Coachella 2019: Ariana Grande Brings Out *NSYNC and Chokes Up During Mac Miller Tribute

  • Published on Apr 15, 2019
  • The pop star closed out the first weekend at the annual Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival in Indio, California.
    Exclusives from #ETonline :
  • MusicMusic

Comments • 865

  • Catherine Yim
    Catherine Yim 15 days ago

    She said “nace” LoL you mean NAZ?

  • wayamy27narf
    wayamy27narf 17 days ago

    If she replaces JT, their new name would be *ASYNC
    Lanceto...N (though, technically not his real name)

  • Rockie Kane
    Rockie Kane 25 days ago

    Ariana can't sing she sucks

  • Nalini Celebrating_Lyfe

    Go Ariana...

  • Taufik Rahman
    Taufik Rahman 27 days ago +1

    Ariana Grande s*cks!!! 😡

  • S CP
    S CP 27 days ago +4

    ?All of these clips are bad vocally? Like dry as if she really is bored... was that the whole show?

  • Allison Marbella
    Allison Marbella 27 days ago

    QUEEN!!!! 👑👑👑

  • TYG Vlogger
    TYG Vlogger 28 days ago +2

    "We cant hear anything"
    That was cute lol

  • u wish
    u wish 28 days ago

    +the LGBT flag

  • EE La
    EE La 28 days ago

    She did not perform One Last Time like wtf girl that one of you biggest song n you chose to do some boring new songs that no one can relate to.

  • Valeria Talavera
    Valeria Talavera 29 days ago


  • Jeremy Tate
    Jeremy Tate Month ago +2

    AG looks like a walking STD.

  • Leslie Salmeron
    Leslie Salmeron Month ago

    JC sounded Amazing!!!! He still got the moves too!! Loved their performance!! ❤️Nsync

  • Zuraily Gonzalez
    Zuraily Gonzalez Month ago

    Love Ariana soooooooooo much I wish I was there so bad😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

  • Santilla V.
    Santilla V. Month ago

    Alriiiiiight Ari.

  • Masha Mitchell
    Masha Mitchell Month ago +1

    Stop with arichella. It's unoriginal and thristy. You're not Beyonce.

  • Christopher Angeles
    Christopher Angeles Month ago +1

    Yes choke in stage !!

  • Christopher Angeles
    Christopher Angeles Month ago +2

    ????? What!!!!!!

  • Aicargalliv Nek
    Aicargalliv Nek Month ago

    That wistle note 🥰

  • George Navarro
    George Navarro Month ago

    I love ariana so much 💘

  • Shannon Feathers
    Shannon Feathers Month ago +2

    What a sweetheart! 💜 She gets better and better and Im def not a fan of boy/girl band/bubblegum poprock type of stuff, but shes different, shes a old soul, and very generous, really cares. Seems everytime " Bang Bang" is performed theirs a malfunction. Shes sweet! 💟

  • David Savage
    David Savage Month ago +2

    RIP XXX too

  • Greg Jones
    Greg Jones Month ago

    garbage feminazi thot

  • Miss X Awatere
    Miss X Awatere Month ago +1

    Coachella IS SOOOOOO Over rated 🤣🤣🤣🤣
    OneLove AOTEAROA

  • Sydney Noelle
    Sydney Noelle Month ago

    I forgot/didn't know she could dance

    • Jasmine Shelton
      Jasmine Shelton 15 days ago

      +Sydney Noelle yeah I guess she's not too bad at doing some of the poppy, fun 1-2-3 2 3 combos. I do like her choreographers though I don't know what the twins names are but they're cool

    • Sydney Noelle
      Sydney Noelle 15 days ago +1

      +Jasmine Shelton Well I wouldn't consider her a dancerI just think he doesn't suck...9 years of my life has been devoted to competetive dancing so I know shes not a dancer

    • Jasmine Shelton
      Jasmine Shelton 16 days ago

      +Sydney Noelle it was cute but she has even said yourself personally she prefers to sing on stage than focus on dancing. But I am a trained dancer and I will admit that I don't consider her much of a dancer but she is an incredibly talented singer and fabulous performer so it's not insulting what I'm saying

    • Sydney Noelle
      Sydney Noelle 21 day ago

      +Jasmine Shelton she was handling the NSYNC choreography pretty well I'm sure if she tried she could dance

    • Jasmine Shelton
      Jasmine Shelton 21 day ago

      She can't, she's not much of a dancer, she prefers to focus more on her singing.

