Why Lucius Malfoy Is The Worst Death Eater Ever

  • Published on May 10, 2018
  • Use our link www.audible.com/scb or text code scb to 500-500 to get a free book and 30-day free trial.
    Today Ben dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss one of the least effective Death Eaters of them all and his plan to kill Harry in the Chamber of Secrets.
    Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► bit.ly/2oDIxOL
    J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
    Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
    Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ tvclip.biz/user/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    V L O G➜ tvclip.biz/user/jonathancarlin
    T W I T T E R➜ jonkerlin & SCB_Ben
    I N S T A G R A M➜ jonkerlin & scb_ben
    F A C E B O O K➜ supercarlinbrothers
    G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
    P A T R E O N ➜ www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Want to send us something?
    Super Carlin Brothers
    PO Box 4339
    Roanoke, Virginia 24015
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Comments • 2 392

  • Caleb Cohoon
    Caleb Cohoon Day ago

    Percy Jackson all of them please

  • Pineapple Panda
    Pineapple Panda 5 days ago

    5:05 lol beat part

  • Evie Taylor
    Evie Taylor 7 days ago +1

    Read Warhammer Adventures: Attack Of The Necron on Audible

  • David Zimmerman
    David Zimmerman 7 days ago +2

    Harry:we need to find Draco
    Ron:do you like muggleborns
    Draco: no there filthy mud bloods
    Ron and Harry:found him.

  • David Zimmerman
    David Zimmerman 7 days ago +1

    Draco' s a better deatheater makes sense he was able to open that thing in the room of requirement and his dad destroyed the prophecy

  • KD GrimX
    KD GrimX 7 days ago


  • MrKneeV
    MrKneeV 7 days ago +1

    I don't believe Lucius ever had "being bad" as his goal, or that he even cared about being loyal to Voldemort. He simply wanted to protect his family, and believed that aligning with Voldemort was the best means to that end.

  • Elmays Maneri
    Elmays Maneri 7 days ago +1

    4.15 then I assume the only category I fit into is Dark Lords.
    Dear diary, today I accomplished something and I'm proud of myself

  • Reg
    Reg 9 days ago

    Lucuis reminds me of Peter.

  • Melodie Ferrin
    Melodie Ferrin 10 days ago

    Not to mention all the unnecessary abuse done to Dobby...

  • Just an Introvert
    Just an Introvert 10 days ago

    In my opinion, Voldemort recruited Lucius for his wealth and influence. It's more about politics and money than skills and offense. Plus, his parents will disown him if he refuses.

  • Jubilacian
    Jubilacian 13 days ago

    I never really thought that Lucius knew what the diary was at all (and might have forgotten/not known it came from Voldemort at all). I thought when I first read it that he was just trying to get Dark Objects out of his house and he maybe thought it would be embarrassing if one was found with a family member of the Wizard who was looking for them. ::shrugs::

  • #HarryPotterNerd4Life Pribula

    WAIT, WAIT, WAIT! Lucius Malfoy is bad at being a death eater? I never would have noticed if you didn’t tell me ( she said sarcastically )
    My father will here about this!

    3xM -DRACONIC 15 days ago

    what if the malfoys where dubbel agents?

  • Amy Lee
    Amy Lee 17 days ago

    Your parents were meddlesome fools, too! Mark my words, Potter! One of these days, you are going to meet the same sticky end!

  • Cougars in Tuxes
    Cougars in Tuxes 17 days ago

    In chamber of secrets he tries to avada kedavra him after setting dobby free i feel like no one talks about this

  • Isabelle
    Isabelle 17 days ago

    Listen to Percy Jackson

  • energiesoler
    energiesoler 17 days ago

    I'm pretty sure at the end the Order of the Phoenix lets Malfoy out because they figured if Voldemort has more plans to come back (like a secret daughter trying to mess the timeline or something) they would have less chances to succeed with Lucius in on them

  • E play_859
    E play_859 18 days ago

    I'm waiting for Chinese wizard school they go all year long probably learned more spells cause you got Americans school Europe school an African but no asian ?

  • E play_859
    E play_859 18 days ago

    If Voldemort never went after baby harry would harry still been able to match him. Voldemort would of remained in power, Potter probably would of stayed hidden, an Neville parents wouldn't of been tortured an Neville could of been his equal the whole time getting his own wand in year one not his father's which didn't help but still kept with the class, how do they grade can you be held back or summer school

  • Rusty Blader
    Rusty Blader 18 days ago

    So he's basically a less competent Saruman

  • dresdencypher
    dresdencypher 19 days ago

    Well technically he successfully killed buckbeak before time travel was used.

