J vs Ben: ULTIMATE Sirius Black Quiz


Comments • 3 611

  • Reece David
    Reece David 7 hours ago

    The crew figures out Lupin’s secret in there 2nd year so it took them the better part of three years meaning they were in there 5th year.

  • Hana Brammer
    Hana Brammer 11 hours ago

    Marauders Quiz!!!

  • Deniz Kenger
    Deniz Kenger Day ago

    I got 26:)

  • Deniz Kenger
    Deniz Kenger Day ago

    Fifth year. Carry on reading that paragraph, it clearly says they all managed to turn into their animagus forms by their fifth year...

  • BeastAll Day
    BeastAll Day Day ago

    In the British version of Order of the Phoenix Sirius dies on the same page as his vault number 711

  • Haribojedi 21
    Haribojedi 21 2 days ago

    at 4.38 the answer was crookshanks I hope I get it wright

  • Raghav Sriram
    Raghav Sriram 2 days ago

    To me, this was the most interesting quiz on SCB

  • Katherine Longuil
    Katherine Longuil 2 days ago

    They became animagi in 5th year. They found out in 2nd year and I’m pretty sure peter fulfilled his in 6th year

  • Wolf Knight
    Wolf Knight 2 days ago

    One problem. That passage about them becoming animagi, it says it took them 3 years. It does not say if they started learning in year 1, or 3.

  • silkwoodallen
    silkwoodallen 3 days ago

    17 out of 30

  • The Hero of Hyrule
    The Hero of Hyrule 3 days ago

    hey i remembered his gringotts vault # as clear as day it's when he sent harry his permission slip and letter while they were riding home on the hogwarts express. It's the letter he sent with pigwigeon that told harry he bought bought him the firebolt with the gold from his vault, 711

  • Zoe Bourne
    Zoe Bourne 3 days ago

    I got 22 :))) no wonder, he’s my favourite

  • A Person
    A Person 4 days ago


  • Eirene
    Eirene 4 days ago

    They became animagi in fifth year. It took them three years to do it, but that's AFTER they find out Remus was a werewolf, which is not in first year

  • Charlie Cummings
    Charlie Cummings 4 days ago

    Is that Padfoot became an animagus in 5th year, Wormtail became an animagus in 7th year?

  • kingofthegrapes1212
    kingofthegrapes1212 5 days ago

    11:00 Ben 10

  • Alexis Nestrud
    Alexis Nestrud 5 days ago

    Ok but how do we know how long it took wormtail, that isn't in the passage so it could be fifth year for Peter but third or fourth or fifth year depending how long he took??? IDK sounds very ambiguous

  • Elira Alievski
    Elira Alievski 6 days ago

    When Ben said Albania I was like *gasp* I’m Albanian

  • Brendan Watson
    Brendan Watson 7 days ago

    It took three years from their second year so it’s their fifth year

  • Jocelyn Jacob
    Jocelyn Jacob 7 days ago

    12:30 What if they figured out Lupin's secret in their 2nd year...?

  • Julius G.
    Julius G. 7 days ago

    it sais three years, because they started in their second year...

  • MultiMediaInput
    MultiMediaInput 8 days ago

    The Multiple Choice Rule should be you can choose to go to multiple choice but if you write down your answer before the question is read you get 2 points; Both players still have to agree to the multiple choice just so you cant do it every single question, plus it would add an extra level of strategy to risk your opponent to get two points instead of one.

  • Anusuya Bhattacharyya

    I got 25 having seen the multiple choices !!! Some were just lucky guesses though !!

  • LLadyRose
    LLadyRose 8 days ago

    You guys were wrong. It says James and Sirius needed 3 years, not until their 3rd year. Plus it says “in our fifth year, THEY managed it” not wormtail managed it. So the quiz was right, but I understand the confusion.

  • Joshua Armitt
    Joshua Armitt 8 days ago

    Said Sirius seriously

  • Dance Kitties
    Dance Kitties 9 days ago

    Who is older, Jay?