  • Sofija Gjurashaj
    Sofija Gjurashaj Month ago

    She did great! Sad bc last years Coachella she was there with Mac Miller and shortly after they broke up

  • Joanah Taylor
    Joanah Taylor Month ago

    Bruh her lip fillers are outta control JuSt SaYiNg

  • serenity gibbs
    serenity gibbs Month ago +2

    I’m sorry but she should not have been paid more than Beyoncé

    • Ari L
      Ari L Day ago

      Đěąđ Īñşíđę see full article here, and any brief google search can confirm the same.

    • Đěąđ Īñşíđę
      Đěąđ Īñşíđę Day ago

      Nope ariana got more

    • A
      A Month ago +1

      serenity gibbs I’m pretty sure she wasn’t? I read somewhere on twitter that it was a fake report meant to get people stirred up but I think they both got the same $8mil check.

  • aryanna 345
    aryanna 345 Month ago

    What about of xxxtentacion

  • Blahk Morris
    Blahk Morris Month ago

    man I wish JT would have been there, I wonder why not

  • Blahk Morris
    Blahk Morris Month ago


  • Elenh
    Elenh Month ago

    Ari said “we can’t hear anything” it’s not only nicki

  • Kelby C
    Kelby C Month ago +3

    Beyoncé was the best Hands down

  • Unknown
    Unknown Month ago +1

    0:11 its not her first lol

  • HL Watts
    HL Watts Month ago +2

    I loved everything about her performance except “Arichella”. She should have gone with “Coachella Grande”. Missed opportunity sis...

  • obsidiana07
    obsidiana07 Month ago

    She killed the song and not in a good way. 😒😕

  • Symmy
    Symmy Month ago +1

    #Beychella Superior

    • Symmy
      Symmy Month ago

      nikki scissorhands you prefer Ariana’s boring ass performance? Bye omg

    • nikki scissorhands
      nikki scissorhands Month ago


  • Gregory Artisan
    Gregory Artisan Month ago +1

    All she does is talk about mac Miller for attention. She treated him like such garbage before he died.

    • Rashid Emcee
      Rashid Emcee Month ago +1

      Gregory Artisan Thank You for not being a sheep

    YOUNG GEN1US Month ago


  • Alba Gutierrez
    Alba Gutierrez Month ago +7

    She is a great performer and her voice is amazing ♥️

  • Zach Wagner
    Zach Wagner Month ago +6

    Tbh I’m glad that she didn’t decide to put ghostin’ on the set list, she definitely wouldn’t make it through the whole song.

  • ShipyNerdz
    ShipyNerdz Month ago

    Don't make @Coachella seem innocent they did them girls dirty they are gonna pay big when they get much hate from the barbs and Ariana grande fans Coachella should be ashamed they did that to them and any one else they did that to technical difficulty my ass

  • Official. Jhade
    Official. Jhade Month ago +6

    Arichella are you serious 🤦🏽‍♀️. Man there are some huge wave riders, BEYCHELLA was a ONE time thing for a true Queen because my sis Beyoncé actually made history with her record breaking performance . The fact that Beyoncé’s Homecoming documentary about the Coachella performance that she did a year ago was talked about more than Ariana’s performance just proves my point. Don’t @ me 💯🤷🏽‍♀️

    • the one
      the one Month ago

      +Abdul Alamery bitch you're wrong and I'll tell you why Beyonce put so much effort passion and work into her performance Ariana did none of that all she did was sing her shity bubblepop songs Beyonce made a documentary of her coachella performance I recommend you watch it it'll open your eyes

    • the one
      the one Month ago

      I know right can't believe they paid Ariana twice as much then Beyonce like wtf

    • Abdul Alamery
      Abdul Alamery Month ago +2

      Official. Jhade ari has made history this year with the fastest album to reach #1 and longest time at #1 for a song so ARICHELLA is equally as special as BEYCHELLA and just because someone else is headlining other thank ur fave doesn’t make them less special so go back to crying just coz Beyoncé ain’t here

  • Hottt Teaaa
    Hottt Teaaa Month ago +2

    Hello people who didn’t go coachella

  • Elle Stevens
    Elle Stevens Month ago +12

    I like Ariana, but calling it arichella is a stretch and disrespectful to all of Beys work.

