J vs Ben: ULTIMATE Sirius Black Quiz


Comments • 3 863

  • amanda bensema
    amanda bensema 23 hours ago

    But it say finally in our faith year the maniged it

  • The Potter Potato

    Sirius is my favorite. I will crush the quiz!
    EDIT: as I suspected, I only missed one. The most intelligent of his kind I’ve ever met.

  • RancidRobDaM3M3R
    RancidRobDaM3M3R 2 days ago

    no because they found out lupin was a warewolf in the second year not the first time 12/23

  • Leila Lapus
    Leila Lapus 3 days ago

    got 28/30

  • Anirban Sen
    Anirban Sen 3 days ago

    I knew it was the fifth year

  • joseph nolen
    joseph nolen 5 days ago


  • Allia is The best
    Allia is The best 6 days ago


  • Vaibhav Sinha
    Vaibhav Sinha 6 days ago

    12:33 The text explicitly states that they finally did it in their fifth year. You guys just assume that James and Sirius did it first and then taught Wormtail how to do it later but what I believe happened is that while all three of them became Animagi at the same time, Peter would need help from the other two to do it correctly, nevertheless they all got through it together at the same time. It never explicitly states when they started the process, but it would make sense if they started in their second year, spending the first year finding out about Lupin's furry little problem.

  • Alison Jones
    Alison Jones 7 days ago


  • Lenia N. Ldzn
    Lenia N. Ldzn 8 days ago

    27:51 WEIRD FACT: In the Romanian translation of PoA Sirius' vault number is mentioned in his letter to Harry in the final chapter of the book, that's how i knew it. But I looked up scans of the English version online and in them the number does not appear. Can anyone check a physical English copy of Prisoner to see if it's present there? Seems odd to be included in a translation if it's not present in the original.

  • josh
    josh 8 days ago

    Sirius did become an animagus in his 5th year, they didn't discover Lupin was a werewolf right away. It took them over a year to figure it out. It took them 3 years, they started towards the end of second year I'm guessing. maybe early 3rd year.

  • Carinne Forpanek
    Carinne Forpanek 9 days ago

    They started working on becoming animaguses in their 2nd year so 3 years later would bring them to their 5th year

  • radomiania castle
    radomiania castle 9 days ago +2

    The most intelligent is CROOKSHANKS!!

  • Sofia Cook
    Sofia Cook 11 days ago

    It did take them three years to figure out how to do it, but they found out Remus' secret in the second year and then they came up with the idea.

  • Tathren Nuinamon
    Tathren Nuinamon 11 days ago

    20/30 Pat on the Black. You definitely love this handsome Marauder, but need to do a bit more dusting in his bedroom at Grimmauld Place before you’ll know the true Sirius.... oh my Pottermore

  • Seamus Eoghan Sugrue
    Seamus Eoghan Sugrue 11 days ago

    Who says that they actually start to try to become animagisus in their first year

  • ninaandianfan21
    ninaandianfan21 12 days ago

    whoever is reading the questions should make audiobooks :D

  • annete jensen
    annete jensen 13 days ago

    You guys are the reason to that I started reading the Harry Potter books. I can't explain why but I loves those books now and I can't wait to start reading the third book.

  • Schnuller
    Schnuller 13 days ago

    the question is when they started. They needed three years, but maybe they started in their second or third year. Five would still be correct.

  • Octo Visa
    Octo Visa 14 days ago

    12:19 at the bittom it says they acoplished it in during their 5th year

  • Reagan Parker
    Reagan Parker 14 days ago

    I GOT 20!!!! I WONNN

  • Abbie Brown
    Abbie Brown 14 days ago

    Just because it took them 3 years to become animagi, dosnt mean it was in their third year! They FOUND OUT that Lupin was a werewolf in their second or third year, started to try to become animagi, and 3 years LATER, so their 5th year, they accomplished it!

