAAAHHHH!"

  • finalbossd
    finalbossd 9 months ago

    At 14:45, if you sum all the probabilities of all possible license plates, you will get 1, therefore there is some permutation of letters you are guaranteed to have, albeit unlikely for each individual license plate.

  • Bobby Bax
    Bobby Bax 9 months ago

    The guy on the left is the husband.

  • Mr Niceguy
    Mr Niceguy 9 months ago

    Set the speed to 1,25 to hear Henrys original voice

  • wellusee
    wellusee 9 months ago

    My brain si overhetin ... my brn s ovrhtng ..... m brn i ....

  • adan adanmendez
    adan adanmendez 9 months ago

    You, Hank Green are fantastic, and I apologize because I am not going to rewind the video. But the animal handler is always awesome and just my opinion, this show always has fantastic guests. Thanks for the educational videos. 🍻

  • sclassicallyme
    sclassicallyme 9 months ago

    So, this episode was amazing. Quantum entanglement and tortoise relations, an altogether wonderful bit of wtf.

  • mark yisser
    mark yisser 9 months ago

    hank... i think you have some colored blood in you.
    just realizing how big those lips are... lol
    you look taller than i thought too.

  • mark yisser
    mark yisser 9 months ago

    it's nice to see you guys from different channels come together and work as a team.
    i like that unity. no need to hate each other . if you were rappers there would be all kinds of hate among each other. good way to personify your intelligence.

  • Mark Nicholson
    Mark Nicholson 9 months ago

    Henry and Hank in the same video...I'm creaming my pants.

  • Soulz TheYoshi
    Soulz TheYoshi 9 months ago +1

    I love how absolutely enamored hank is by the cloaca facts

  • pokelover223
    pokelover223 9 months ago

    I hate statistics!!

  • JawAdrian
    JawAdrian 9 months ago

    Am I the only one who failed to see how the title related to the video?

  • shared psfour
    shared psfour 9 months ago

    "Blacks not getting in." -Minute Physics

  • Anthony Morton
    Anthony Morton 9 months ago

    Way too high for this....my mind is blown

  • Sirake
    Sirake 9 months ago

    Of every person in all of time, I was born me and now. Improbable things happen.

  • Andrew Church
    Andrew Church 9 months ago

    Hey, DEMONSTRATE the paradox with example, show HOW two data sets can both show one thing, then show the opposite when combined! tvclip.biz/video/BABu3bNoaBg/video.html this guy does a good job 👍

  • Sirena Chantal
    Sirena Chantal 9 months ago

    In the first segment, why would anyone call this equal? Why is logic not being combined with statistics? It's only equal if there are 50% male and 50% female students in the seats of the classes. To get that, admissions would have to change so that the group with fewer submissions would have more admitted. It's less of a paradox when you look at the final results. I hope universities aren't using this as an excuse.

  • Galaxis
    Galaxis 10 months ago

    just couldn't make it through. This whole thing needs to be 15 minutes, not 35

  • KendrixTermina
    KendrixTermina 10 months ago

    The part with the tortoises was almost cooler than the main event.

  • Im Simmin
    Im Simmin 10 months ago

    I live in the caribbean and have had 3 of these as pets, when she said they eat fox feces.... they also eat dog feces, also the part about them having different personalities is so true, one would literally be like a dog, if i went out into my yard and called its name, it would come out of the bushes to greet you, but another hated interaction with people, so i would have to go digging in the bush to find her.

  • swapertxking
    swapertxking 10 months ago

    this was a weird video, at first it was what I came for... then the turtle stuff happened and I was so lost.

  • Mayapurcandra Das
    Mayapurcandra Das 10 months ago +2

    some sort of ..... tension in that room.. hmmmm

  • mortaché de muerte
    mortaché de muerte 10 months ago

    i have a pet turtle for 5 years and i never noticed that it poops from its tail!

  • Aleksa Kole
    Aleksa Kole 10 months ago +3

    at 21:30 they ask, "How do you tell the boys from the girls."
    Well, generally boys DON'T lay eggs. :D :P

    • Zach
      Zach 8 months ago +2

      Aleksa Kole that's convenient, if you find a turtle in the wild just hope it's the right time of year and wait for it to lay eggs.

  • Baka Neko
    Baka Neko 10 months ago

    I'm in at about 13-14 minutes and I think a simplified version of what you guys are talking about is "look at this equation x = 2 + y and once we know what y (observed one photon) is x (other photon) has been defined"

  • Nate Hladki
    Nate Hladki 10 months ago

    Hank helping the tortoise eat was so cute and funny at the same time.

  • turtletowers
    turtletowers 10 months ago

    I am enjoying watching these turtles eat, far too much.

  • Hard Boyle
    Hard Boyle 10 months ago

    that poor table

  • ripvanwho
    ripvanwho 10 months ago

    swissarmy tail

  • CatherineZ
    CatherineZ 10 months ago

    Good statistics: proving human common sense is mostly good at mundane tasks, and often fails miserably at what it was not used to historically. We are not the best tools to estimate stuff, it's that human quality that made us invent science. Which is a way to look at the world, looking for its truth, while trying to remove all human bias.

  • Rowan Streeter
    Rowan Streeter 10 months ago

    At 7 minutes I realised Henry keeps licking his lips when he's talking... and now I can't stop seeing him doing it. Lost all attention to the content after that point.

  • Jay H
    Jay H 10 months ago

    29:20 hank says "... but they find it...." hahahaha.

  • daisykicker
    daisykicker 10 months ago

    "Do you....do you wanna meet an animal?" That doesn't sound shady 😂😂

  • Don Wald
    Don Wald 10 months ago +2

    Watch John squirm with the concept of "women possibly not discriminated against!"

  • Benjamin Cronce
    Benjamin Cronce 10 months ago

    So many people tell me to never do averages of averages unless they're weighted, but Simpson's paradox seems to be an example of where the opposite is true.

  • Jon Penn
    Jon Penn 10 months ago

    Well you can't never let anything happen to him. Then nothing would ever happen to him. Not much fun for little Harpo.