    • the one
      the one Month ago +2

      +trybogus sis wake the fuck up I doubt arana granola is making more then hey oh child

    • trybogus
      trybogus Month ago

      Bunch of Beyoncetards hating because Ariana got more fans and is making it bigger, she's not even over yet!

    • Masha Mitchell
      Masha Mitchell Month ago +3

      And this performance didn't come close to what beyonce pulled off. I'm not even a fan, but that shit was amazing.

    • the one
      the one Month ago

      I agree

    • Elle Stevens
      Elle Stevens Month ago +1

      +Perighesade Ednockelwal Wrong. I won't waste my time explaining what Beychella meant. Ari is one of the few talented singers out there, we love her. She wasn't the one that started the arichella shit.

  • Mel M
    Mel M Month ago

    Is nsync there because justin was supposed to perform?

  • Adam Shafiq
    Adam Shafiq Month ago +1

    My wig stay gluedt to my scalp and is secured

  • Maya M.
    Maya M. Month ago +162

    she's such a good performer seriously though .... all that dancing and her vocals still sound so good. she works hard and has improved her stamina so much!!!

    • My name is Aminé
      My name is Aminé 26 days ago +1

      celebstadium lmao the fact you think you have the power to banish me. 😂 I’m not a Beyoncé stan I’m a talent stan, and I watch the entire show and she didn’t dance energetic or complex choreography the entire show (apart from maybe during the NSYNC tribute). You as an Ari stan know that she doesn’t truly dance and is not a dancer and doesn’t enjoy dancing on stage, she’s all about the singing 🎤 she has said this multiple times in interviews. What about pointing that out seems toxic to you? 🤔 🙄

    • celebstadium
      celebstadium 26 days ago

      My name is Aminé get out toxic bey stan, thank you next!

    • My name is Aminé
      My name is Aminé Month ago +3

      Maya M. “all that dancing” where? 😂 she’s doesn’t even ‘truly’ dance like that - maybe a lil 5678 here and there but c’mon now 🙄 she wasn’t energetically dancing like say Beyoncé was last year...I don’t like the false equivalence... people see their fav swaying from side to side while singing then say “OMG the talent to sing and dance simultaneously”! 🙄

  • Maya M.
    Maya M. Month ago +2

    woah 0:49 her lip injections.... i never noticed until now

  • Windysaint
    Windysaint Month ago


  • Aly p
    Aly p Month ago +22

    Bruh I watched homecoming by Beyoncé and this looks so lame lmao

    • Masha Mitchell
      Masha Mitchell Month ago +1

      Right? I'm not even a bey fan and i was watching like this is fucking amazing. You could feel the energy thru the television.

    • the one
      the one Month ago +2

      Spit the facts sis

    • Official. Jhade
      Official. Jhade Month ago +2

      I know right

    • Mariana Antunes
      Mariana Antunes Month ago +2

      Aly p gtfo then

  • Alanna Jenkins
    Alanna Jenkins Month ago +26

    I just wanna say and i mean this is the nicest way possible.......... No one's coachella performance can beat beyonce's🤷🏾 y'all know it's true so sis dont attack me

    • the one
      the one Month ago +1

      Year queen louder for the people in the back

    • Alanna Jenkins
      Alanna Jenkins Month ago

      +Perighesade Ednockelwal i understand she never said she was trying to top beyonce but IN MY OPINION beyonce's performance was the best I've seen so far no shade no tea 😁

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago +1

      +Alanna Jenkins not you specifically but everyone is being super rude. She never said she was trying to top Beyonce. She literally just brought her tour to the stage

    • Alanna Jenkins
      Alanna Jenkins Month ago

      +Perighesade Ednockelwal no one was being rude or salty😂 i love ariana grande so much so why would I shade her🤦🏾

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago +1

      You're telling the truth but why keep pushing it. Ariana Grande is Ariana Grande. Can we just let her be her without salty and rude comparisons

