Everything Wrong With The Shining in Murderous Minutes or More

  • Published on Nov 5, 2019
  • Visit mubi.com/cinemasins
    With the support of Creative Europe - MEDIA Programme of the European Union.
    The Shining rules. But since the sequel is coming soon we did our duty and went looking for sins. Found some. I bet you're surprised.
    Thursday: Holiday sins.
    Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
    Patreon: www.patreon.com/CinemaSins
    Podcast: soundcloud.com/cinemasins
    TVSins: tvclip.biz/channel/UCe4bOvc1mYxFcQ5xPb9Zmow
    MusicVideoSins: tvclip.biz/channel/UCUBq8oBRVTsMpjWiHfjJpDw
    Jeremy: cinemasins
    Barrett: musicvideosins
    Aaron: aarondicer
    Jonathan: samloomis13
    Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasins-store
    Subreddit: reddit.com/r/cinemasins
    Website: cinemasins.com
    SinCast Facebook page: SinCastCinemaSins
  • Film & AnimationFilm & Animation

Comments • 3 772

  • Ron Mani
    Ron Mani Day ago

    okay... again. do you actually WATCH the movies you sin? There are so many things here you call a sin that if you watched the entire movie they make sense. Also, its not fair to call a sin based on the way we do things today as opposed to what was the norm back in the time a movie is set.

  • Mr J
    Mr J Day ago

    I literally held my breath as the Sins reached 36 and was disappointed a lot when they crossed 37...

  • SirBrianDaLion
    SirBrianDaLion Day ago

    Lots of your questions could be answered by reading the book (scrapbook, man in the dog costume, etc)

  • Playlist
    Playlist Day ago

    Okay sooooo most of these sins can go away kf youve read the book. Alot is cut out in the movie, things are left in with no context, because the book has way more detail.

    • Ken Hollis
      Ken Hollis Day ago

      That's right, but a movie should be able to stand on its own.

  • Mark Taylor
    Mark Taylor Day ago

    Haha, I just bought Arizona Jeans from JC Penny.

  • AtiTheDuck ree
    AtiTheDuck ree Day ago

    I’ve actually been to the hotel where this movie was filmed for my dad and Stepmom’s wedding which was like eight years ago

  • TheAlexpub
    TheAlexpub 2 days ago

    Wow a Stanley Kubrick movie. You must be really desperate. What's next? Barry Lyndon.

  • Goat Warrior
    Goat Warrior 2 days ago

    Pretty sure they stocked the freezer before they closed because they know there's a family going to be living there with little access to grocery stores for the next 6 months.

  • Ricardo Torres
    Ricardo Torres 3 days ago

    The actresses who played the ghosts of the murdered Grady daughters, Lisa and Louise Burns, are identical twins; however, the characters in the book and film script are merely sisters, not twins. In the film's dialogue, Mr. Ullman says he thinks they were "about eight and ten".

  • Jarryd Smith
    Jarryd Smith 4 days ago +1

    I would have thought Grady dropping the n-word might have been worth a sin or two.

  • Molly Fowles
    Molly Fowles 4 days ago

    anyone here cuz they CANT watch this?

    • abcd efgh
      abcd efgh 3 days ago

      Molly Fowles why cant you?

  • Pavel R.
    Pavel R. 4 days ago

    Jeremy sinning the shinning for things that he mostly disagrees with/dislikes vs sinning for discrepancies within the movie itself is a sin.

    • Ken Hollis
      Ken Hollis Day ago

      It's meant to be humorous, not a completely professional movie critique.

  • Bill Clay
    Bill Clay 5 days ago +3

    Jesus Christ is Lord, not a swear word.

    • Bill Clay
      Bill Clay Day ago

      @Ken Hollis ...and that's what makes the world such a special place, for you and for me and the entire human race. Jesus Christ will return shortly. Be ready. God bless.

    • Ken Hollis
      Ken Hollis Day ago

      Not everyone agrees.

  • wayne ruddock
    wayne ruddock 5 days ago

    This makes CimSin more attentive than grumpy moon landing faking Kubrick... 'Oh yes!!

  • wayne ruddock
    wayne ruddock 5 days ago

    I'm already chuckling before I've even watched this video

  • Lexi Lol
    Lexi Lol 5 days ago

    do you think the ghosts are making him crazy and telling him to kill his family? or just by being alone, he is going crazy and seeing imaginary people (the ghosts) that tell him to kill his family? We'll never know ig.

