In-N-Out Vs. Shake Shack Taste Test with Tom Segura | Sean in the Wild

  • Published on Dec 26, 2017
  • Which cult-favorite burger joint reigns supreme: Shake Shack or In-N-Out? It's an East Coast-West Coast rivalry that's raged in the fast-food world for years-and Sean Evans is here to get to the bottom of it. Joined by his buddy comedian Tom Segura, Sean pits French fry against French fry, cheeseburger against cheeseburger, and secret-menu item against secret-menu item to find out which chain deserves the crown. Will Tom become a Shake Shack convert, or remain an In-N-Out die-hard? Find out on an all new episode of SITW.
    Subscribe to First We Feast on TVclip:
    Check out more of First We Feast here:

    First We Feast videos offer an iconoclastic view into the culinary world, taking you behind-the-scenes with some of the country's best chefs and finding the unexpected places where food and pop culture intersect.
  • Howto & StyleHowto & Style

Comments • 4 564

  • James Latini
    James Latini 19 hours ago

    No need pointing out the obvious but a little biased

  • Pashmotatoe
    Pashmotatoe 2 days ago

    10:25 *Tom Segura Is In The Logang*

  • Exera80
    Exera80 5 days ago

    I wish we had Shake shack and In-N-Out in Norway :/

  • Dan Perry
    Dan Perry 8 days ago

    what kind of a psychopath doesn't put toppings on a burger???

  • David Fox
    David Fox 8 days ago

    I hope both of these guys have MIs and die...

  • Dandy Campusano
    Dandy Campusano 10 days ago

    I don't think is fair to be in L.A make this competition shake shack food its going to be cold af and not as good as it is

  • Steven French
    Steven French 10 days ago

    Um......five guys????

  • Nerdy White Guy
    Nerdy White Guy 17 days ago


  • john jones
    john jones 19 days ago

    You want a burger they stab a cow in the parking lot

  • Mott Dude
    Mott Dude 22 days ago

    If you’re debating who has the best burger the West Coast or the East Coast then the answer is obvious. You’ve never had a good burger. In the Midwest what we throw out as trash is what they serve at In and Out or Shake-shack. If you’ve never had a Jucy Lucy, Thurman Burger or a Mott Burger you don’t know what a good burger is and as for chain burgers...try Steak n Shake and you’ll forget all about second raters like In and Out or Shake Shack which are the east coast/west coast versions of White Castle by comparison. Hell Jollibees is better than then In and Out Burger.

  • MrJordanhead19
    MrJordanhead19 26 days ago

    Five Guys gang!

  • bluegreensubmarine
    bluegreensubmarine 27 days ago +4

    Peanut butter and beef? GTFO East Coast lol

  • PJ
    PJ 29 days ago

    Peanut butter on a burger is one of those things where you either haven't tried it yet, or you're in the secret club. You don't know why it works, it just does.

  • Raphael Gordh
    Raphael Gordh Month ago +2

    "Wow, you really went out of your way. Someone just got their yogurt out the fridge, I hope they come back. It's really really impressive, man." - Tom Segura

  • kandi cooper
    kandi cooper Month ago +1

    You can tell hes bias because those in-n-out burgers look dry as hell lol the shake shack looks better

  • ANDROID Bot.
    ANDROID Bot. Month ago

    Honestly I’m pretty biased against in and out but still it’s soooo good and has great childhood memories

  • Aly J
    Aly J Month ago

    Ok but what the fuck does animal style even mean? In N Out doesn’t exist in the Midwest 🤷🏼‍♀️

  • Aly J
    Aly J Month ago

    Never been to In N Out but all these youtubers make me wanna fly to Cali just to try it

  • Your Friendly Neighborhood Smark

    But in the end, we can all agree the Five Guys is king right? RIGHT?!

  • Your Friendly Neighborhood Smark

    In and Out don’t let you put bacon on your burgers. That automatically brings them down a peg no matter how good their animal style is

  • jabba978
    jabba978 Month ago +1

    In-N-Out is overrated...

    Sorry California

  • brinks5555
    brinks5555 Month ago

    This shit was biased from the beginning

  • Niro HAY
    Niro HAY Month ago

    Not really objective review by the way...

  • Raven 212
    Raven 212 Month ago

    Even though I am a beast coast all day err' day guy. In n out will always my go to go place. Shake shack even in Japan as well as recently in Changi Airport's Jewel in Singapore will never compare.