  • todaXPTO
    todaXPTO 15 days ago

    They figured out Lupin was a werewolf in their 2nd year. And the text says it took them 3years to do it, soo they became animagus in the 5th year.

  • Sunil Permaul
    Sunil Permaul 15 days ago

    12:17 It says it took them the best part of 3 years, but is that assuming they started in their 1st year? If they started in their 2nd year then they would all have made it by 5th. The way they are describing Peter is just that he needed more help/he wouldn't have been able to do it alone. The "them" the sentence is referring to is all the marauders sans Lupin, as in, "It took [my friends] the best part of three years...Finally, in our fifth year [my friends] managed it."

  • Helen 22 22
    Helen 22 22 15 days ago

    God Bless Might Hippogriff

  • ThatRandomGal
    ThatRandomGal 16 days ago


  • Matt Smith
    Matt Smith 16 days ago

    I think the question refers to the end of book for where Sirius me Tim getting off the train. What you’re thinking about is at the beginning of book 5 when Draco uses the phrase dogging you

  • Tiffany Ellis
    Tiffany Ellis 16 days ago

    21/30 lol

  • Cheese 33
    Cheese 33 18 days ago +1

    Rip, I got 17

  • Amelie Schneider
    Amelie Schneider 18 days ago

    At the end of the 3rd book, in his letter to Harry, he said along the lines of: I was the one who gave you the Firebolt. I turned into a dog with a note saying that I was you, but to take the money out of my own vault, 711

  • Amelie Schneider
    Amelie Schneider 18 days ago

    Sirius said that he saw “Barty Crouch Jr’s” body after he died, but he didn’t know it was Mrs. Crouch

  • Emily Johnson
    Emily Johnson 19 days ago

    While the underline in the 3rd year question is relevant, I think the second sentence from the last is more conclusive. Also they didn't necessarily start their first year. If they began in their 2nd year 3 years from then would be their 5th. Also James and Sirius would help Peter as they went along, not after the fact.

  • LiveAction Link
    LiveAction Link 19 days ago

    "Who of the following were in Azkaban at the same time as Sirius?" Made me have to think way too hard and just give up completely after only guessing Hagrid lol. Although, the "God rest, ye merry..." question was so obvious that I swore the announcer gave away the answer as he said it. I just heard it as "God rest, ye merry Hippogriffs" automatically in my head and was confused by the question

  • Nyx's Son
    Nyx's Son 19 days ago

    Arcturus and pollux are his grandparents and cygnus is a greengrass i belive

  • Luc Robillard
    Luc Robillard 19 days ago

    What are your guys' favorite Marauder?
    I like Remus and Sirius, but I'm gonna have to go with Sirius.

  • Luna Nyx Nightshade
    Luna Nyx Nightshade 20 days ago

    I got 30 out of 30

  • Ravenclaw Pancake
    Ravenclaw Pancake 21 day ago

    No because they figured out he was a werewolf in 2nd year so in 5th year. Right?

  • 1Coby
    1Coby 21 day ago

    Sirius, Lupin, Dobby, Buckbeak, Fawkes. Favourite characters

  • TJ Is Human
    TJ Is Human 21 day ago

    I took them 3 years to work out HOW to do it but it took the 2 years to actually get it right because gosh darn it Peter!

  • Jen And Urwin
    Jen And Urwin 21 day ago

    I think, I only got one wrong. Oooooooo, yeeeeah!

  • lindsey vlog life
    lindsey vlog life 22 days ago

    They found out that lupin was a wolf year 2 and so it took them three years so it was their fifth year

  • Kate Gunn
    Kate Gunn 23 days ago

    Curiously, in the U.S. edition of Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, the line referencing Vault 711 was modified to read "I used your name but told them to take the gold from my own Gringotts vault." The original line read "I used your name but told them to take the gold from Gringotts vault number seven hundred and eleven -- my own

  • RobloxandMinecrafters4life

    22:05, yes he does

  • RobloxandMinecrafters4life

    the one about the "nice dog" i knew.