    • Ken Hollis
      Ken Hollis Day ago

      The book makes it clear that the hotel itself is a living entity and making Jack crazy.

  • Stephanie Baker
    Stephanie Baker 5 days ago

    It's not that unusual to hear weather reports about other states. I'm in California, an we're well aware on the polar vortex going on on the East coast.

  • Maria Cowle
    Maria Cowle 5 days ago

    You guys really need to get on the found flix channel. It explains this movie in detail and it actually makes so much more sense!.

  • Hey YouTube
    Hey YouTube 6 days ago +4

    Fun Fact: In the maze scene all of the snow is actually salt.

  • Hey YouTube
    Hey YouTube 6 days ago +4

    Danny and Wendy, throughout the movie, tend to wear a lot of red and blue colours, to represent the twins with their blue dresses and red blood.

  • Jose California
    Jose California 6 days ago

    Tuesday ?lol best line

  • colin gibson
    colin gibson 7 days ago +2

    I'm not watching this, but I hope he doesn't say anything about the layout of the hotel, because its intentionally bullsh*t.

  • Keyla Auikyani
    Keyla Auikyani 7 days ago

    I read somewhere that the furry bear fellatio it's a reference to Danny being abused by his das, due to the many bear references in Dannys rooms both on the hotel and his Home. But i'm not really sure, just found it an interesting theory

    • Ken Hollis
      Ken Hollis Day ago

      Eh, that's an interesting theory as far as the movie goes, but the "dog man" scene does happen in the book, and the book makes no reference to stuffed dogs or sexual abuse; quite the contrary, the book makes it clear that Jack loves his son in the healthiest way possible and that his alcoholism was his only problem before arriving at the hotel.

  • 1 million subscribers with no videos

    2:56 he was assuming the age of the twins, not saying one girl was 10 and the other was 8, we was guessing the age

  • Soul resonance
    Soul resonance 7 days ago +1

    If you want to do another Stanley Kubrick movie you should do full metal jacket

  • Ricky Got
    Ricky Got 7 days ago

    I feel CinemaSins made lots of assumptions thinking there were actual ghosts in the movie and that CinemaSins knew what what accruing.

  • nepali choro
    nepali choro 7 days ago

    I don’t get is how is this move terrifying ?
    Everything is average, kid acting is horrible. Scenes of 2 kids, bloods flooding, kid trying to make another voice. I find it too cringe.
    dumb boomers loved this crap 💩

    • Ken Hollis
      Ken Hollis Day ago

      And dumb zoomers think "cringe" is an adjective.

  • HerecomesawildRUS
    HerecomesawildRUS 7 days ago

    Theres so much different stuff in this move. From Jack and wendys hair color to the room number and how many times the two girls are mentioned

    FOOEL 7 days ago

    15:03 This was always my question too

  • Tevin Landry
    Tevin Landry 8 days ago +1

    I agree...
    ...that naked woman DID have a nice beave lol.

  • Felipa Shark
    Felipa Shark 8 days ago

    You forgot the shadow of the hellacopter

  • hcastelvetere
    hcastelvetere 8 days ago

    DUDE you literally made a sin over them having to much kool aid

  • kay
    kay 9 days ago

    now you're REQUIRED to do doctor sleep

  • Booker Jones
    Booker Jones 9 days ago +1

    Lucky me; I was working in a movie theater where this was playing on release. The manager told us the book was the scariest thing she'd ever read and got us all worked up to see it. So we all did, and were like, "This?" "The book was scarier," she said weakly.

    I think at some point Kubrick's career strategy was to create films that would be lukewarmly received when released, then reassessed later on and discussed forever by film critics/students/laymen aficionados. Which is pretty clever, and just what happened. Back then, people said, "Why would Kubrick make a 'Barry Lyndon' with no erotic life?" "Why would he do a Stephen King adaptation that isn't frightening?" Again, I think because, while the lack of scariness would disappoint contemporary audiences, the absence of that distraction makes it easier for later generations to have a perfectly lovely time analyzing all of those impressive visuals and details for their "meaning"; and in that sense it's actually a plus that they're all disconnected and don't cohere and accumulate in a way that builds even elementary suspense, much less terror.

    There are good things in the movie--Shelley Duvall's performance, for example; it was the only thing that made me "feel" the horror of the situation; of course the manuscript scene, a few other tidbits (certainly not the oceans of red-colored corn syrup cascading out of a freaking elevator) But it wasn't and isn't scary. Scary is like funny; it either is or isn't right then; it doesn't become scary or funny years later after talking about it a whole bunch. And despite the impressiveness of all those patented Kubrick touches scattered here and there throughout, it is a fact that "The Shining" fails at the primary job of the genre: if I haven't been clear enough, let me repeat: it isn't scary.