  • Gabriel Berki
    Gabriel Berki Month ago

    Tom Segura is a fucking fool.

  • Sean Hart
    Sean Hart Month ago

    Tom Segura is so funny.

  • Atb Illy
    Atb Illy 2 months ago

    When u realise that u never had a one of em :(
    Feelz bad man

  • Bryan Colliver
    Bryan Colliver 2 months ago

    I love in N Out but there fries suck

  • Pepe Shiraz
    Pepe Shiraz 2 months ago +2

    everything at in-n-out is literally half the price of its corresponding item at shake shack. nobody seems to mention this in arguments

  • Ross Salese
    Ross Salese 2 months ago

    five guys better than both

  • Moonrunner87
    Moonrunner87 2 months ago

    Until I have In n out it’s shake shack for me on the east coast.

  • Jesse Lieberman
    Jesse Lieberman 2 months ago

    News flash. They are both overrated we as fuck.

  • The Pope
    The Pope 2 months ago +1

    I still like five guys better

  • to_the_batmobile_
    to_the_batmobile_ 2 months ago +4

    The problem is the food has always been sitting for awhile before ppl start these videos

  • James Peters
    James Peters 2 months ago

    I don't think Sean knows that he should have pissed on and beat Tom. he really should have tried it out.

  • Mark McCaffery
    Mark McCaffery 2 months ago

    Cook Out puts them both to shame.

  • Galan Voorhis
    Galan Voorhis 2 months ago

    Smash is way better than shake shack

  • MaynardOwns
    MaynardOwns 2 months ago

    Fucking everyone wears bomber coats. Sure they've been around for ever. But I've been rocking my fucking jacket for a decade. mother fuckers biting my style. I really need a new one before next winter. I don't give a shit about what's cool and what's in or not. This instance, I'm hesitant to buy a new bomber. Unless I carry around my worn out, torn up, broken zippered, put a pack of smokes in the pocket pull them out of the sleeves o.g. bomber jacket I can't evenn claim I've been wearing bomber jackets exclusively for a decade without sounding like 1, a total douche bag and 2, a lying douchebag.
    I do like the leather one tho....

  • MaynardOwns
    MaynardOwns 2 months ago

    Loved in n out when I drove to the west years ago. They just opened a shake shack around here a year or a few years ago. I need to try it soon. Also, I ve heard steak n shake is the best.

  • Weston Atkins
    Weston Atkins 2 months ago

    silly americans! learning how to make a poutine

  • Rancimus
    Rancimus 2 months ago

    I have never had worse fast food fries than the one time I went to In N Out. They are tiny, dry, and bland. Absolutely awful. Wtf is wrong with you Californians?

  • Terrence Payne
    Terrence Payne 2 months ago

    In and out Fries seems better than shake shack. But I like Shake Shack burgers better.

  • Jackbe Nimble
    Jackbe Nimble 2 months ago

    dats some cold ass food. 100%

  • T Bone
    T Bone 2 months ago

    Just take the strings out of the hoodie Sean. The tuck in is weirding me out.

  • MR.223rem
    MR.223rem 2 months ago

    In this case innout over shitshack. Fudruckers RIP though. Five guys is better.

  • erinwalts27
    erinwalts27 2 months ago +64

    I worked at In-N-Out for 2 years and they truly treat their employees amazing. somehow working there made me appreciate the food even more, which doesn’t happen at a lot of fast food places. everything is fresh and clean. I’m ride or die for that company now lol

    • Bonzi Buddy
      Bonzi Buddy Month ago +1

      I worked fast food in another life... The making and breaking of the product that goes to the consumer is definitely on how management operates with the majority of emphasis on proper training, hiring and keeping on top of employees and try making it a place with decent morale. A good thing to help morale is treating employees with respect and paying them a little bit more than the competition and other options they could be lured away from.
      You'll get far better consistency if these rules are applied. Where there is a lack of leadership you will find chaos and crappy employees that go rogue doing things that will give the whole company a black eye when their behavior is exposed.
      Chick Fil A will tend to be on the better side of things because they vet owners (who can only own one single store) so they don't view their regional locations as just money making machines and view problems as something they don't need to deal with. In N Out is family owned and have high standards. I'm not sure about Shake Shack enough, but McDonalds, Burger King, Dominos.... you can get a serious mixed bag with those last 3. Seriously, you can get a whopper and say "Wow, that was good" and go to another location and have one of the worst things you've ever eaten in your life.