  • EiferBrennan
    EiferBrennan 19 days ago

    The only problem I have with this theory is Draco Malfoy would not have been at risk with the Basilisk, Not only was he pure-blood, he was also a Slytherin, and therefore had nothing to fear from Slytherin's monster.

  • David Meyer
    David Meyer 21 day ago +3

    2:20 - Technically he IS successful in getting Buckbeak _SENTENCED_ to death. Getting that sentence _carried out_ is another matter.

    • Short Tj
      Short Tj 9 days ago

      Given the circumstance you can’t really blame luscious for that.

  • Tanya Smith
    Tanya Smith 22 days ago +1

    Ah, Lucius Abraxas Malfoy... My favorite character, so I simply must come to his defense. Lucius did not make the choice to become a Death Eater himself, he was pressured into it as a child, it was his father's decision. Lucius was still young and in his final years of Hogwarts when the Dark Lord rose to power, therefore he received the Dark Mark before he was of age. In pureblood circles, children are married shortly after graduating from school. Therefore, Lucius would only be 19-20 years old when Draco was born. The war lasted for eleven years, so Lucius did not have a choice when he became a Death Eater. Rant Over.

  • Briana GregoryHowe
    Briana GregoryHowe 22 days ago

    I know this comment has NOTHING to do with the video but is it a bad thing I have an oc who is Draco's younger sister by a year in-spite of me knowing he is an only child?

  • nunya
    nunya 23 days ago

    Your list didn't include Skyrim bandits.

  • Derkainer Sledgehammer Productions

    Read the dragonriders of pern by ann McCaffrey

  • Camryn Keen
    Camryn Keen 24 days ago

    Listen to the king killer chronicles

  • Christopher Barker
    Christopher Barker 24 days ago

    WORMTAIL is worse!!!!?

  • TheRizlaSlim
    TheRizlaSlim 24 days ago

    I feel like the topic of this video changed part way through haha

  • Marvin H
    Marvin H 25 days ago

    Is Malfoy the worst deatheater ever?
    I know this is a late post, and that it is too long, so don’t bother to read it. I wanted to respond months ago, but I didn’t have my thoughts sorted out yet.
    I think you are right about Lucious Malfoy and his family not being the most powerful magic users nor the most ruthless. I would like to point out the manner in which the Malfoy family actually is the most “important” Deatheater family.
    Lord Voldemort, in books 5 - 7, is trying to fill the role of charismatic leader. He is building an army to take over the government and bring down Albus Dumbledore and the Hogwarts School. To do this he must recruit as many wizards and witches as possible. He will need people who will be able to fill the positions that come open in the government, fill the vacancies at the school, and who will gain and mold the willing compliance of the general populace.
    Lord Voldemort will need to recruit a wide variety of individuals. Just like any other army, he will need cannon fodder as well as officers. As cannon fodder, he just needs powerful viciousness that he can some-what control. Trolls, werewolves, giants, dementors, and various criminals will make great cannon fodder.
    To fill the position of his officers, and for people to place in his government and teaching positions, he needs intelligence. He cannot recruit these officers with the promise of “all the man-flesh they can eat.” Lord Voldemort must show people something that he has that they want. A snake-like face with no hair, red eyes, and slits for nostrils will not entice anyone.
    The kind of wizards, that Lord Voldemort needs to recruit, must be intelligent and have a lust for power. This is where the Malfoy family come in. The Malfoy family are the example of pure-blood that also have the wealth, influence, beauty, and prestige that people find attractive. The fact that they have always been “faithful” to Lord Voldemort, implies that these virtues can be maintained and/or obtained by association with Lord Voldemort. The Malfoy family is Lord Voldemort’s advertisement campaign for his officers.

    • Lahly Bird
      Lahly Bird 24 days ago

      I think that plan may have backfired a little

  • Michael Munsinger
    Michael Munsinger 26 days ago +1

    I thought he gave the diary to Ginny because of Arthur Weasley's muggle protection act and was trying to get him discredited so it wouldn't pass...

  • ColinG_13
    ColinG_13 27 days ago +1

    #piechartresponsibly 🥧

  • Back2BackSisters
    Back2BackSisters 27 days ago

    5:05 I died

  • Seren Fryar
    Seren Fryar 29 days ago +4

    If he was writing in the diary, then maybe Tom told him to send it to Hogwarts

  • Spectre Gacha
    Spectre Gacha Month ago +5

    I can just imagine Lucius rallying after Harry

    Lucius: My lord, how do you plan to take over the world?

