J vs Ben: ULTIMATE Sirius Black Quiz

  • Published on May 24, 2018
  • Take the Quiz :: www.pottermore.com/features/back-to-sirius-black-quiz
    Today J and Ben dive into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter and face off to see who has more knowledge of of the most infamous convict to ever escape Azkaban: Sirius Black!
    Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► bit.ly/2oDIxOL
    J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
    Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
    Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ tvclip.biz/user/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    V L O G➜ tvclip.biz/user/jonathancarlin
    T W I T T E R➜ twitter.com/jonkerlin & twitter.com/SCB_Ben
    I N S T A G R A M➜ instagram.com/jonkerlin & instagram.com/scb_ben
    F A C E B O O K➜ facebook.com/supercarlinbrothers
    G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    P A T R E O N ➜ www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Want to send us something?
    Super Carlin Brothers
    PO Box 4339
    Roanoke, Virginia 24015
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Comments • 3 862

  • Luke Loew8
    Luke Loew8 6 hours ago

    I got 22,I feel pretty good about mydldf

  • Jay Johnson
    Jay Johnson 3 days ago

    They started trying in their 2nd year, which means that in three years, it was their 5th year.

  • jun seila
    jun seila 4 days ago


  • Danae Kolyva
    Danae Kolyva 7 days ago

    I don't intend to watch this I just came to say his mom's name was Walburga :)

  • Luka 13
    Luka 13 7 days ago

    J: 8; Ben: 5

  • Luka 13
    Luka 13 7 days ago

    J: 8; Ben: 5

  • Luka 13
    Luka 13 7 days ago

    J: 8; Ben: 5

  • Luka 13
    Luka 13 7 days ago

    J: 8; Ben: 5

  • layla singletary
    layla singletary 9 days ago

    they became animagi in 5th year because they found out that lupin was a werewolf in their 2nd year

  • David Fluffy Jr
    David Fluffy Jr 10 days ago

    12:52 the text literally says on the bottom, “finally in our *fifth* year they managed it”

  • virginia7191
    virginia7191 10 days ago

    25 out of 30 but I used the multiple choice on some of them.

  • Percusionlove91
    Percusionlove91 10 days ago

    Is that oxhorn reading off the questions?

  • Doge
    Doge 11 days ago +1

    12:00 no J it was not in fact wrong read the poa again maybe?

  • Cheesy Sarah
    Cheesy Sarah 11 days ago +2

    "in our fifth year,they managed it."

  • juliet burns
    juliet burns 12 days ago


  • Skellybone
    Skellybone 12 days ago +1

    When Sirius was explaining to Harry about buying the Firebolt, he says that he signed in as Harry, but still took gold from his vault, which was 711.

  • angel whispers
    angel whispers 13 days ago +1

    23:50 darn it Ben...
    30:37 really...

  • Maria Vassallo
    Maria Vassallo 16 days ago +1

    all correct but 1 (i read order of the pheonix yesterday

  • max bowder
    max bowder 16 days ago

    It way have took them 3 years to do it but they first found out lupin was a werewolf in their 2nd year. So that answer is true 5th year

  • Kristina Hard
    Kristina Hard 17 days ago


  • 436jcarr
    436jcarr 18 days ago

    For the animagus question

    They found out about lupin being s werewolf in there second year and it took them their third year to find out how to become animagi and they accomplished it in there fifth year

  • DeclanG
    DeclanG 18 days ago

    I got 26/30

  • Tristan Oberbroeckling
    Tristan Oberbroeckling 20 days ago +3

    A true Slytherin would not have apologized for tricking J!!!!!

  • Pooja Kumar
    Pooja Kumar 23 days ago

    I scored 24

  • Pooja Kumar
    Pooja Kumar 23 days ago

    The fifth year is correct wormtail padfoot and prongs all became animagus in fifth year after finding out lupin was werewolf in their 2nd year. They took 3years to become animagus

  • Theblaze07
    Theblaze07 24 days ago

    It took them three years to do it yes BUT they didnt work on it until they found out lupin was a werewolf in there 2nd year so they would have figured it out in their 5th year at Hogwarts

  • Highrise75
    Highrise75 24 days ago

    I didnt keep count but I think I got about 7 wrong so 23???

  • AshidentsHappen
    AshidentsHappen 24 days ago +2

    I just spent an ungodly amount of time with the family tree titles breakdown figuring out 16:41

  • What's Life Without a Little Risk?

    I accidentally skipped, and was about to watch, when I was like, "Oh! I should go take the test so I don't cheat!" Well I paused it at the perfect time 1:08

  • Floyd Freeman
    Floyd Freeman 26 days ago

    In the text it said by the 5th year they managed it

  • Polly Alexander
    Polly Alexander 26 days ago


  • Lucianne Stoltzfus
    Lucianne Stoltzfus 26 days ago +16

    I got most of them right, INCLUDING the Hanna Abbot one.