    • Jesse Mattingly
      Jesse Mattingly 2 months ago +9

      Im pretty jealous man, fast food employees usually get treated like dog shit by the employers and customers alike. I worked at a Dairy Queen years ago and they treated me like a convicted felon, which I am, but still.

  • Raul Paredes
    Raul Paredes 2 months ago +3

    Protein type style looks gang. Tom Burgers. I'm in

  • synergest1
    synergest1 2 months ago

    What a disappointing comparison, Dutchman against peanut butter bacon burger? Makes no sense

  • Dimitri
    Dimitri 2 months ago

    NO, I don't want to be a teacher. Also, I've never had In-n-Out but Shack is where its at no doubt

  • osvaldo hernandez
    osvaldo hernandez 3 months ago

    Biased ass guy, it’s like saying I’m from Chicago and people trying to convince me NY pizza better than Chicago lol gtfo

  • just a random guy
    just a random guy 3 months ago

    Tom wasn't kidding about killing Sean

  • William Bendele
    William Bendele 3 months ago +1

    In-N-Out vs Whataburger

  • Carlos Armenta
    Carlos Armenta 3 months ago +1

    Shake Shack by day, In-N-Out by night, ALL DAY!

  • Nelson Um
    Nelson Um 3 months ago

    They got no tastes bud wtf

  • A Bl
    A Bl 3 months ago

    in n out looks nasty as fuck

  • jace welsh
    jace welsh 3 months ago

    Flyin Dutchman is for gluten free people.

  • Marcus
    Marcus 3 months ago

    it looks like they choose the lamest burger off the shake shack menu

  • Andrew Nieto
    Andrew Nieto 3 months ago

    Curious about that peanut bacon burger but Im allergic to peanuts. Still going to try it if I can.

  • Chandler Smith
    Chandler Smith 3 months ago

    in n out is OVERRATED

  • djbarberomusic
    djbarberomusic 3 months ago +1

    This was a rip off review..the shack burger doesn't come plain. It comes with their own secret sauce and lettuce and tomato. Why would they ask for it plain and the in and out burger not?Bullshit review!

  • BryanKeithCunningham
    BryanKeithCunningham 3 months ago

    Considering I've never heard of shake shack imma go with in and out

  • Shaneaynay
    Shaneaynay 3 months ago

    Peanut butter on a cheeseburger is pretty damn good. Lay it on right under the cheese.

  • Mister Belvidere
    Mister Belvidere 3 months ago +2

    Shake shack is better, but both are over rated.

  • jacques-
    jacques- 3 months ago

    tom is byus

  • Luis Baez
    Luis Baez 3 months ago +28

    Im a New Yorker but when i visted LA and had that In N Out burger, i was just amazed on how good it is. Its indescribable. Shake Shack is good , but compared to In N Out its not that good.

    • Taha Kamran
      Taha Kamran Month ago

      Yea but their fries taste like Pokemon cards

  • Yaser Rahimi
    Yaser Rahimi 3 months ago

    Purest Stfu you stupid beep

  • Yaser Rahimi
    Yaser Rahimi 3 months ago

    Soo stupid he ordered two parties with cheese. Flying Dutchman are your stupid

  • Start Studying
    Start Studying 3 months ago

    Shake shack has BACON cheese fries too

  • Bluesteel
    Bluesteel 3 months ago

    Why do so many people lie about these two places. They aren't even comparable, shake shack has one of the greatest burgers on the planet, forget out fast food. Is it really just a twist regional loyalty that compels people? I don't get it at all and it's pretty messed up. Not at single item at in-n-out is even in the same ballpark as shake shack...shame on all of you for lying about fucking FOOD.

    • Leon Solis III
      Leon Solis III 3 months ago +1

      The hell, it's like people can't have preferences.
      I live in Dallas, New in and out just opened near me a couple weeks ago, had shake shack like 3 times before. To me, shake shack tries to pretend it's not a fast food place. It's like a high class McDonald's.
      In an out doesn't pretend it shows you what it is and gives you cheap good tasting burgers.
      Again, that's just my opinion, but I guess that makes me a liar.

  • Will
    Will 3 months ago

    Shake Shack is far superior.

  • Chris Cumming
    Chris Cumming 3 months ago

    Come to Toronto and have a religious burger experience at the Burgers Priest. Great secret menu items as well.