    • BadgerPride89
      BadgerPride89 2 days ago

      Jay, Ben, then their little brother Tyler

  • Casual Tryhard76
    Casual Tryhard76 9 days ago

    13:00 but they also didn’t know about is condition his first year though, right, maybe, idk

  • Shelby Gregory
    Shelby Gregory 9 days ago


  • Nick Dillhoff
    Nick Dillhoff 10 days ago

    12:14 It took them three years....but they didn't start till the second year cause they didn't find about about lupin till the second year

  • kelli wickham
    kelli wickham 11 days ago

    I got 27/30 or siriusly brilliant

  • BunnySaram
    BunnySaram 11 days ago


  • Azzy Smith
    Azzy Smith 12 days ago

    in their FIFTH YEAR. they didn't figure out Remus was a werewolf until their second year and the minute they figured it out they started. And it took them 3 years to manage it and it never says anywhere that Sirius and James got it before Peter. They all got it on the same day and same year.

  • Guffa95
    Guffa95 12 days ago

    Draco is his first cousin once removed, because Draco is the son (once removed) of Narcissa (first cousin). If Sirius were to have a child they would be second cousin to Draco. Also the "merry hippogriffs" question was in the christmas quiz

  • Foxer
    Foxer 13 days ago

    I have the same snitch figure they have :)

  • LinkToo
    LinkToo 14 days ago

    @12:24 look at the second to last sentence. "Finally, in our fifth year, they managed it." Not, just Peter but all of them

  • Ray Magliacano
    Ray Magliacano 15 days ago

    Hannah Abbot is The Goat🐐

  • Lucy Holland
    Lucy Holland 15 days ago

    The k-night bus? Pronunciation...

  • David Powers
    David Powers 15 days ago

    I had to look up the vault number for Sirius online - I think that in the original version read: "I used your name but told them to take the gold from Gringotts vault number seven hundred and eleven -- my own." to not naming the vault number, so it's a tough one. I think it may be the only line mentioning Sirius's vault number, and I think many versions of the US version have the basic line without the number. Probably people with an early version (or who have read the British version) would be more likely to know the number, which would still be tough.

  • Al Zeema
    Al Zeema 15 days ago

    To-do list:
    1. fall in love with Derek's voice - DONE

  • The Ace
    The Ace 16 days ago +1

    I haven't read any of the books personaly because the first one didn't hook me it was so boring I barely got through the first pages only because I've watched the movies religiously . People have said that since I've watched the movies and I know the basic sorry line I could start off with a more interesting book and right now I have prizzoner of Azkaban. If I'm correct it's the 4th Maby third I know order of the Phoenix is 5 and harry had to of already known black since he died in the beginning so it's the 4th book I just can't remember the 3rd . If 1 is soceres stone and 2 is chamber of secrets. Ok no I'm rong it's the third cause then the goblet of fire happens I just forgot they black talked to harry though the fire place 😂😂😂 I had to Google it lol

  • 葉駿成
    葉駿成 16 days ago

    Sorry Derik

  • Pumpkin Guts
    Pumpkin Guts 16 days ago

    Is juste or does j look like a Ben and Ben looks like a j

  • Sanctuary Cheetah
    Sanctuary Cheetah 17 days ago

    I got 23/30

  • FrozenLuna18
    FrozenLuna18 18 days ago

    So I didn't know the number but I guessed 716 just out of thin air so I think I should get the point I was closer

  • PancakeCat24
    PancakeCat24 18 days ago

    i got 27 out of 30

  • kirstin gracee
    kirstin gracee 19 days ago

    a very potter musical is a gem

  • TheRedMenace
    TheRedMenace 19 days ago

    On the dog on the platform question, I initially thought it was Draco Malfoy until I saw the multiple choice and he wasn't one of them. He said something like "don't dog it up, Potter," or something like that, and that's what made Harry think the Malfoys knew about Sirius. But if I hadn't seen the multiple choice answers I probably would've written 'Draco Malfoy' too.

  • M Cruz
    M Cruz 20 days ago

    “How does it help him get into the castle Hannah?!” LOL 😂 I just love these Ben Versus J Harry Potter quizzes!!

  • Get creative with Asha

    Like the Lupin test I got 16/30 :/

  • Liz 372
    Liz 372 20 days ago +1

    Hey guys ! The question was not about the time it took them to manage it, but in which year they did. So your sample is correct, but the right answer is at the end of it, not in the beginning ;)

  • PotterfanKat87
    PotterfanKat87 20 days ago

    I was 50%, stink!

  • Chewbacca the Ravenclaw

    Sirius' death was the first time I cried at something in a book.

  • Ducklover Gaming
    Ducklover Gaming 20 days ago

    They start in the third year and finish in the fifth

  • Averaves _BiroAce
    Averaves _BiroAce 21 day ago

    What’s up with everyone bolding words in comments recently? I’ve come across it in a lot of comment sections and I’m very confused...