    *Baby Harry grabs Lucius's hair*

    Lucius: Yes my lord, I know my hair is luscious

  • Andrew Cotton
    Andrew Cotton Month ago

    I could be get in the movies and the books mixed up, but isn't the ministry doing more and more raids at the start of book 2 looking for dark objects, even though Lucius didn't know the diary was a horcrux he did know it was a powerful dark object, so he might have been trying to get rid of dark objects so it could not be found at his house and also as an extra benefit hurt the Weasley family which he despised. Lucius must have been one of the best Death Eaters before Voldemort's downfall because Voldemort entrusted him with a horcrux, Lucius did not think Voldemort would ever return or he wouldn't have got rid of the diary.

  • Sarah Wendall
    Sarah Wendall Month ago

    Actually, Lucius gave the scenario when he gave Ginny Riddle's diary. (Just sayin')

  • Mikel Garmendia
    Mikel Garmendia Month ago

    Keep in mind that Lucius was indeed one of the very few Death Eaters that had a child and so he would want to keep him away from the dangers he is in is just paternal logic. He believed in the cause of Voldemort's superficial plan: wizarding world's supremacy.
    But he knew there was something else, so he would make whatever in his hands (the possible in his position) to put away his son from Voldemort

  • Annalise Vezina
    Annalise Vezina Month ago +1

    Lucius Malfoy is literally the definition of all talk no bite

  • Andy Raven Chenoweth

    I always assumed lucius was voldys starscream... he wanted to be leader, so he needed harry to beat voldamort, so undercover helping the protagonist. He literally reminds me of James of team rocket.

  • Hailey Powell
    Hailey Powell Month ago +1

    #piechartslammed #piechartresponsably

  • kirbalicious420
    kirbalicious420 Month ago

    Your diary pie chart is missing Doug Funny.

  • Andrew Hernandez
    Andrew Hernandez Month ago

    Using this logic I think Pettigrew might be the best Death Eater.

  • Angry Scotsman
    Angry Scotsman Month ago

    Stephen fry is better lol

  • Nathaniel Stacy
    Nathaniel Stacy Month ago

    As Tom Riddle JR. is himself a Mugblood He as an upper classes likely gave the Dirary to Luscious when they were at school together, scence a Mugblood would not be anything but food to the Basilisc.

  • Mr Random
    Mr Random Month ago +1

    Who else was picturing luscius Malloy with a ponytail having a fuss

  • Rida Khan
    Rida Khan Month ago

    i think he left it with ginny because ministry was raiding houses and malfoy wanted to get rid of that diary and there was no use selling the diary like he sell all those other things. So he gave the diary to one of the supposbely weakest weasley because malfoy hated them.

  • Mason Schwalm
    Mason Schwalm Month ago

    Harry Potter and Hermione fighting for house elf rights! #ElfLivesMatter

  • Kawaii Gaming
    Kawaii Gaming Month ago


  • Daniel Stoica
    Daniel Stoica Month ago

    If Draco wrote in Tom Riddle Diary, the ink would be absorbed.. That is what happens with Harry. However, I would expect a "Why are you bothering me, get me back to Hogearts, or I am pulling you into this diary to kick around." to appear.

  • xcel feary boi recruit mr meme

    And because he stared a whole movie

  • Sheena Su
    Sheena Su Month ago +1

    Draco wouldn't be at risk since the basilisk only attack Muggle-Borns like Hermione, Colin, and Justin

  • resen ven
    resen ven Month ago

    In the first wizarding war lusius was actually one of voldemorts most trusted and effective death eaters

  • Guðbjörg Gísladóttir

    Lucius Malfoy did exactly nothing unless he was ordered to do it. Why Harry´s second year? Because Voldemort told him to. And Voldemort could not do anything after loosing his body and his fight with Harry before the end of Harry´s first year. Lucius was trapped. He most likely wanted out of the Death Eater group altogether and could not find a way to so. Laying down his live ? No way. He wanted to be feared and powerful. Not wanting to risk his live for anybody or anything.

  • Neveah Devries
    Neveah Devries Month ago


  • William Stephenson
    William Stephenson Month ago

    Lucius Malfoy introducesv riddle`s diary, allowing harry to destroy it

  • Nicky Mouse
    Nicky Mouse Month ago +1

    That and he would make quite hurt in the Weasley reputation as a bonus.

  • Matthew Buehler
    Matthew Buehler Month ago

    We all know why lucius was the worst Death Eater... nobody can pull of hair like that.