  • Reina Arana
    Reina Arana Month ago +1

    It's not *NSYNC without JT

  • Reina Arana
    Reina Arana Month ago +185

    To me no one else can top Beyoncé's performance but Ari did amazing

    • Nikolina Stegnjaic
      Nikolina Stegnjaic Month ago +1

      +TheMac 727 Dude i know that they're on different levels. Thats what ive been saying. Beyonce is on a higher level than her. However, im gonna repeat this so that you understand, they both headlined coachella so people are obviously gonna compare which show was more interesting. Nothing wrong with that. Now take a step back and stop riding Ariana.

    • Nikolina Stegnjaic
      Nikolina Stegnjaic Month ago +2

      +TheMac 727 Dude maybe you should actually read my comment. Its not about the different style of music, its because of the show in general. The dance, the vibe of the show, etc. Beyonces performance was dedicated to black empowerment. And were comparing it bc both of them headlined coachella so obviously were gonna talk about which one was a more interesting performance.

    • Nikolina Stegnjaic
      Nikolina Stegnjaic Month ago +3

      TheMac 727 Its not just about the difference in style though. If you saw beyonces new documentary, you would understand how crazy it is and how much time and effort her and her dancers had to go through. Ariana’s performance literally cannot even begin to compare in any way.

    • ARYEliB
      ARYEliB Month ago +5

      TheMac 727 sorry but Beyoncé was amazing 😂😂😂

    • Stylish Diva
      Stylish Diva Month ago +3


  • Ross Harb
    Ross Harb Month ago +10

    Y’all have no idea how much these guys meant to my childhood . BSB never had that kind of effect on me like NSYNC .

  • Hana Belle
    Hana Belle Month ago

    Wow!! She brought anyone out!!!

  • untold truths
    untold truths Month ago +7

    I don't need Justin there trying to pop open Ariana's bra

  • rockstarglam mona
    rockstarglam mona Month ago +29

    Ari I love u but don’t with the arichella

  • Zowy 92
    Zowy 92 Month ago +19

    Its a shame that the audio didn’t work very welll 😢

    P.s. Ari is a true legend 😍❤️

  • Bryan Jones
    Bryan Jones Month ago


  • Cover POINT
    Cover POINT Month ago +70

    Is it a bird?
    Is it a plane?

    No, it’s my wig.

  • Haley Faragalli
    Haley Faragalli Month ago +2

    What a queen

  • Crystal 225
    Crystal 225 Month ago +27

    After Beyonce?? Girl bye! Have several seats.

  • Ocean Master
    Ocean Master Month ago +1

    Why is she still trying to get sympathy over a guy that she killed.

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago

      +Ocean Master they teach from Kindergarten up that drugs will kill you. Mac Miller was on drugs. They killed him

    • Ocean Master
      Ocean Master Month ago

      +Perighesade Ednockelwal you shouldnt do drugs in kindergarden. Are you ok?

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago

      Drugs they have a reputation for killing someone. Thought you should know just in case they didn't tell you that in kindergarten

  • AJ Direct
    AJ Direct Month ago +6

    Remember when people actually sang without the help of a computer?

  • crustytoe
    crustytoe Month ago +10

    Yeah but can we legalize marijuana

  • mayorbloomburg
    mayorbloomburg Month ago +5

    Nsync reunion except for Justin Timberlake? Then it wasn’t a reunion, was it?

  • Joseph Verdugo
    Joseph Verdugo Month ago +2


  • Zamil Khan - The You-Tuber

    She is soo Shady..🙄

  • darian wofford
    darian wofford Month ago +1

    Ariana IS THAT BITCH!!!!! She ain’t come to play at all!!! Love it

  • Triforce Gamer
    Triforce Gamer Month ago

    She choked up on mac miller but didn't care when he was alive. Fake tears

    • Triforce Gamer
      Triforce Gamer Month ago

      +Alina Mollie lmao gullible little girl. And you know all this how? Is she you're best friend and she told you all this? I swear people make up all this b.s for a person they don't even know 😂