  • Saghar Setareh
    Saghar Setareh 21 day ago

    As a die hard Sirius Black fan, I was quite offended by my poor result of 23/30, but after seeing you, I feel better :D (multiple choices helped a lot though).
    A part of me will NEVER forgive JK Rowing for killing off Sirius. I feel like I should state this every few years.

  • Simon Hirschmugl
    Simon Hirschmugl 21 day ago

    Question 10 is almost the exact same thing Dumbledore says about Sirius and his treatment of Kreacher. That's just... wow!

  • Blake Catherine Jean
    Blake Catherine Jean 22 days ago

    Sorry, did he just pronounce the K in Knight Bus??? 😳😮

  • Demon Bullet
    Demon Bullet 22 days ago

    Draco’s mother is Sirius’s cousin, therefore making Draco his first cousin once removed

  • Rukmani Sindhu Thangam

    Just so you know, I kicked both your arses in this quiz. Although it could probably be because I loved Sirius even before. It was revealed he was a good guy. And I haven’t ever read the book since I left my parents’ house! But seriously, do you know the chapter number and not the name? I was the opposite!
    And. AND dismissing Hannah? Really? _Really?_ I know one of you did a video about Hufflepuffs not being represented except by Cedric, but Hannah was one of the first Hufflepuffs we get to know. She was one of the very few people who believed Harry wasn’t the heir until Ernie convinced her and then the duel incident. She was from a pure blood family listed in the sacred 28, but she was also pulled from school because death eaters had murdered her mother. She had a lot in common with Hermione, including being prefects, fear of being expelled as a priority and the fact that they were the two to return to Hogwarts after the war to finish a lost year.
    My personal favourite is that she took over the Leaky Cauldron after Tom, which is essentially the main doorway between the muggle and magic world. Oh and of course she married Neville, which isn’t very important. But she knew about Neville’s parents in the goblet of fire, during Moody’s cruel class. Or so I assume from the reaction. But she eventually became a healer and went back to Hogwarts.

    M1RANDA 22 days ago

    12:15 yes, 3 years. They found out Lupin was a werewolf in second year and therefore didn't manage it "until 5th year"

  • Starbuck R
    Starbuck R 22 days ago

    It took them three years to figure out how to do the transformation, but when did they start even looking into it? I find it hard to believe that 13-yr-old james and sirius were animagi. Maybe late 4th year but I interpreted it as they all figured out the transformation in or around 5th year

  • booklover900
    booklover900 22 days ago +1

    Here's why I disagree with the "Nice one James!": It's because it proves Molly's point that Sirius doesn't see Harry as his own person he's just using him as a replacement for his best friend which in my opinion is worse of an insult than the Dursley's putting him under the stairs. Because all he wants is family that sees him and treats him as family but no, he doesn't get that. He gets to be a replacement.
    This is so poorly worded, because it makes me so angry every time.

  • Martí Rodríguez Pont

    "How does it help him break into the castle, Hannah?!" Love how he's scolding a fictional side character

  • BowPeep
    BowPeep 22 days ago

    What's a "7 ELEVEN"
    Sorry Witch

  • me hi
    me hi 22 days ago


  • adrian stancliff
    adrian stancliff 23 days ago

    Alastor Moody and Reubus Hagrid are very powerful or strong charecters

  • Kevin Sean
    Kevin Sean 23 days ago

    Why do y'all always think barty Jr was only in for one year just before book 4? Barty says he had Winky looking after him for years. Bertha's memory charm from Crouch Sr is years old. He'd been out for a good long while. Not sure how long Mrs Crouch took his place, but it couldn't have been that long after initial imprisonment, as Neville also grew up without his parents, and Barty was convicted of torturing them.

  • siobhan kilsby
    siobhan kilsby 23 days ago

    The stuff you learn from Marauders fanfic.

  • NRGKnight
    NRGKnight 23 days ago

    They started in their second year when the marauders find out lupin is a werewolf, so 2+3=5

  • Alex Riptide
    Alex Riptide 24 days ago

    27/30. So happy with myself.

  • Noneofyou Business
    Noneofyou Business 24 days ago

    No the quiz was not correct, second cousin and first cousin once removed mean the same thing.

  • Dog
    Dog 25 days ago

    14:24 The Kuh night bus?

  • Gigi Rauchut
    Gigi Rauchut 25 days ago

    How did I get 21 right?