  • The Fucking Third Reich

    Now you have to do Doctor Sleep,the sequal of The Shining *AFTER NEARLY 40 FUCKING YEARS JUST TO MAKE A SEQUAL OF THE SHINING*

  • Liana H
    Liana H 9 days ago +1

    Y'all know a sequel can't be good when it comes out 40 years later... Nobody wanted Dr. Sleep man 🤢

    • Ken Hollis
      Ken Hollis Day ago

      Apparently they did, because the whole reason King wrote Doctor Sleep was because the most common question fans asked him was, "What ever happened to little Danny Torrance." Personally, I like the book very much, and the movie wasn't bad, either.

  • nickie tee
    nickie tee 9 days ago

    I can appreciate sinning based on what is actually IN the film, but, in case you didn't know... a ton of those images make sense based on the book. And it makes it all even creepier. Infamously, Stephen King wasn't too thrilled with Kubrick's interpretation. BUT, I will say that anytime they have tried to remain true to the book the movies were just dumb.

  • Vanessa Aiselbrown
    Vanessa Aiselbrown 9 days ago

    3:02 also, how did the hedges last that long? That hotel is stupid old, so there's no way the hedges could have lasted THAT long!

  • NawtNCosmic
    NawtNCosmic 9 days ago

    15:37 big fucking incorrect. torrance hates his son.

  • Spottedfeather
    Spottedfeather 10 days ago

    I found a sin...the way you pronounce Xavier...

  • WegZurHölle
    WegZurHölle 10 days ago

    7:10 pattern on the floor, dannys sweater.
    kubrik 2001
    also kubrik apollo filming, no matter what. it is odd why kubrik wanted exactly that.

  • lowrider993
    lowrider993 10 days ago

    Why is the sin counter sentient?

  • Koasters Incoming
    Koasters Incoming 10 days ago


  • Albino Cadillac
    Albino Cadillac 10 days ago

    That peer pressure line at the teins made me lose it

    AWAKE INDIAN 11 days ago

    He fucked the oldie for $$$

    AWAKE INDIAN 11 days ago

    What WTF wasn't HAL 9000 shutdown in 2001 🤣🤣🤣💣✌🏻

    AWAKE INDIAN 11 days ago

    Who is the sin counter ?

  • Jaxon Smith
    Jaxon Smith 11 days ago


  • jeepthing98
    jeepthing98 11 days ago

    The level of bourbon in the bottle changes during the bar scene. I noticed that because I was watching the bubbles pop out of the top.

  • William Warner
    William Warner 11 days ago

    Why would you sin this movie. Like Shrek, it has no problems

  • Troy Johnson
    Troy Johnson 11 days ago

    That was some of King's biggest beefs with thr movie. Jack was already nuts before even getting to the hotel. Wendy in the book is described more at a cheerleader type much hotter than the movie Wendy.

  • Cassidy Anthony
    Cassidy Anthony 11 days ago

    Everything wrong with...
    Desolation and before I wake.

  • Samuel Levy
    Samuel Levy 12 days ago

    I can’t believe you actually sinned the come and play with us Danny scene

  • Syntherus
    Syntherus 12 days ago

    A misconception is that Jack randomly goes crazy when other caretakers didn't. This isn't about the haunting. The hotel wants Danny because he has The Shining. This story is about the war between the hotel and Danny. Everyone else was just caught in the crossfire.

  • Cal Kramer
    Cal Kramer 12 days ago

    Cinemasins, can you please make an everything wrong with midsommar?

  • Terra Asara
    Terra Asara 12 days ago

    Your sin doesn't make any sense

  • Dakota Raymond
    Dakota Raymond 13 days ago

    I assume Jack showing up in the picture at the end is just symbolism of his soul being claimed by the hotel after he died.

  • Nikki Dejageh
    Nikki Dejageh 13 days ago

    you kinda sound like seth rogen

  • Paivi Project
    Paivi Project 13 days ago

    I've seen this movie ones many years ago and I showed this to my hubby so he would wanted to watch it with me but he didn't seem to be too excited gout it...dammit...but you never know maybe he will watch it with me one day. Thanks 👍

  • Dessert Snob
    Dessert Snob 13 days ago +4

    Imagine watching a movie with this guy...