  • nana
    nana Month ago

    can't believe i got 19 on it,,

  • kinata kofa
    kinata kofa Month ago

    this was a cake walk to me as a walking wiki for harry

  • Devin Sloane
    Devin Sloane Month ago

    I think the text is unclear on the year. It does say it took them three years to work out how it was done but that doesn't mean, necessarily, that they could actually do it themselves. Just that they worked out what is needed for it. While it does sound like they're saying it took three years, the next line down sounds like they all did succeeded in their fifth year. Idk, I think it was written in a rather unclear way.

  • apuppy567
    apuppy567 Month ago

    I saw the 711 coming. I could have gotten it, they discussed it in his will in the 6th book if I am not mistaken. When Dumbledore is talking to Harry on summer break. Pretty sure.

  • Lost hero
    Lost hero Month ago +1

    They found out about lupin in 2nd year, so if it took 3 years it would be 5th year

  • Lusine Baghyan
    Lusine Baghyan Month ago

    29/30 yeah I'm a fan.

  • Ahlyana Seaman
    Ahlyana Seaman Month ago

    well we basically all failed that although I got so many of the questions you didn't do then you got so many of the ones I didn't like how do you guys always get the hard ones I miss that easy ones also remix says that they figured he was a werewolf in his third year and that they became anime giant in their 5th year it does not say anything about Peter figuring it out later he just says they meaning they all figured it out the same year and there are few other point I was going to make it already forgot because that was a really long video God rest ye merry hippogriffs oh and to answer your question the shrub helps him high because he walks into the castle the human turns into a shrub in anyone's looking oh Hannah Abbott you're hilarious didn't Neville end up married to her and we're also convinced Neville and Luna what happened oh well guess it's herbology credits

  • Amber Wilfong
    Amber Wilfong Month ago +3

    Question 6...the convo about the years harry potter came out...you open at the close.

  • Sopita
    Sopita Month ago

    How did I not remember his vault was 7 eleven

    • Ahlyana Seaman
      Ahlyana Seaman Month ago

      Because it never says it I honestly can't remember ever telling us his vault number I would have remembered that too because I've seriously close to the sorcerer's Stone and I make those connections so yeah there is no way I could have missed that let's it's on Pottermore somewhere in an article I haven't read yet which means I've basically been spoiled for furthermore LOL

  • K Jewels
    K Jewels Month ago +1

    12:25 I already know it was their 5th year. But it legit says at the bottom. "Finally, in our fifth year, they managed it." So, that means they started their 2nd year and finished their 5th year.

    • Ahlyana Seaman
      Ahlyana Seaman Month ago

      I know wait didn't they start their third year but yeah I definitely remember that line specifically and finally in our fifth year they figured it out and I'm like you guys are so pathetic how do you not know this how do you not pay attention to every single line Remus lupin ever says

  • Hanvika Allamsetty
    Hanvika Allamsetty Month ago +1

    hello in your own proof if you read in there fifth year they managed it!!!!

    • Ahlyana Seaman
      Ahlyana Seaman Month ago

      it's funny they're acting like they're proving themselves right and then like in be so funny if we're wrong and we are all here watching and going like yeah guys

  • Ville
    Ville Month ago +1

    Draco said something like ill be dogging your steps or something

  • Cora Lanford-Crick
    Cora Lanford-Crick Month ago +1

    Sirius's vault number come up in the letter at the end of the 3rd book when they are on the train. He tells harry that it was him who got the firebolt, something about crookshanks and an order form, and how he put it under harry's number but USED HIS VAULT NUMBER 711!!!

    • Cora Lanford-Crick
      Cora Lanford-Crick Month ago

      "Crookshanks took the order to the owl office for me. I used your name, but told them to take the gold vault number 711, my own." -Prisoner of Askaban ( the audiobook)

    • Ahlyana Seaman
      Ahlyana Seaman Month ago

      There is absolutely no way it says that but it's got to be in some kind of special edition or something

  • 36513 Playz
    36513 Playz Month ago

    When they were talking about animagi it is the fifth year it took them 3 years to master animahgus not including finding out about lupins lycanthropy.

  • Kathryn Allen
    Kathryn Allen Month ago +1

    Why did he pronounce the k in knight bus???

    • Ahlyana Seaman
      Ahlyana Seaman 25 days ago

      It's an inside joke of theirs you have to walk further other videos to get it

    • cg standing
      cg standing 25 days ago

      because it's a joke.