  • Jenny S
    Jenny S 26 days ago

    How have you not seen A Very Potter Musical!?! Ben you NEED to watch it!

  • Nico Di Angelo
    Nico Di Angelo 26 days ago

    They found out Lupin was a werewolf in their second year, and it took them three years to figure it out.

  • Korbin Kidwell
    Korbin Kidwell 26 days ago

    They didn't find out that Lupin was a werewolf until their 2nd year, and also didn't start on trying to be an animagus until second year also, and it took them 3 years to do it, so that means it would be their 3rd year. The quiz was right!

  • Korbin Kidwell
    Korbin Kidwell 26 days ago

    They didn't find out that Lupin was a werewolf until their 2nd year, and also didn't start on trying to be an animagus until second year also, and it took them 3 years to do it, so that means it would be their 3rd year. The quiz was right!

  • Izzy La la
    Izzy La la 26 days ago

    They found out that lupin was a werewolf in their second year so three years would mean that they are in their 5 year

  • Kim Ng
    Kim Ng 26 days ago

    If you say third year, you're assuming they took one look at Remus and were like, "Ah, the dude's a werewolf."

  • Ebony Barbat
    Ebony Barbat 26 days ago

    If anyone didn’t know the real reason Sirius said nice one James was cause obviously he was reminded of James but when they were in school James uses Expeliarmus on Snape and says nice James .Harry uses it on Antonon Dolohov. :( so sad

  • Ebony Barbat
    Ebony Barbat 26 days ago

    How did Sirius spend 12 years in Azkaban if he convicted in 1981 but escaped in 1992. Ben and J said the year wrong. Lol

  • Chris Ortega
    Chris Ortega 27 days ago

    7:06; Hentai Reference. Bible Black, look it up younglings.

  • CryingBuddha
    CryingBuddha 27 days ago


  • Nora Girl
    Nora Girl 27 days ago

    Lol I was so frustrated with my 21 but I guess it's good...

  • Marisa Martignon
    Marisa Martignon 27 days ago

    I got 28/30

  • Anian Krieg
    Anian Krieg 27 days ago

    why is this quiz so easy?

  • Anian Krieg
    Anian Krieg 27 days ago

    12:00 they actually did become animagus in the fifth year because they found out about lupin being a werwolf in their 2nd year and from there on it took them 3 years to figure out how to do it.

  • Jose Fuentes
    Jose Fuentes 28 days ago

    For some reason always imagined a toucan delivering Sirius' letters.

  • Charlotte LI
    Charlotte LI 29 days ago

    They finished in FITH year

  • Charlotte LI
    Charlotte LI 29 days ago

    They started in SECOND year

  • James Stokes
    James Stokes 29 days ago

    This quiz was hilarious! Out of all the quizzes I have watched the Carlin brothers complete this has been one of the most amusing quizzes reaction videos they have produced.
    I actually got 19/30, so barely squeaked by the two Carlin brothers :P

    I also agree with +Nicole Shen that Daricks voice is very soothing.

  • Aaliyah Nelson
    Aaliyah Nelson 29 days ago +1

    I NEED HELP.. I cant do these quizzes!! I have a pottermore a account Ive taking quizzes (Im a Slytherin) but i cant take them??

  • Akcampbell1970
    Akcampbell1970 29 days ago

    Sirius says he could hear Barty Crouch Jr. crying himself to sleep at night in Azkaban.

  • Joanna Jammaini
    Joanna Jammaini 29 days ago

    I got 23/30 which is 76/100

  • Luna Moonchyld
    Luna Moonchyld Month ago +1

    I guessed it right it was fifth year also I think I got 21 out of 30 right so I think I did pretty good considering I haven't read the books in a long time I'm reading them now but I'm only halfway through the third book so haven't really read much Sirius stuff in a long time

  • Poseidon Frostborn
    Poseidon Frostborn Month ago

    What was harries first school like or did he even go to school

    • Akcampbell1970
      Akcampbell1970 29 days ago

      It's only mentioned in passing in the first book, but we know he turned a teacher's wig blue and got constantly beat up by Dudley's gang.

  • Nyx
    Nyx Month ago

    I got 3 wrong. Geez, 27 points.

  • Tiffanie Marks
    Tiffanie Marks Month ago

    The deeper the vault(higher the number) the more important the vault.

  • Tiffanie Marks
    Tiffanie Marks Month ago

    I remember Sirius commenting about Barty Crouch Jr dying in prison while he was there, only to realize that it was Mrs. Crouch