  • Ashley Boseman
    Ashley Boseman 25 days ago +1

    I got 100%!!

  • Summer Kaye
    Summer Kaye 25 days ago

    I have the Snitch they have on the table! It’s so cool!!

  • Eye Kona
    Eye Kona 26 days ago

    "Somebody Told you who R.A.B. was?" I reread all the books and wrote down all names who could fit. It were two and I figured out, it is Regulus Black all on my own. ^^

  • Kenneth Schroeder
    Kenneth Schroeder 26 days ago

    But when did Sirius and James find out Lupin was a werewolf? Because you would have to add three years to that year they found out

  • Akseli Halonen
    Akseli Halonen 26 days ago +1

    Whoa i beat You guys 27-18-18 without multiple choises.

  • Kal-el Pottervey
    Kal-el Pottervey 26 days ago

    I actually know the vault numbers for some reason

  • Jenny Shull
    Jenny Shull 26 days ago

    12 long years I waited

  • Marion Manalo
    Marion Manalo 26 days ago

    I got 27/30!

  • logan handley
    logan handley 27 days ago


  • Ombre Dragon
    Ombre Dragon 27 days ago

    Sirius says that Barty crouch Jr came in Azkaban and died less than a year later sooo yeah

  • Dontisco
    Dontisco 29 days ago

    Not correct about the year they became an animagus, if you read it, it said ‘THEY’ managed to do it, which is referring to James, Sirius and Peter. They would of found out that Lupin was a werewolf in there 2nd year and then it took ‘three years to work it out’ thus they all became animagus in there fifth year.

  • Zoey Neal
    Zoey Neal 29 days ago

    It took them all until the fifth year because they didn’t know Lupin was a werewolf until their 2nd year and it took them all 3 years to LEARN it 2+3=5 there ya go

  • Samara Llenas
    Samara Llenas Month ago

    It took them 3 years, but they didn’t find out he was a werewolf until 2nd, right??

  • Bryce Davis
    Bryce Davis Month ago

    Where did you get the golden snitch from?

  • Stephanie Hernandez

    I liked this. I took the quiz before watching and I got 28/30. I think that its because I love Sirius and he is one of my favorite characters.

  • leah schell
    leah schell Month ago

    This quiz was actually kinda easy for me.

  • Shannon Mann
    Shannon Mann Month ago

    When they learned to become animagus? It took them the better part of three years to learn it, but, it DOESN'T say when they started. so, the quiz is correct. They learned it in 5th year, with Peter needing much help to even do it at all....

  • Joseph Lind
    Joseph Lind Month ago

    I just rewatched the crimes of grimwald and I noticed something.
    Grimwald was lying to credence, he isn't a Dumbledore because the phoenix didn't come to credence , grimwald already had it there as a baby chick, so he just timed it so that it would grow to maturity when credence was there

  • Maximus Anigacz
    Maximus Anigacz Month ago

    The last one was the easiest

  • Sara Samaletdin
    Sara Samaletdin Month ago

    Sirius wasn’t blasted of for becoming a Gryffindor at age 11but running away from home at 16 so I am glad Ben got the point.

  • taylor prawito
    taylor prawito Month ago

    Omg I got 66% like I’m so bad at Sirius black quiz

  • Sarah ODell
    Sarah ODell Month ago

    Sirius's cousin is a first cousin, Draco would be once removed. If Sirius had a son/daughter, his child and Draco would be second cousins.
    When Sirius buys Harry the broom he uses Harry's name but his own vault, when Sirius told Harry this did he say his vault number?

  • Kari Barron
    Kari Barron Month ago

    J is so cute, he has VERY nice arms. Not super buff, and not super lanky. Helps that he is confident too.

  • Jennifer Elizabeth Edwards

    28/30 · Scored 93%
    Result: Siriusly Brilliant
    Mischief managed! Whether you know him as Snuffles, Padfoot, or just plain old Sirius, your knowledge on this character is enviable. The keys to Grimmauld Place are yours! If it was real.