    • Ahlyana Seaman
      Ahlyana Seaman Month ago

      I know right I was wondering about that I mean I didn't even know it had a case until this video

  • awesomedude123 456
    awesomedude123 456 Month ago +1

    I got 28 out of 30! I got 27 and 30 wrong. How did I get so many right?! Well, I do love Sirius Black... ❤😍😍😘😂

  • Maya Kowski
    Maya Kowski Month ago +1

    I knew Ms. Crouch was in Azkaban.

    • Ahlyana Seaman
      Ahlyana Seaman Month ago

      the boys are going what's the third did Sears ever mention crouch coming in and I'm over here like yes very very explicitly during the goblet of fire scene where he is telling them that he saw a Barty crouch jr. Being brought in and I'm like how are you guys not remember honestly they can be so pathetic sometimes

  • Lalisa Oppa
    Lalisa Oppa 2 months ago

    Now I want a Hannah Abbott video lol

  • Laughlin Mercedes
    Laughlin Mercedes 2 months ago +1


  • Laughlin Mercedes
    Laughlin Mercedes 2 months ago

    At 17:05 I wanted to see the conversation

  • teo baigent
    teo baigent 2 months ago

    Omg on his vault i guessed 713 it was 711 woow

  • Tenley Jackson
    Tenley Jackson 2 months ago +2

    Do they not understand that Hannah Abbet married Neville. 🙄

  • Tenley Jackson
    Tenley Jackson 2 months ago


  • Jedi Loki Pumpkin
    Jedi Loki Pumpkin 2 months ago

    I knew

  • Storm Retro
    Storm Retro 2 months ago +1

    If u picks hippogrif feather it attacks you hagrid said it in the 3rd book so it couldn’t have been a hippogrif feather

  • Snuffles The Marauders
    Snuffles The Marauders 2 months ago

    Took the pottermore quiz and got 100%! Don't believe me, well, I don't give one.

  • Christine Joyce Sanvictores

    J and Ben I got 13 points. I’ve learned a lot. And James and Sirius transformed at third year. Peter during 5th year.

  • emily cheetham
    emily cheetham 2 months ago

    Yes Iv never even read the books and I got no 25 correct. Is knew it wasn’t a feather as the hypogryph feather is with the broom Harry gets.

  • emily cheetham
    emily cheetham 2 months ago +1

    I always get mixed up on the different of second cousin and first cousin once removed.

  • emily cheetham
    emily cheetham 2 months ago

    I figured out RAB before Harry, Ron and Hermione did.

  • Liam Downey
    Liam Downey 2 months ago

    It took until third year to figure out but it wasn't until fifth year till they actually became a animagus

  • Jiexi Chen
    Jiexi Chen 2 months ago

    It means it took them three years to do it and I’m pretty sure they did not find out in their first year right?

  • Theøretìcał Kìñdš
    Theøretìcał Kìñdš 2 months ago +1

    I love Harry Potter and I got 5😭😭😭

  • geno love
    geno love 2 months ago

    I got 20-30

  • Marissa BeDell
    Marissa BeDell 2 months ago

    29 out of 30

  • Maria João Ribeirinho Capeloa

    I love watching SCB

  • Heather Sacco
    Heather Sacco 2 months ago

    also i knew his mother's name because of all the harry potter as vines

  • Heather Sacco
    Heather Sacco 2 months ago +1

    sirius is meh favorite character so i didn't get many wrong (rip sirius)

  • Jennifer Eichhorn
    Jennifer Eichhorn 2 months ago

    Sometimes they drive me nuts with an idea that they know more than the writers of the quiz and then ignore the bottom of their own reasoning. It doesn’t say they all managed it, it says they managed it which is completely different syntactically. Then they go to the trouble of putting up an agreement with them on another question they questioned. They are very imaginative and delve in depth for their theories, but don’t realize that lupin was trying to keep them in the dark so it took them a while to work out what was actually going on.

  • Monardo N.
    Monardo N. 2 months ago +2

    Harry: your white
    Sirius: No I'm black
    Harry: lol ok stop joking
    Sirius: I'm not joking. I'm Sirius.
    Also Sirius Black is my favorite character🙂

    • Pugs4Ever
      Pugs4Ever 24 days ago

      awesomedude123 456 : You have a crush on Sirius?

      I’m in love with *Draco*

    • awesomedude123 456
      awesomedude123 456 Month ago

      He may be your favourite character, but I've got a crush on him. ❤

  • Jennifer Barter
    Jennifer Barter 2 months ago

    21 :)

  • PikaMeer
    PikaMeer 2 months ago

    How did they not get 25? GoF is my least read book and yet I still got it correct. Harry gets the hippogrif feather with the firebolt (I think?)