    • Alina Mollie
      Alina Mollie Month ago

      Triforce Gamer what? lol what do u mean she didn’t care? They literally were together for a long ass time? After the break up they still texted each other, and they still loved each other and what do we know behind closed doors really. U need to get out of this internet with that negativity, thank u next

  • Cola Slimes
    Cola Slimes Month ago +14

    *jessie j has left the chat*

  • Jamais Vu
    Jamais Vu Month ago +2

    No one under 15 listens to arianna grande 💁🏻‍♀️

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago +1

      +Jamais Vu and so do a lot of ppl. Don't ask me. Ask the charts

    • Jamais Vu
      Jamais Vu Month ago

      Perighesade Ednockelwal that’s unfortunate. 😅

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago +1

      My 70 year old Grandma listens to Ariana Grande

    • Jamais Vu
      Jamais Vu Month ago +1

      Ary'ana Munson 😂❤️ no hate no hate

    • Zizou A
      Zizou A Month ago +1

      are u trying to hate on the queen of pop?

  • Nikki Rose
    Nikki Rose Month ago +21

    I love me some Ariana but stop calling her Arichella...Bey dubbed the name first. Beychella forever! Y’all always tryna compare where you don’t compete, sit down!

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago +1

      I'm sorry Beyhive are literally the ones commenting tidals website. We call it Arichella cause thats her name

  • Thomas Wolf
    Thomas Wolf Month ago +1

    We need Meghan Trainor there I don't why but she will kill it

  • Maayannes
    Maayannes Month ago

    I hate ariana

  • ashley thebest
    ashley thebest Month ago +1


  • waterside
    waterside Month ago +1

    Sad that she got molested on national television and nothing came of it. Shows how sick Hollywood is.

  • Trent Brown
    Trent Brown Month ago +2


  • Maggie Vue
    Maggie Vue Month ago


  • Cake Gaming
    Cake Gaming Month ago +1

    I remember Ariana Grande being in Victorious then Sam & Kat and now she is a super popular singer and all the girls like her singing and maybe more... and all the boys like her for something else but I’ll just say you already know what that is...


    Garbage music

    • Thithuylinh Bui
      Thithuylinh Bui Month ago

      ANONYMOUS so music need to be fast for u?

      ANONYMOUS Month ago

      thats what i been thinking her song is so damn slow

  • Adam Jones
    Adam Jones Month ago +2

    Nah she moved on too fast for me to believe this. She wasn’t crying when she was fucking Pete a week later

  • princeoffriendship
    princeoffriendship Month ago

    Any kind human reading this comment could tell me or sent a link to where i could find her full performance???

  • Dhk4
    Dhk4 Month ago +17

    Arichella 🤦🏾‍♂️

  • Elisha Kins
    Elisha Kins Month ago +102

    Didn't diddy put the hit out that got Pac killed? He wrong for that "tribute"

    • Kelsey DotC
      Kelsey DotC Month ago

      He put a hit out on biggie

    • The Collab Trio
      The Collab Trio Month ago +1

      I’m confused I think the song ur talking ab is I’ll be missing you

    • waterside
      waterside Month ago +3

      The proof? Or you still into fairytales...

  • Black Canary Gaming
    Black Canary Gaming Month ago +119

    she's the newest member of nsync lol

  • mayasheartdesiire
    mayasheartdesiire Month ago +234

    It can’t be a Nsync reunion without Justin 😭🤦🏽‍♀️

    • mayasheartdesiire
      mayasheartdesiire Month ago

      Rachel Barraza Medellin lol that doesn’t mean backstreet is better tho comment has nothing to do with backstreet...that’s just your opinion. I like backstreet too but I enjoy Nsync songs more🤷🏽‍♀️

    • Jen Ye
      Jen Ye Month ago


    • Jessica Lopez
      Jessica Lopez Month ago

      Rachel Medellin yup exactly

    • Jessica Lopez
      Jessica Lopez Month ago +20

      Justin is not humble at allllllll he thinks hes too good to be preforming with nsync now smh

  • Banks the halo great
    Banks the halo great Month ago +38

    U gotta pay JT a milly to show up with those clowns 🤷🏾‍♂️😰😅

  • Chase Rogers
    Chase Rogers Month ago +412

    “We can’t hear anything”

  • STOP oh yeah yeah disease thousand

    Where did she choke?