  • MizzNijna
    MizzNijna Month ago

    14:12 Omg, What is it Derek never noticed?! I need to know.

  • Doctor Dad
    Doctor Dad Month ago

    I got most of these wrong, however I got 22 correct and was proud so I wanted to share.

  • TTV Editz_SZ
    TTV Editz_SZ Month ago

    I’ve been watching since 87k

  • Eden Garvey
    Eden Garvey Month ago

    im sorry but at 14:23 did Derek say the k-night bus instead of pronouncing it correctly.


  • Katie Moretz
    Katie Moretz Month ago +2


  • Kyle Parent
    Kyle Parent Month ago

    It took them 3 years to figure out how, but knowing the procedure and actually completing the transformation are 2 different things. Plus that is 3 years from when they discovered remus is a werewolf which isn't necessarily in their first year. Book says they all finished in 5th year and Peter needed help, not that he took longer

  • David Messer
    David Messer Month ago

    I cracked up with the vault number question. :)
    I'd be totally impressed if anyone actually knew that.

  • miss unknown
    miss unknown Month ago

    very cool video I enjoyed it

  • 3Z Movers
    3Z Movers Month ago

    I got 22!!!!!!

  • Kiera Espey
    Kiera Espey Month ago

    It took them 3 years but they started in second year

  • Frosty Star
    Frosty Star Month ago

    They found out Lupin was a werewolf in there 2nd year, it took them three year to complete, so they managed it in fifth year. Pettigrew needed some help, but completed it in the same year as James and Sirius.

  • emuzoo 09
    emuzoo 09 Month ago +1

    The 11th question, they figured it out in the 3rd year but they didn't become animagi until the 5th year due to wormtail.

  • mekseb mike
    mekseb mike Month ago

    The year that Sirius James and Peter becomes an Animagus has to be before or the year they have the O.W.L.S cause in the end of the exam when Peter tells them he can't get all the answer right to describe a werewolf James told Peter"you walk out with a werewolf every once a month"
    Edit he doesn't say walk but I forgot

  • mekseb mike
    mekseb mike Month ago

    Sirius is my fav from Harry potter I cried sip hard when he died


    ben does great british accents lol

  • PA
    PA Month ago

    They don't figure out Lupin's lycanthrope until the 2nd year and then it took three more school years to become animagi

  • Sophia Ballard
    Sophia Ballard Month ago

    9 3/4 is the almost the same as Snape's " turn to page 394"

  • Shadow Star
    Shadow Star Month ago

    I GOT 13 :(

  • Skits N’ Gaming
    Skits N’ Gaming Month ago +4

    Is it only me or Ben looks like jacksepticeye

  • Dragan Snyder
    Dragan Snyder Month ago

    I got a pat on the black literally that's what it's called or 63%

  • Kiren Nasta
    Kiren Nasta Month ago

    The god rest ye merry was on the 2017 Christmas quiz

  • Cowz 115
    Cowz 115 Month ago +1

    The they as it is in lupins prospective also includes james and sirius

  • Paula Luckylope
    Paula Luckylope Month ago


  • geno love
    geno love Month ago


  • Georgia Zz
    Georgia Zz Month ago +3

    I always root for J like to root for J comment to root for Be

  • Starwars Girl
    Starwars Girl Month ago

    I got the muddy paw print right 🐾

  • Ravenclaw Pride
    Ravenclaw Pride Month ago

    0:43 Why are his eyes so far apart (right)

  • Cohen Wright
    Cohen Wright Month ago

    Yh it took them 3 years to become animagus but they only figured out that lupin was a werewolf in their 2nd year

  • Platy Poof
    Platy Poof Month ago

    (Gets question wrong)


  • Maddie Johnson
    Maddie Johnson Month ago

    I got them all right

  • PrettyChillKid
    PrettyChillKid Month ago