    • PikaMeer
      PikaMeer 2 months ago +1

      Oh yeah yeah, I often get the books/movies confused. I think it’s because the visual image is more memorable than the words in the book. Thanks!

    • Jennifer Eichhorn
      Jennifer Eichhorn 2 months ago

      The feather with the firebolt was PoA movie, they find out that he gave Harry the firebolt with the letter he sent him on the train, coincidentally this was also when we see the number of his vault. In GoF he sent the parchment with the muddy paw print because he was still in hiding as a dog in Hogsmeade.

  • Dark Luigi47
    Dark Luigi47 2 months ago

    I know people have been saying it already but the text for them becoming animagi says that they figured out how to do it during their third year and it took them till the fifth year to do it. Also Sirius' best line in the Prisoner of Azkaban movie, "I've done my waiting! 12 years of it, in Azkaban!"

  • Odin Satanas
    Odin Satanas 2 months ago

    thats really funny, i had the same experience
    i was in my early teens when HBP came out, and that was the first fan theory id heard too, about RAB haha
    i was heading to Jr Lifegaurds that summer and was reading it, and we talked about it while surfing

  • Melissa Lofgren
    Melissa Lofgren 2 months ago

    I got 16

  • Fra Patten
    Fra Patten 2 months ago

    I feel like I have disgraced Sirius Black.

  • Royaa Ramy
    Royaa Ramy 2 months ago

    24/30... I'm Siriusly proud of myself.

    • awesomedude123 456
      awesomedude123 456 Month ago

      28/30 I'm even more Siriusly proud of myself! 😀😏😛😜😝😛😜😝🙃👍👍

  • Normal'sWayOverrated
    Normal'sWayOverrated 2 months ago


  • Normal'sWayOverrated
    Normal'sWayOverrated 2 months ago

    The found out how to become animagi in their third year, they actually did it in their fifth year.

  • Mc Mikey
    Mc Mikey 2 months ago

    On the nice dog Potter Malloy says one step out of line Potter and I’ll be dogging at your heels

  • Mia Wade
    Mia Wade 2 months ago

    Is it bad that I only know the old generation answers because I’m obsessed with reading Tom Riddle FanFiction 😂😂

  • Vidya rajeev
    Vidya rajeev 2 months ago

    Carlin brothers, James, Sirius and Peter got to know that Lupin is a Werewolf in their second year, so as mentioned in the extract in the video, it took them 3 years which means 2+3 = 5. So Sirius and James became animagi in their fifth year. J and Ben pls reply for this

  • shorty foster
    shorty foster 2 months ago

    Sirius did tell them about Barty and even saw “his” body being buried

  • Swords Dance
    Swords Dance 2 months ago

    OMG!!! I got 27 out of 30!! (And yes, i was keeping track of my scores)

  • IE Cameron
    IE Cameron 2 months ago

    12:30 they didn’t find out lupin was a werewolf until their second year at hogwarts so it took them 3 years to find out how to do it meaning they were at their 5th year when they acc became an animagus ,, cmon guys this was an easy one😂😂

  • Simply arti
    Simply arti 2 months ago

    I had 21 correct

  • Lawrence Ge
    Lawrence Ge 2 months ago +1

    Its when Sirius explains how he bought the fire bolt and gets crooks Hanks and says 711

  • Lawrence Ge
    Lawrence Ge 2 months ago

    It says finally in their fifth year

  • warron24
    warron24 2 months ago

    22:16 Trick question. His name is Sirius Black not Sirius Gold.

  • Randomness is my name
    Randomness is my name 3 months ago

    ( ^-^ )
    / >🍕>
    who wants some FREE pizza!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • rock ruff
    rock ruff 3 months ago

    Hannah is great, fav character

  • Benjamin Frederick
    Benjamin Frederick 3 months ago

    I got 23 correct overall what did you get?

  • Shayla Roblox
    Shayla Roblox 3 months ago

    12:16 The text said ''Finally, in our fifth year, they managed it" *they* not *he* if they were referring to Peter, they would say he. It took them three years to do it.

  • Olivia Mchugh
    Olivia Mchugh 3 months ago

    Sirius and James guessed in their 2nd year and then it took them till their 5th year (3 years later) to get it right

  • Benjamin Frederick
    Benjamin Frederick 3 months ago

    For question 26 I did 717

  • Benjamin Frederick
    Benjamin Frederick 3 months ago +1

    It says in their second year they figured out that he was A werewolf and it took them the better part of three years to figure out how to become animagi
    So they figured out how to do it in their fifth year

  • Jessica Carozza
    Jessica Carozza 3 months ago


  • Amanda Lunaria Diaz Butterfly