    • Anne Wheeler
      Anne Wheeler Month ago +2

      When she sang “thank u, next” on the line, “I wish I could say thank you to Malcom, cuz he was an angel.”

  • Chechi De La Rocha
    Chechi De La Rocha Month ago +13

    Arichella??? Really et? 🤮🤮🤮

    • the one
      the one Month ago

      +keyblademaster 21 beychella was an much better than this shit show periodtttttt!!!!!!!!!!

    • Zizou A
      Zizou A Month ago

      Ur fave could never beat Ariana

    • keyblademaster 21
      keyblademaster 21 Month ago +3

      Your faves could never beat Arichella. Periodt.

    • Andrei Terry
      Andrei Terry Month ago +3

      Chechi De La Rocha it is actually called arichella. Search it up

  • sour lemon
    sour lemon Month ago +1

    Ariana is god

  • Merlina Abraham
    Merlina Abraham Month ago +149

    lovely gorgeous girl with the most beautiful voice

  • Wendy Qu
    Wendy Qu Month ago

  • Cindy Rella
    Cindy Rella Month ago

    Why Nsync look so old now?

    • Risingofthephoenixx x
      Risingofthephoenixx x Month ago +1

      Lol because they're in there 40s now. I know it's sad seeing our idols get older

    • Marshall Street
      Marshall Street Month ago +3

      Cindy Rella They’re in their 40s now.

  • Aubrey Madison
    Aubrey Madison Month ago +2

    She Dosnt sound good at all live to me 😬😬😬

    • Edward Leon
      Edward Leon Month ago +1

      Aubrey Madison maybe clean your ears ?

    • Justice Y
      Justice Y Month ago +3

      Aubrey Madison she sound just like she do in studio wym

  • Tina Ly
    Tina Ly Month ago +617

    Justin Timberlake should've been there with his group N'sync. 😕🙄

    • Brigette Anna
      Brigette Anna Month ago +1

      +Sailor MoonStone girl ain't that the truth 💯

    • CJ Carpenter
      CJ Carpenter Month ago +1

      Lol they suck compared to him.

    • Vipe Jay
      Vipe Jay Month ago +1

      When JT brought out NSync for 1 minute, everyone complained because it was short, then everyone started this whole "f**k JT, Nsync can still go on tour without that big head"..and now that they performed without JT, people still complain, like seriously? You can"t win with these stupid fans...cuz no matter what JT does, these Nsync fans would still try to put him down, why? Because they're still salty that JT is the only one in the 2000's boyband era who have a successful career..stop this bitterness, you're still living in the past, move on...the guy is on tour, do you think he would choose this event over the millions of dollars he could earn in 1 night?

    • Benjamin
      Benjamin Month ago +1

      Zaraeah Hardin he is though

    • OcarinaSims
      OcarinaSims Month ago +1

      +Zaraeah Hardin he is on tour and obviously has moved on from the group

  • Lush Tv
    Lush Tv Month ago +4

    Ariana is not a good performer . She sings good but not exceptional, the Mac Miller thing was just fake .She just did it for views and the Mo money song sounded flat.

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago

      WHAT VIEWSSSSSSSS. The video isn't even available on youtube. You wouldn't know about the tribute unless you tuned in and watched all the way through. Troll

  • Babymo Bagwell
    Babymo Bagwell Month ago +80

    I got in my feelings when ari and p diddy did the tribute but left out X

    • Jazmyn Williams
      Jazmyn Williams Month ago +1

      Because no one likes a rapist and abuser lmao.

    • Perighesade Ednockelwal
      Perighesade Ednockelwal Month ago

      +Babymo Bagwell the screens were from Khalids set. Diddy shouted some names. Idk if it was all scripted on off his mind.

    • Israel Washington
      Israel Washington Month ago +2

      Maximus Guerrero please don’t start with that, just accept it🤦🏾‍♀️

    • Maximus Guerrero
      Maximus Guerrero Month ago

      X still alive watchu mean brudda

    • Babymo Bagwell
      Babymo Bagwell Month ago +3

      Victoria Xoxo at the end of the video it showed people dat died recently and in the past and all I’m trying say is X was a recent pass