  • Stickey Notes2
    Stickey Notes2 3 months ago +1

    Five Guys is the best. Hands down. I've had In-N-Out and Shake Shack. They don't live up to the hype.

    • javier guy
      javier guy 3 months ago

      Five guys is trash and expensive

  • ArkRaider22
    ArkRaider22 3 months ago

    I'm from Australia and had heard so much hype surrounding In-N-Out. On my last trip to America I had to check it out but after I ordered it I was super disappointed. Do not understand the hype at all. Went to Shake Shack a few days later and was pleasantly surprised. Honestly though, there are so many burger places in my home city of Melbourne that I've been to that crush both of these places without question. Which feels weird to say because there's this notion that America has the greatest burgers. But for real, Australian burger culture is way better imo. Though it is generally more expensive in Australia.

  • John Weems.
    John Weems. 3 months ago

    In and out overated as all fuck good burgers terrible frys overhyped for sure

  • vietbond
    vietbond 3 months ago

    You didn't do the Shakes........

  • robvas
    robvas 3 months ago +1

    Rally’s/Checker’s is the king of cheap burgers. In-and-out is so forgettable.

  • Hey You
    Hey You 3 months ago +2

    Animal style isn't good fight me

  • Richie
    Richie 3 months ago

    What's fucked up is that they used Tom's old fat head photo hahaha.

  • Robert Botello
    Robert Botello 3 months ago

    The true winner is Whataburger

  • Jason May
    Jason May 3 months ago +4

    I had Shake Shack. It was good...not as good as it cost like $15.

    • Jason May
      Jason May 3 months ago

      @Bluesteel I prefer fresh produce on my burger. I also do not like the smashed patty with crispy edges.. These are just my prefrances.
      Shake Shack was a good burger but not worth the bill. Come on son.

    • Bluesteel
      Bluesteel 3 months ago +1

      Bullshit, it's not even close and if you've tried them both you know the only way you can say that in-n-out is even remotely comparable is if you are a liar who cares about something besides the actual food.

  • Frank Williams
    Frank Williams 3 months ago

    I’ve lived in the ATL all my life I know there’s a shake shack here but I’ve never eaten there cause it’s packed like a mf all the time so fuck that

  • John Ibarra
    John Ibarra 3 months ago +1

    Shouldve added Tommy's to the mix. Love me that greasy shit. But n out #1 always and forever like heatwave.

  • Daryl Dixon
    Daryl Dixon 3 months ago

    Never had either but I think I’d be a In N Out guy

  • Mr Nicks
    Mr Nicks 3 months ago +8

    Shake Shack Gang
    (only because I never lived in the west)

  • Hank Misson
    Hank Misson 3 months ago

    Shouldve gotten five guys its better than shake shack imo

  • Lmaze 797
    Lmaze 797 3 months ago

    Closest shake shack to me is 80 miles and the lines are to long and the closest in n out is around 4,500 miles

  • Factoid
    Factoid 3 months ago


  • Richard Vazquez
    Richard Vazquez 3 months ago

    People talking about whataburger or whatever, I didn’t event know that place existed and it’s 2019.

  • Humble Humility
    Humble Humility 3 months ago +1

    In n Out!!!!!!!!!

  • Papi Loco
    Papi Loco 3 months ago +2

    It shouldve been Five guys vs. In N Out

  • michael denino
    michael denino 3 months ago

    "Hey, do you want a salmon milkshake?"

  • Azaldi
    Azaldi 3 months ago

    Didn’t even get the Bacon Cheese Fries smh Sean tf didn’t even get ShackSauce double tf Sean.

  • Jasmine Edwards
    Jasmine Edwards 3 months ago

    Team shake shack😭

  • Jeffrey F
    Jeffrey F 3 months ago

    I think they are pretty equal, but for me I like Shake Shack taste better, but you can’t beat In-n-Out prices because you can get a burger and fries for a single shackburger

  • Brock Albert
    Brock Albert 3 months ago

    0:48...I love the way Tom is looking at Sean.

  • abel doe
    abel doe 4 months ago +1

    Bet everything was all cold and not at full potential

  • Walker Mudd
    Walker Mudd 4 months ago

    Biased af

  • Magucci13
    Magucci13 4 months ago

    Wendy's is better than in'n'out

  • MadeByDenim
    MadeByDenim 4 months ago +2

    Biase much!!! In n Out fries are so trash!!!
    5 Guys still the Best!!!

  • Varmando Varuso
    Varmando Varuso 4 months ago

    1:54 LOL